Class 9 English Chapter 5: The World of Limitless Possibilities

The World of Limitless Possibilities is Chapter 5 of NCERT / CBSE Class 9 English. This page has the complete chapter notes across 3 topics , 76 practice MCQs with answers and explanations , 27 important short and long questions and 64 flashcards — all written to the NCERT / CBSE syllabus and free to read.

The Interview, and Dr. Deepa Malik's Story

A chapter that opens as an introduction and then becomes an interview. This topic works through the facts it establishes — the diagnosis at twenty-nine, the two choices, the Rio silver, the list of firsts — and through what Dr. Malik says about challenge, advocacy and the phrase that gives the chapter its title.

What you will be able to do

  • State what the Paralympics are, whom they are for, and what the chapter says they do beyond competition.
  • Give the facts of Dr. Malik's diagnosis, her choice and her breakthrough.
  • List her 'firsts' and the awards she has received.
  • Explain what she names as her greatest challenge, and how she met it.
  • Describe her advocacy work and the advice she closes on.

Key points

  • The Games honour toughness and remarkable skill in athletes whose bones, joints or muscles, senses or intellect work differently, and set out to put down fixed ideas and widen what is thought possible.

  • Bharat's debut in the Paralympics was in 1968, and the first medal was won in swimming in 1972.

  • Dr. Deepa Malik is a Khel Ratna, Arjuna and Padma Shri awardee, listed by the International Paralympic Committee among the ten most inspirational women para-athletes globally.

  • At twenty-nine she was diagnosed with a spine tumour; after surgery she was told she would be bound to a wheelchair, paralysed waist down.

  • She describes two choices: to squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities.

  • She had loved sports and had been a swimmer, so the switch to para-athletics came comfortably; her breakthrough was the silver in the shot-put at Rio 2016.

  • Her greatest challenge was societal perception rather than anything physical, and meeting it required mental resilience as much as strength.

  • Her advocacy covers emotional health, empowering women through outdoor sports, support for those from lower socio-economic strata, and awareness sessions in schools and colleges.

Full explanation

How the Chapter Is Built

It opens by addressing the reader directly, asking what happens when athletes defy the odds and show their skills on a global stage — and then answering.

The Paralympic Games are a celebration of resilience and of the extraordinary talent of athletes with locomotor, sensory or intellectual disabilities. And they go beyond competition: they exist, the chapter says, to quell stereotypes and redefine possibilities.

The word quell is worth pausing on. It means to overcome, and it is normally used of riots. Stereotypes, on this account, are not to be reasoned with but put down.

Bharat's record

  • Debut: 1968.
  • First medal: 1972, in swimming.

Since then many Indian Paralympians have brought honour to the country — and one of them is the subject of what follows.

The subject

Dr. Deepa Malik, a Khel Ratna, Arjuna and Padma Shri awardee, who has left an indelible mark on countless aspiring athletes.

And from there the chapter changes form. It becomes an interview.

The Turning Point

The interviewer's first real question is about how she braved the odds. Her answer is the centre of the chapter.

At twenty-nine, she was diagnosed with a spine tumour. She underwent surgery — and then, she says, misfortune raised its ugly head again. The doctors declared she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life, paralysed waist down.

Two choices

She had two: to squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities.

That second phrase is the chapter's title. It is hers, not the book's — she said it of her own decision, and the chapter took it.

Why sport, and why so quickly

She loved sports, and had been a swimmer. So switching to para-athletics was not a leap into something unfamiliar; the discipline was already hers. That is the whole answer to the exercise's question about why the change came comfortably.

The breakthrough

The 2016 Rio Paralympic Games — silver in the shot-put.

In hindsight, she says, it was both a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things.

The List of Firsts

The interviewer calls her a trailblazer, and the list is not short:

  • the first Indian woman para-athlete to take an Asian Games medal on the track and field;
  • India's first female Paralympics medallist across any sport.

And the list of firsts, the interviewer says, is never ending. She has also been given several coveted awards.

What they mean to her

She appreciates the accolades. But she describes them as something other than prizes:

They are a testimony to her belief that physical limitations do not define one's potential.

A testimony is evidence. Placed that way, the medals are not the point; they are proof of a claim she was making anyway.

And she names the school of thought she is a proponent of: 'ability beyond disability'.

The Challenge

Asked about the challenges she faced, she does not begin with her body.

One of the significant challenges was societal perception. People often underestimated her abilities.

Overcoming that required not only physical strength but mental resilience. She embraced challenges as opportunities to prove her capabilities, and the support of her family together with her own fortitude allowed her to turn obstacles into stepping stones.

Sport against stereotype

Asked how the Paralympics can challenge stereotypes, her answer is about witnessing:

When people see the strength, the skill and the competitive spirit of para-athletes, it breaks down preconceived notions. Argument does not do this; watching does.

And for her personally, the Paralympics have given a new lease of life and helped her push boundaries. They made her what she is, and made her realise that individuals with disabilities can be as capable as their able-bodied counterparts — if not more.

Advocacy

Advocacy, she says, is integral to her mission. It has four strands:

Strand What it addresses
Emotional health of persons with challenges The inner cost, not the visible one
Empowering women through outdoor sports and adventure Two barriers at once
Support for those from lower socio-economic strata, including equipment for para sportspersons A practical obstacle, not an attitudinal one
Awareness and advocacy sessions in schools and colleges Because youth is the voice of tomorrow

Her goal, stated plainly: a society in which every person, whatever they can or cannot do, is treated with dignity and given a fair run at success.

Why schools

This is worth thinking about rather than memorising. Changing a policy changes what is allowed. Changing what a sixteen-year-old assumes changes what is expected — and expectation outlasts policy.

The Last Word

Asked what advice she has for people facing setbacks, she gives three things and then a sentence.

  • Take every reverse as a chance to show what you are made of.
  • Keep people around you who will hold you up, and believe in yourself.
  • Let your journey inspire others.

And then:

Disability is not a limitation; it is a unique strength waiting to be unleashed.

That is the chapter's thesis, and it is placed last rather than first — so that by the time the reader meets it, the whole interview stands behind it as evidence.

Concepts and terms

Resilience

The ability to recover quickly from difficult circumstances. It is the first quality the chapter attaches to the Paralympics, and the one Dr. Malik keeps returning to — including in its mental form.

Locomotor

Related to bones, joints or muscles. The chapter names three kinds of disability among Paralympic athletes: locomotor, sensory and intellectual.

Quell

To overcome. The chapter uses it of stereotypes, which is a deliberate choice — stereotypes are treated as something to be put down rather than argued with.

Fortitude

Strength to face adversity or difficulty. Dr. Malik pairs it with her family's support as the two things that let her turn obstacles into stepping stones.

Proponent

Somebody who argues publicly for a given idea or course of action. She calls herself a proponent of the school of thought 'ability beyond disability'.

What Students Get Wrong

Did you know

The chapter's opening question is addressed to the reader, not to Dr. Malik — the interview does not begin until the second page.

She calls her accolades a testimony rather than a reward, which places them as evidence for a claim rather than as a prize.

Her advocacy includes providing equipment to para sportspersons from lower socio-economic backgrounds — a practical barrier rather than an attitudinal one.

Memory tricks

The two choices — Squander, or transform. — Remorse on one side; a world of limitless possibilities on the other.

Bharat's Paralympic dates — Debut sixty-eight, medal seventy-two. — Four years between the first appearance and the first medal, which came in swimming.

Her three awards — Khel Ratna, Arjuna, Padma Shri. — Named in the introduction, before the interview begins.

Practice MCQs with answers (24)

Q1 Assertion (A): The verb quell tells the reader how the chapter regards stereotypes. Reason (R): Quell is a mild word normally used of settling a disagreement politely. advanced
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is true but R is false
Why:

It is the word used of putting down riots, which is the point being made. The assertion stands, the reason is false.

Q2 Which three kinds of disability does the chapter name among Paralympic athletes? intermediate
  • A Locomotor, visual and congenital
  • B Sensory, intellectual and temporary
  • C Locomotor, sensory and intellectual
  • D Physical, emotional and intellectual
Show answer
Answer: Locomotor, sensory and intellectual
Why:

Locomotor covers bones, joints and muscles.

Q3 Which pair of dates opens Bharat's Paralympic record? intermediate
  • A Debut in 1960, first medal in 1968
  • B Debut in 1972, first medal in 1976
  • C Debut in 1968, first medal in 1972
  • D Debut in 1948, first medal in 1960
Show answer
Answer: Debut in 1968, first medal in 1972
Why:

The first medal was won in swimming.

Q4 A student says the Paralympics are simply a separate competition for disabled athletes. Which part of the chapter's own description does that reading leave out? advanced
  • A That they exist to quell stereotypes and redefine possibilities, beyond competition
  • B That they are held every four years in a fixed location
  • C That they are open only to athletes from a single continent
  • D That they award more medals than any other event
Show answer
Answer: That they exist to quell stereotypes and redefine possibilities, beyond competition
Why:

The chapter is explicit that the purpose goes past the contest itself.

Q5 At what age was Dr. Malik diagnosed, and with what? intermediate
  • A Thirty-nine, with a spine tumour
  • B Twenty-nine, with a muscular condition
  • C Twenty-nine, with a spine tumour
  • D Nineteen, with a spinal injury
Show answer
Answer: Twenty-nine, with a spine tumour
Why:

The surgery followed, and then the declaration about the wheelchair.

Q6 A reader asks what the doctors told her after the operation. What did they say? advanced
  • A That she would recover fully within two years
  • B That she would be bound to a wheelchair for life, paralysed waist down
  • C That she would be able to walk with support
  • D That further surgery might restore movement
Show answer
Answer: That she would be bound to a wheelchair for life, paralysed waist down
Why:

Misfortune, as she puts it, raised its ugly head again.

Q7 Which pair of options does she say she faced at that point? intermediate
  • A Return to swimming, or give up sport altogether
  • B Accept medical advice, or seek a second opinion
  • C Squander her life in remorse, or transform it into a world of limitless possibilities
  • D Move to a different city, or remain where she was
Show answer
Answer: Squander her life in remorse, or transform it into a world of limitless possibilities
Why:

The second phrase became the chapter's title.

Q8 Whose words gave the chapter its title? advanced
  • A The interviewer's, in the closing exchange
  • B Dr. Malik's own, about the choice she faced at twenty-nine
  • C The International Paralympic Committee's citation
  • D A slogan of the Paralympic movement
Show answer
Answer: Dr. Malik's own, about the choice she faced at twenty-nine
Why:

The possibilities are hers first and everyone's afterwards.

Q9 Why did the move to para-athletics come comfortably to her? advanced
  • A She had trained as a coach before her illness
  • B Her family had all been athletes
  • C She already loved sports and had been a swimmer
  • D The rules of para-athletics were simpler than those of swimming
Show answer
Answer: She already loved sports and had been a swimmer
Why:

Only the form of the discipline changed, not the discipline itself.

Q10 What exactly did Dr. Malik win at Rio in 2016? intermediate
  • A Gold in the shot-put
  • B Silver in swimming
  • C Bronze in the javelin
  • D Silver in the shot-put
Show answer
Answer: Silver in the shot-put
Why:

And it was nonetheless a first for an Indian woman.

Q11 How does she describe that medal, looking back? advanced
  • A As the end of a long struggle and the start of retirement
  • B As a disappointment, since she had aimed at gold
  • C As a result of luck rather than of training
  • D As a personal victory and a step forward in changing perceptions
Show answer
Answer: As a personal victory and a step forward in changing perceptions
Why:

Two things at once, one private and one public.

Q12 Which of these is NOT one of the 'firsts' the interviewer names? advanced
  • A First Indian woman para-athlete to take an athletics medal at the Asian Games
  • B First Indian to compete in a Paralympic Games
  • C India's first female Paralympics medallist across any sport
  • D One of the ten most inspirational women para-athletes globally
Show answer
Answer: First Indian to compete in a Paralympic Games
Why:

Bharat had been competing since 1968, long before her.

Q13 Dr. Malik uses an unusual word for what her awards represent. Which, and why does it matter? advanced
  • A A reward — which makes them payment for effort
  • B A tribute — which makes them honours paid by others
  • C A testimony — which makes them evidence for a belief rather than a prize
  • D A consolation — which makes them compensation for loss
Show answer
Answer: A testimony — which makes them evidence for a belief rather than a prize
Why:

The belief being that physical limitations do not define potential.

Q14 What school of thought does she describe herself as a proponent of? intermediate
  • A Strength before sympathy
  • B Sport for all abilities
  • C Nothing about us without us
  • D Ability beyond disability
Show answer
Answer: Ability beyond disability
Why:

A proponent is somebody who speaks in support of an idea.

Q15 Asked about her challenges, what does she name first? advanced
  • A The physical pain that followed her surgery
  • B Societal perception, because people underestimated her abilities
  • C The cost of equipment and travel
  • D The shortage of coaches for para-athletes
Show answer
Answer: Societal perception, because people underestimated her abilities
Why:

Which is why mental resilience mattered as much as physical strength.

Q16 What two things does she credit with letting her turn obstacles into stepping stones? advanced
  • A Her medical team, and her coaches
  • B Government funding, and media attention
  • C Her earlier swimming career, and good fortune
  • D The support of her family, and her own fortitude
Show answer
Answer: The support of her family, and her own fortitude
Why:

One from outside her and one from within.

Q17 According to Dr. Malik, what makes sport effective at changing attitudes towards disability? advanced
  • A Athletes are given a platform to explain their experiences in words
  • B People witness strength, skill and competitive spirit, and preconceived notions break down
  • C Governments are obliged to fund accessible facilities
  • D Medals attract media coverage that no campaign could buy
Show answer
Answer: People witness strength, skill and competitive spirit, and preconceived notions break down
Why:

Watching does what arguing cannot.

Q18 Consider these statements about Dr. Malik's advocacy. 1. It includes providing equipment to para sportspersons. 2. It includes sessions in schools and colleges. 3. It is confined to athletes who have already competed internationally. Which of the statements are correct? advanced
  • A 1 and 2 only
  • B 1 and 3 only
  • C 2 and 3 only
  • D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: 1 and 2 only
Why:

She works with persons from lower socio-economic strata and with schoolchildren.

Q19 Which strand of her advocacy addresses a practical barrier rather than an attitudinal one? advanced
  • A Running awareness sessions in schools and colleges
  • B Strengthening emotional health among persons with challenges
  • C Speaking publicly about inclusivity and accessibility
  • D Providing equipment to para sportspersons from lower socio-economic strata
Show answer
Answer: Providing equipment to para sportspersons from lower socio-economic strata
Why:

Equipment is a cost, not a prejudice.

Q20 Why, in her own terms, does she work with the young? intermediate
  • A Because schools are easier to reach than workplaces
  • B Because young athletes recover faster from injury
  • C Because the government requires such sessions
  • D Because youth is the voice of tomorrow
Show answer
Answer: Because youth is the voice of tomorrow
Why:

The slowest form of advocacy, and the most permanent.

Q21 What does Dr. Malik state as her goal? advanced
  • A A country in which ability makes no difference to how somebody is treated or to the chances they get
  • B A separate sporting structure for athletes with disabilities
  • C Increased medal counts for India at future Paralympics
  • D Legislation requiring accessible facilities in every school
Show answer
Answer: A country in which ability makes no difference to how somebody is treated or to the chances they get
Why:

Dignity, and a fair chance to succeed.

Q22 Which sentence closes the interview, and where is it placed in the chapter's argument? advanced
  • A That disability is a unique strength waiting to be unleashed — placed last, so the whole interview stands behind it
  • B That disability is a unique strength — placed first, as a heading for what follows
  • C That sport is the only route out of prejudice — placed in the middle of the interview
  • D That accolades matter less than effort — placed as the answer to the first question
Show answer
Answer: That disability is a unique strength waiting to be unleashed — placed last, so the whole interview stands behind it
Why:

A thesis stated after its evidence rather than before it.

Q23 Which definition matches the word the chapter glosses as 'strength to face adversity or difficulty'? intermediate
  • A Resilience
  • B Fortitude
  • C Fervour
  • D Fortune
Show answer
Answer: Fortitude
Why:

Resilience is recovering quickly, which is a related but distinct idea.

Q24 Which of these does the chapter NOT say about Dr. Malik? advanced
  • A That she competed in swimming at the Paralympics
  • B That she had been a swimmer before her illness
  • C That she won silver in the shot-put at Rio
  • D That she was a member of a working group on a Five Year Plan
Show answer
Answer: That she competed in swimming at the Paralympics
Why:

She switched to para-athletics; her Paralympic medal came in shot-put.

Important short questions (6)

What are the Paralympic Games, and what does the chapter say they do beyond competition?

They are a celebration of resilience and of the extraordinary talent of athletes with locomotor, sensory or intellectual disabilities. Beyond the competition itself, the chapter says they exist to quell stereotypes and to redefine possibilities. The choice of verb is pointed: quell is normally used of riots, so a stereotype is presented as something to be put down rather than debated.

Describe the turning point in Dr. Malik's life and the choice she made.

At twenty-nine she was diagnosed with a spine tumour. She underwent surgery, and the doctors then declared that she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life, paralysed waist down. She says she had two choices: to squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities. She chose the second, and that phrase became the title of the chapter.

How did her Paralympic career begin, and what was her breakthrough?

She had always loved sports and had been a swimmer, so switching to para-athletics came comfortably — the discipline was already hers and only its form changed. Her breakthrough came at the 2016 Rio Paralympic Games, where she secured the silver medal in the shot-put. Looking back, she calls it both a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things.

Why does Dr. Malik call her awards a testimony rather than simply appreciating them as prizes?

Because a testimony is evidence for something. She holds that physical limitations do not define a person's potential, and she treats the accolades as proof of that claim rather than as the point of her career. Placed that way, the medals are not what she was after; they are what makes the argument impossible to dismiss. It is consistent with her calling herself a proponent of ability beyond disability.

What does she name as her greatest challenge, and how did she meet it?

Societal perception. People often underestimated her abilities, and that is a difficulty no amount of training removes, so overcoming it required mental resilience as well as physical strength. She says she embraced challenges as opportunities to prove her capabilities, and that the support of her family together with her own fortitude allowed her to turn obstacles into stepping stones.

Set out Dr. Malik's advocacy work and her reason for concentrating on the young.

She works to strengthen the emotional health of persons with challenges, to empower women through outdoor sports and adventure activities, and to support persons from lower socio-economic strata, including by providing equipment to para sportspersons. She also organises disability sports awareness and advocacy sessions at schools and colleges, because youth is the voice of tomorrow. Her goal is a society in which every person, whatever they can or cannot do, is treated with dignity and given a fair run at success.

Long answer questions (3)

Give an account of Dr. Deepa Malik's journey as the interview presents it, from the diagnosis to the medal.

She was twenty-nine when an awful tragedy struck: a tumour was found in her spine. She underwent surgery, and then, as she puts it, misfortune raised its ugly head again — the doctors declared that she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life, paralysed waist down.

What follows is the sentence the whole chapter rests on. She had two choices: to squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities. The second phrase is hers, and the book took it for its title.

The transition into sport was not a leap. She had always loved sports and had been a swimmer, so moving to para-athletics meant changing the form of a discipline she already had rather than acquiring a new one. That is the reason the switch came comfortably.

Her breakthrough came at the 2016 Rio Paralympic Games, where she took the silver medal in the shot-put. In hindsight, she says, it was two things at once: a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things.

By then the list of firsts had begun. She was the first Indian woman para-athlete to take an Asian Games medal on the track and field, and India's first female Paralympics medallist across any sport, and the interviewer says the list is never ending. She has also been given several coveted awards — the Khel Ratna, the Arjuna and the Padma Shri — and has been listed by the International Paralympic Committee among the ten most inspirational women para-athletes in the world.

And she appreciates all of it while refusing to treat it as the point. The accolades, she says, are a testimony to her belief that physical limitations do not define one's potential.

Dr. Malik says her biggest challenge was societal perception. Explain what she means and how the chapter supports the claim.

Asked about the challenges she faced, she does not begin with her body. The significant one, she says, was societal perception: people often underestimated her abilities.

The distinction matters. A physical difficulty can be worked at directly — with training, equipment or time. A perception held by other people is not hers to train away. That is why she says overcoming it required not only physical strength but mental resilience, and why she describes embracing challenges as opportunities to prove her capabilities rather than merely to overcome them. Proving is a public act; it is aimed at an audience.

The chapter then supplies the mechanism by which such perceptions shift. Asked how the Paralympics can challenge stereotypes, she answers in terms of witnessing: when people see the strength, the skill and the competitive spirit of para-athletes, it breaks down preconceived notions. Nobody is argued out of an assumption here; they are shown something that the assumption cannot accommodate.

Her own record works the same way. She does not call her medals rewards but a testimony to her belief that physical limitations do not define potential — evidence produced for a public that needed convincing.

And her advocacy follows from the diagnosis of the problem. If the barrier is what people assume, then the work is to change assumptions: awareness sessions in schools and colleges, because youth is the voice of tomorrow; visibility for women through outdoor sports; a goal stated as dignity and a fair chance rather than as facilities or funding.

Two things she names lie outside all this and are worth noting: her family's support, and her own fortitude. Perception is changed in public, but it is endured in private.

Justify the title of this chapter with reference to Dr. Malik's attitude and achievements.

The title is not the book's phrase but hers. Describing the moment after her surgery she says she had two choices: to squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities. The chapter simply took her words for its name, which means the possibilities belong to her first and to the reader afterwards.

It fits her attitude exactly. She does not describe her situation as something endured but as something chosen, and every answer she gives keeps that shape. Challenges are embraced as opportunities to prove her capabilities. Obstacles are turned into stepping stones. A setback, she says at the end, is an opportunity to prove your strength. There is no sentence anywhere in the interview in which she is acted upon without acting back.

It fits the achievements even more plainly, because a list of firsts is a record of things previously assumed impossible. She was the first Indian woman para-athlete to take an Asian Games medal on the track and field, and India's first female Paralympics medallist in any sport. Each of those was a limit until she passed it, and the interviewer says the list of firsts has no end — which is the title stated as a fact rather than as a hope.

And the title covers her advocacy too. Providing equipment, running sessions in schools, empowering women through outdoor sports: all of it works to make the same range of possibility available to people who have not had it.

Her closing sentence completes the case. Disability, she says, is not a limitation; it is a unique strength waiting to be unleashed. A limitation closes a world. A strength not yet unleashed is precisely a world of limitless possibilities — so the title is her argument compressed into five words.

Flashcards (20)

What are the Paralympic Games, according to the chapter, and whom are they for?
A contest that sets out to honour toughness and remarkable skill in athletes whose bones, joints or muscles, senses or intellect work differently. And it is not only a contest: it aims to put down fixed ideas and to widen what people think possible.
Give the two dates that open Bharat's Paralympic record.
The debut in 1968, and the first medal in 1972, won in swimming.
Which three awards are named for Dr. Deepa Malik in the introduction?
The Khel Ratna, the Arjuna and the Padma Shri. She is also listed by the International Paralympic Committee among the ten most inspirational women para-athletes globally.
What happened to Dr. Malik at twenty-nine?
She was diagnosed with a spine tumour. She underwent surgery, and the doctors then declared that she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life, paralysed waist down.
What were the two choices she describes, and which gives the chapter its title?
To squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities. The second is the chapter's title — her phrase, taken by the book.
Why was the switch to para-athletics comfortable for her?
Because she already loved sports and had been a swimmer, so the discipline was not new to her. Only the form of it changed.
What was her breakthrough moment, and what did she win?
The 2016 Rio Paralympic Games, where she secured the silver medal in the shot-put event. In hindsight she calls it both a personal victory and a step forward in changing perceptions.
Give the two 'firsts' the interviewer names.
She is the first Indian woman para-athlete to take an Asian Games medal on the track and field, and India's first female Paralympics medallist across any sport.
How does Dr. Malik describe what her accolades mean to her?
She appreciates them, but calls them a testimony to her belief that physical limitations do not define one's potential. A testimony is evidence, so the awards prove a claim she was already making rather than being the point in themselves.
What school of thought does she call herself a proponent of?
Ability beyond disability.
What does she name as her most significant challenge, and why was it hard?
Societal perception. People often underestimated her abilities, so overcoming it required not only physical strength but mental resilience.
What two things allowed her to turn obstacles into stepping stones?
The support of her family, coupled with her own fortitude — the strength to face adversity.
How does she say sport challenges stereotypes?
Through witnessing. When people see the strength, skill and competitive spirit of para-athletes, preconceived notions break down. Argument does not achieve this; watching does.
What has the Paralympics done for her personally?
Given her a new lease of life and helped her push boundaries. It made her what she is, and made her realise that individuals with disabilities can be as capable as their able-bodied counterparts, if not more.
Name the four strands of Dr. Malik's advocacy work.
Strengthening the emotional health of persons with challenges; empowering women through outdoor sports and adventure activities; supporting persons from lower socio-economic strata, including providing equipment to para sportspersons; and organising disability sports awareness and advocacy sessions in schools and colleges.
Why does she work with schools and colleges?
Because youth is the voice of tomorrow. Changing a policy changes what is allowed, but changing what a young person assumes changes what is expected — and expectation outlasts policy.
What is Dr. Malik's stated goal?
To help build a country in which nobody is valued differently for what their body can do, and in which the chance to succeed is handed out on the same terms to everybody.
What three pieces of advice does she offer people facing setbacks?
That every setback is an opportunity to prove your strength; that you should surround yourself with a support system and believe in yourself; and that you should let your journey inspire others.
Give the chapter's closing thesis in her own terms.
Disability is not a limitation; it is a unique strength waiting to be unleashed.
Define resilience, locomotor and quell as the chapter glosses them.
Resilience is bouncing back quickly after something hard. Locomotor concerns the bones, the joints and the muscles. And to quell something is to put it down or get the better of it.

Play this topic

  • Match the Word to Its Meaning
  • True or False: The Interview
  • Complete the Statement
  • Unscramble the Words of the Lesson

Reading the Interview Closely

Two reading skills the lesson builds — telling a fact from an opinion, and a cause from an effect — then the two Critical Reflection extracts worked through in full, and the larger questions the chapter asks at the end.

What you will be able to do

  • Distinguish a fact from an opinion, and give the test that separates them.
  • Distinguish a cause from an effect, and apply it to the lesson's pairs.
  • Answer the first extract, on the two choices and the breakthrough moment.
  • Answer the second extract, on tone, analogy and the phrases that mark transformation.
  • Explain what the chapter argues about perception, advocacy and its own title.

Key points

  • A fact is evidence or factual information that can be proved true; an opinion is the writer's belief or perception.

  • The worked pair: securing silver at Rio is a fact, while feeling it was a personal victory is an opinion.

  • A cause is the action or event; an effect is the outcome. The diagnosis is the cause, the surgery and its verdict the effect.

  • Of the two practice pairs, the one about the Five Year Plan working group is fact and opinion, and the one about showcasing talent is cause and effect.

  • The caterpillar comparison works because both are complete transformations from confinement into freedom, not repairs of what went before.

  • The switch to para-athletics was comfortable because she already loved sports and had been a swimmer.

  • 'In hindsight' shows the speaker is reflective; the tone of the second extract is appreciative and optimistic.

  • In the analogy, ability is to potential as preconceived notions are to stereotypes.

Full explanation

Fact and Opinion

The lesson gives both definitions plainly.

Definition
Fact Evidence or factual information that can be proved to be true
Opinion The writer's belief or perception

Knowing the difference, it says, helps us understand a text better — and in an interview it is essential, because the record of a life and the meaning somebody attaches to it sit in adjacent sentences.

The worked pair

  • At the 2016 Rio Games I secured the silver medal in the shot-put. — Fact.
  • For her it was a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things. — Opinion.

The test

Look at the verb.

Secured describes something that happened and that a record can confirm. I feel announces that what follows is a perception.

The trap. The second sentence is perfectly true — she really does feel that. But an accurate report of a belief is a fact about the speaker, not about the event. The question asks about the event.

Cause and Effect

Definition
Cause The action or event
Effect The outcome

Understanding this relationship, the lesson says, is helpful for deeper analysis of a text.

The worked pair

  • I was diagnosed with a tumour in my spine. — Cause.
  • I had surgery and was told I would be bound to a wheelchair. — Effect.

The test

Ask which sentence could stand alone. A diagnosis makes sense by itself; surgery and a verdict about a wheelchair need the diagnosis behind them to mean anything.

The Two Practice Pairs

These are deliberately mixed, so that neither can be answered by pattern.

Pair (i) — fact and opinion

  • She was a member of the Working Group for the Formulation of the Twelfth Five Year Plan of 2012–17.
  • She is held to have done a great deal for creating better sports policies for persons with disabilities.

Membership is a matter of record. The second sentence announces itself with it is believed, which is the giveaway: a belief is being reported rather than a result.

Pair (ii) — cause and effect

  • The Paralympics showcase sheer talent and resolve of para-athletes.
  • The way the world regards disability moves, and para-athletes are encouraged to go after what they want.

Here the second follows from the first. Showing is the cause; the shift in perception is the outcome.

Critical Reflection, Extract 1

The two choices, and the journey into para-athletics.

The caterpillar comparison

The question asks why her decision can be likened to a caterpillar becoming a butterfly.

Because both are complete transformations from confinement into freedom. What emerges is not a repaired version of what went in; it is something different in kind, and it can do what the earlier form could not. Her life after the surgery is not her old life restored but a new one, and she describes it in exactly those terms.

Why the switch was comfortable

Because she already loved sports and had been a swimmer. The discipline was hers already; only its form changed.

Why Rio 2016 is a 'breakthrough moment'

Because it was her first Paralympic medal, and the first by an Indian woman in any sport — so it broke through for her career and for the country's record at once.

'In hindsight'

Of the four options — curious, reflective, determined, courageous — the answer is reflective.

The phrase means understanding something after it has happened. She is determined and courageous too, plainly, but not on the evidence of that phrase.

A perception she might have changed

Any reasonable answer is accepted, provided it names a belief the medal contradicts. For example: that a woman using a wheelchair could not represent her country in an international throwing event.

Critical Reflection, Extract 2

Sport, stereotype, and a new lease of life.

The tone

Five words are offered: appreciative, moralistic, sentimental, optimistic, defensive. The answer is A and D — appreciative and optimistic.

  • Not moralistic: she describes what sport does, and instructs nobody to be better.
  • Not sentimental: there is no appeal to pity anywhere in the extract.
  • Not defensive: she is not answering an accusation.

The analogy

ability : potential :: preconceived notions : stereotypes

In each pair the second word is the wider term for the first — potential is the general idea behind a particular ability, and stereotypes are the general form that particular preconceived notions take.

True or false

The Paralympics does more than put the abilities of para-athletes on display: it puts the stereotypes in question too. — True. The extract says both things in a single sentence.

'Helped me push boundaries'

It tells us she did not settle for what was expected of her, and kept enlarging what she attempted. A boundary is a limit somebody else has drawn; pushing it is a continuing activity rather than a single achievement.

The phrase that marks transformation

'A new lease of life.' It is the one phrase in the extract that names a change of state rather than a change of circumstance.

The Larger Questions

The lesson closes with questions that cannot be answered from a single sentence.

How her achievements challenge perceptions

By producing counter-examples that an assumption cannot absorb. Every first on her list was an impossibility until it happened — and after it, the impossibility has to be rewritten rather than restated.

The long-term impact of youth advocacy

Changing a policy changes what is allowed. Changing what a sixteen-year-old assumes changes what is expected, in every situation no policy covers. The second is slower and far more durable, and it compounds: today's students are tomorrow's employers, teachers and coaches.

Why the title fits

It is her own phrase for the choice she made at twenty-nine, and the chapter took it for everybody. Her closing sentence restates it: disability is not a limitation but a unique strength waiting to be unleashed — which is a world of possibilities described from the other side.

'Every setback is an opportunity to prove your strength'

It is not only for sportspeople, because a setback is a piece of information about a situation rather than a verdict on a person. What makes the sentence useful to anybody is the word prove: strength that has never been tested is only assumed, and a setback is the first occasion on which it becomes visible.

Concepts and terms

Fact

Evidence or factual information that can be proved true. Knowing which sentences are facts is what lets a reader tell the record of a life from the meaning somebody attaches to it.

Opinion

The writer's belief or perception. An opinion may be reported accurately and still not be a fact about the event — an accurate report of a belief is a fact about the speaker, not about the world.

Cause

The action or event that brings something about. In the worked pair it is the diagnosis of a tumour in the spine.

Effect

The outcome that follows. In the worked pair it is the surgery and the verdict about the wheelchair — and understanding this relationship is what the lesson calls deeper analysis.

Analogy

A comparison drawn between two pairs that stand in the same relation. Here ability is to potential as preconceived notions are to stereotypes: in each pair, the second is the wider word for the first.

What Students Get Wrong

Did you know

The two practice pairs are deliberately mixed: one is fact and opinion and the other cause and effect, so neither can be answered by pattern.

The word 'believed' in the Five Year Plan pair is the single word that settles it — a belief is being reported, not a result.

One of the questions asks for a perception she might have changed, which has no single right answer and is marked on the reasoning.

Memory tricks

Fact or opinion — Check the verb. — Secured can be verified. I feel cannot, and was never meant to be.

Cause or effect — Which one could stand alone? — An effect needs its cause to make sense; a cause does not need its effect.

The second extract's tone — Appreciative and optimistic. — Not moralistic, not sentimental, not defensive — three options the exercise offers to catch you.

Practice MCQs with answers (24)

Q1 A student marks a sentence as factual because they are confident the speaker genuinely believes it. What is wrong with that reasoning? advanced
  • A Beliefs can never be reported truthfully in an interview
  • B A true report of a belief is a fact about the speaker, not about the event described
  • C A sentence about feelings cannot appear in a factual text
  • D Nothing — sincerity is the correct test for a fact
Show answer
Answer: A true report of a belief is a fact about the speaker, not about the event described
Why:

The test is whether the thing described can be proved, not whether the sentence is honest.

Q2 Two adjacent sentences report a medal won and a feeling about it. Which test separates them fastest? advanced
  • A Look at the length — opinions are always longer
  • B Look at the verb — one describes an event, the other announces a perception
  • C Look at the position — facts always come second
  • D Look at the punctuation — opinions take exclamation marks
Show answer
Answer: Look at the verb — one describes an event, the other announces a perception
Why:

Secured can be checked against a record; I feel cannot.

Q3 Which sentence would the lesson classify as an opinion? intermediate
  • A She secured the silver medal in the shot-put at Rio in 2016
  • B That the medal felt to her like a private triumph and a move towards altering what people believed
  • C She was diagnosed with a tumour in her spine
  • D She was listed by the International Paralympic Committee among ten athletes
Show answer
Answer: That the medal felt to her like a private triumph and a move towards altering what people believed
Why:

The other three can all be confirmed from a record.

Q4 How does the lesson define cause and effect? intermediate
  • A Cause is what is stated first; effect is what is stated second
  • B Cause is the writer's belief; effect is the reader's response
  • C Cause is the longer sentence; effect is the shorter one
  • D Cause is the action or event; effect is the outcome
Show answer
Answer: Cause is the action or event; effect is the outcome
Why:

Understanding the relationship is what the lesson calls deeper analysis.

Q5 In the worked cause-and-effect pair, which is the cause? intermediate
  • A Being diagnosed with a tumour in the spine
  • B Undergoing surgery
  • C Being told she would use a wheelchair for life
  • D Switching to para-athletics
Show answer
Answer: Being diagnosed with a tumour in the spine
Why:

The surgery and its verdict are both outcomes of the diagnosis.

Q6 Which question separates a cause from its effect most reliably? advanced
  • A Which of the two is stated in the past tense?
  • B Which of the two mentions a date?
  • C Which of the two could stand alone and still make sense?
  • D Which of the two is longer?
Show answer
Answer: Which of the two could stand alone and still make sense?
Why:

An effect needs its cause behind it; a cause does not need its effect.

Q7 Which single phrase settles the practice pair about the Five Year Plan working group? advanced
  • A Working Group
  • B sports policies
  • C persons with disabilities
  • D It is believed
Show answer
Answer: It is believed
Why:

It announces that a belief is being reported rather than a result.

Q8 Why are the two practice pairs deliberately mixed? advanced
  • A Because one of them has no correct answer
  • B Because both are examples of cause and effect
  • C So that neither can be answered by pattern
  • D To show that the two relationships are the same thing
Show answer
Answer: So that neither can be answered by pattern
Why:

One is fact and opinion and the other cause and effect.

Q9 Assertion (A): The pair about the Paralympics showcasing talent states two unrelated facts. Reason (R): The shift in global perception follows from what audiences are shown. advanced
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is false but R is true
Why:

The two are plainly linked as cause and effect, so the assertion is false. The reason describes that link correctly.

Q10 A student explains the caterpillar comparison by saying that both changes take a long time. What have they missed? advanced
  • A The likeness is about completeness — what emerges is different in kind, not repaired
  • B The likeness is about the season in which each occurs
  • C The likeness is about the help each receives from others
  • D The likeness is about the difficulty of the process
Show answer
Answer: The likeness is about completeness — what emerges is different in kind, not repaired
Why:

Her life afterwards is a new one, not her old one restored.

Q11 What does the caterpillar comparison have in common with her description of her own life? advanced
  • A Both take place gradually and without any assistance
  • B Both are described in the interview as painful
  • C Both move from confinement into freedom, and neither returns to its earlier form
  • D Both involve a period of complete rest
Show answer
Answer: Both move from confinement into freedom, and neither returns to its earlier form
Why:

And what emerges can do what the earlier form could not.

Q12 Which fact explains why the change to para-athletics gave her no difficulty? intermediate
  • A Para-athletics requires less training than swimming
  • B She had coached athletes before her illness
  • C She already loved sports and had been a swimmer
  • D Her doctors had recommended athletics specifically
Show answer
Answer: She already loved sports and had been a swimmer
Why:

Only the form of the discipline changed.

Q13 In what two senses was the Rio medal a breakthrough? advanced
  • A It was her first medal and her last international appearance
  • B It was her first Paralympic medal and the first won by an Indian woman in any sport
  • C It was the first Indian medal in athletics and the first in swimming
  • D It was her first medal and the first ever won by Bharat at the Paralympics
Show answer
Answer: It was her first Paralympic medal and the first won by an Indian woman in any sport
Why:

For her career and for the country's record at once.

Q14 The exercise asks what 'in hindsight' indicates about the speaker. Which option is correct? intermediate
  • A Curious
  • B Determined
  • C Courageous
  • D Reflective
Show answer
Answer: Reflective
Why:

The phrase concerns understanding something after it has happened.

Q15 Why is 'determined' a wrong answer to that question even though she clearly is determined? advanced
  • A The question asks what the phrase indicates, not what she is like
  • B She is never described as determined anywhere in the chapter
  • C Determination is not one of the offered options
  • D The phrase occurs in the interviewer's speech rather than hers
Show answer
Answer: The question asks what the phrase indicates, not what she is like
Why:

Read the phrase, not the person.

Q16 Which combination of tone words does the exercise treat as correct for the second extract? advanced
  • A Moralistic, optimistic and defensive
  • B Moralistic and sentimental
  • C Appreciative, sentimental and defensive
  • D Appreciative and optimistic
Show answer
Answer: Appreciative and optimistic
Why:

A combination is wanted, so one correct word alone is not enough.

Q17 Why is 'moralistic' the wrong description of that extract's tone? advanced
  • A She describes what sport does, and instructs nobody to be better
  • B She avoids the subject of attitudes entirely
  • C She quotes other people rather than speaking herself
  • D She limits herself to statistics about the Paralympics
Show answer
Answer: She describes what sport does, and instructs nobody to be better
Why:

There is no instruction anywhere in the extract.

Q18 Which word completes the analogy 'ability : potential :: preconceived notions : ___'? intermediate
  • A Attitudes
  • B Stereotypes
  • C Obstacles
  • D Perceptions
Show answer
Answer: Stereotypes
Why:

In each pair the second word is the wider term for the first.

Q19 Consider these statements about the second extract. 1. It claims that watching para-athletes breaks down preconceived notions. 2. It says the Paralympics gave the speaker a new lease of life. 3. It argues that attitudes cannot be changed by sport alone. Which of the statements are correct? advanced
  • A 1 and 2 only
  • B 1 and 3 only
  • C 2 and 3 only
  • D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: 1 and 2 only
Why:

The extract makes no claim about the limits of what sport can do.

Q20 What does the phrase about pushing boundaries reveal about the speaker? advanced
  • A She preferred individual events to team ones
  • B She did not settle for what was expected of her, and kept enlarging what she attempted
  • C She found international competition physically easier than she had feared
  • D She trained beyond the hours her coaches prescribed
Show answer
Answer: She did not settle for what was expected of her, and kept enlarging what she attempted
Why:

A boundary is a limit somebody else has drawn.

Q21 Which phrase from the second extract marks the transformation of her life? advanced
  • A Competitive spirit
  • B Preconceived notions
  • C Push boundaries
  • D A new lease of life
Show answer
Answer: A new lease of life
Why:

It is the only one naming a change of state rather than of circumstance.

Q22 How do a record of firsts change what people believe, on the chapter's account? advanced
  • A Each is publicised widely enough to make argument unnecessary
  • B Each brings funding that removes the original obstacle
  • C Each is a counter-example an assumption cannot absorb, so the assumption must be rewritten
  • D Each persuades officials to change the rules of competition
Show answer
Answer: Each is a counter-example an assumption cannot absorb, so the assumption must be rewritten
Why:

Which is why she calls her awards a testimony.

Q23 Why is advocacy aimed at students likely to outlast advocacy aimed at policy? advanced
  • A Students have more time to attend sessions than officials do
  • B Policies are reversed more often than they are made
  • C Policy changes what is allowed; assumptions change what is expected, everywhere no policy reaches
  • D Students are more sympathetic than adults to sporting causes
Show answer
Answer: Policy changes what is allowed; assumptions change what is expected, everywhere no policy reaches
Why:

And it compounds, since today's students become tomorrow's employers and coaches.

Q24 Which word makes the advice about setbacks useful to somebody who plays no sport at all? advanced
  • A Opportunity — every difficulty contains one
  • B Setback — the word applies to any interruption
  • C Strength — everybody possesses some
  • D Prove — strength that has never been tested is only assumed
Show answer
Answer: Prove — strength that has never been tested is only assumed
Why:

A setback is the first occasion on which strength becomes visible.

Important short questions (6)

Define fact and opinion, and show how the worked pair illustrates the difference.

A fact is evidence or factual information that can be proved to be true; an opinion is the writer's belief or perception. The worked pair puts them side by side. Securing the silver medal in the shot-put at Rio in 2016 is a fact, since a record can confirm it. Feeling that it was a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things is an opinion. The verb settles it: secured describes an event, while I feel announces a perception.

A student argues that because the speaker sincerely feels something, the sentence reporting it must be a fact. Correct the reasoning.

The sentence is indeed true, but truth is not the test. An accurate report of what somebody believes is a fact about the speaker, not about the event described. The question asks whether the thing described can be proved, and a feeling about a medal's significance cannot be checked in the way the medal itself can. Sincerity makes a sentence honest; it does not make the content verifiable.

Explain cause and effect using the lesson's worked pair, and give the test that identifies each.

A cause is the action or event and an effect is the outcome. In the worked pair the cause is being diagnosed with a tumour in the spine, and the effect is the surgery together with the news that she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life. The test is to ask which sentence could stand alone. A diagnosis makes sense by itself; surgery and a verdict about a wheelchair need the diagnosis behind them before they mean anything at all.

Why can the speaker's decision be compared to a caterpillar becoming a butterfly?

Because both are complete transformations out of confinement and into freedom. What emerges in each case is not a repaired version of what went in but something different in kind, capable of what the earlier form could not do. That is exactly how she describes her own situation: not her old life restored but a new one, deliberately chosen over spending the years in remorse. The comparison is about completeness, not about slowness or difficulty.

Work through the tone question on the second extract, saying why each wrong option fails.

The correct combination is appreciative and optimistic. Moralistic fails because she describes what sport does and instructs nobody to be better. Sentimental fails because there is no appeal to pity anywhere in the extract — she speaks of strength, skill and competitive spirit. Defensive fails because she is answering no accusation; the question invited her to explain, not to justify. Note that the exercise wants a combination, so choosing one correct word alone still loses the mark.

Why might advocacy directed at schools and colleges matter more in the long run than a change of policy?

Because the two work on different things. A policy determines what is permitted, and its reach ends where its wording ends. What a young person assumes determines what is expected, and expectation operates in every situation no policy covers — in a classroom, on a playing field, at a job interview years later. The effect is also cumulative, since today's students become tomorrow's employers, teachers and coaches, and carry their assumptions into those roles.

Long answer questions (3)

Set out the two reading skills this lesson teaches, with definitions, tests and all four pairs of sentences.

The first is telling a fact from an opinion. A fact is evidence or factual information that can be proved to be true; an opinion is the writer's belief or perception. The worked pair puts the two in adjacent sentences: securing the silver medal in the shot-put at Rio in 2016 is a fact, while feeling that it was a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things is an opinion. The test is the verb — secured describes an event a record can confirm, while I feel announces that a perception follows. The trap is to reason that because the second sentence is true it must be factual; an accurate report of a belief is a fact about the speaker, not about the event.

The second skill is telling a cause from an effect. A cause is the action or event and an effect is the outcome, and understanding the relationship is what the lesson calls deeper analysis. Its worked pair gives the diagnosis of a tumour in the spine as the cause, and the surgery together with the verdict about the wheelchair as the effect. The test here is to ask which sentence could stand alone: a diagnosis makes sense by itself, whereas surgery and a prognosis need it behind them.

The two practice pairs are then deliberately mixed. In the first, her membership of the Working Group for the Twelfth Five Year Plan is set against the statement that it is believed she contributed greatly to better sports policies. Membership is a matter of record and the phrase it is believed announces a belief, so this is fact and opinion. In the second, the Paralympics showcasing the talent and determination of para-athletes is set against the shift in global perception that inspires other athletes — and since the second follows from the first, this is cause and effect.

The mixing matters. Given two pairs of the same type a student could answer the second without reading it.

Answer the questions on the first Critical Reflection extract in full, explaining your reasoning at each point.

The extract covers the two choices she faced and the beginning of her Paralympic career.

Her decision can be likened to a caterpillar becoming a butterfly because both are complete transformations out of confinement and into freedom. What emerges is not a repaired version of what went in but something different in kind, able to do what the earlier form could not. She had been told she would spend her life in a wheelchair, and rather than treating that as a damaged version of her old life she built a different one. The comparison is about completeness, not about slowness.

She could switch to para-athletics comfortably because she already loved sports and had been a swimmer. The discipline, the training habit and the competitive instinct were all in place; only the form of the sport changed, so she was not starting from nothing.

She calls the 2016 Rio Games a breakthrough moment because it produced her first Paralympic medal and the first won by an Indian woman in any sport at all. It broke through for her own career and for the country's record simultaneously, which is more than any single medal usually does.

Of the four options offered for what in hindsight indicates, the answer is reflective. The phrase means understanding something only after it has happened, which is reflection and nothing else. She is plainly determined and courageous as well, but the question asks what the phrase shows, not what she is like, and nothing in it suggests curiosity.

As for a perception she might have changed, any well-reasoned answer is accepted. One would be the belief that a woman using a wheelchair could not represent her country in an international throwing event — an assumption her medal makes impossible to hold.

Answer the questions on the second Critical Reflection extract in full, and explain what the extract contributes to the chapter's argument.

The tone is appreciative and optimistic. The three decoys all fail for identifiable reasons. Moralistic fails because she describes what sport does and instructs nobody to be better. Sentimental fails because there is no appeal to pity anywhere — the words she uses are strength, skill and competitive spirit. Defensive fails because she is answering no accusation; the question invited an explanation, not a justification. Note that a combination is wanted, so one right word alone is not enough.

The analogy is completed by stereotypes: ability is to potential as preconceived notions are to stereotypes. In each pair the second word is the wider term for the first, so the relation is between a particular instance and the general category it belongs to.

The statement that the Paralympics both showcase remarkable abilities and question stereotypes is true, and the extract says both things within a single sentence.

That she was helped to push boundaries tells us she did not settle for what was expected of her and kept enlarging what she attempted. A boundary is a limit somebody else has drawn, so pushing it is a continuing activity rather than a single achievement.

And the phrase suggesting she was able to transform her life is a new lease of life, which is the only expression in the extract naming a change of state rather than a change of circumstance.

What the extract contributes to the chapter is the mechanism. Everywhere else the chapter asserts that perceptions change; here it explains how. People witness the competitive spirit of para-athletes and preconceived notions break down. Nobody is argued out of an assumption — they are shown something the assumption cannot accommodate, which is why the chapter's central claim rests on sport rather than on advocacy alone.

Flashcards (20)

Define fact and opinion as the lesson defines them.
A fact is evidence or factual information that can be proved to be true. An opinion is the writer's belief or perception.
Which sentence in the worked pair is the fact, and which the opinion?
Securing the silver medal in the shot-put at the 2016 Rio Games is the fact. Feeling that it was a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things is the opinion.
Give the quick test for telling a fact from an opinion, and the trap that goes with it.
Look at the verb: secured can be confirmed from a record, while I feel announces that a perception follows. The trap is thinking that because the second sentence is true it must be a fact — an accurate report of a belief is a fact about the speaker, not about the event.
Define cause and effect, and give the lesson's worked pair.
A cause is the action or event; an effect is the outcome. The cause is being diagnosed with a tumour in the spine; the effect is the surgery and the news that she would be bound to a wheelchair for life.
What is the quick test for cause and effect?
Ask which sentence could stand alone. A diagnosis makes sense by itself, whereas surgery and a verdict about a wheelchair need the diagnosis behind them to mean anything.
Which of the two practice pairs is fact and opinion, and what settles it?
The pair about her membership of the Working Group for the Twelfth Five Year Plan. Membership is a matter of record, while the second sentence opens with it is believed — the phrase that announces a belief rather than a result.
Which practice pair is cause and effect, and why?
The pair in which the Paralympics showcase the talent and determination of para-athletes, and the global perception on disabilities then shifts, inspiring para-athletes to pursue their dreams. The second follows from the first.
Why can the speaker's decision be likened to a caterpillar becoming a butterfly?
Because both are complete transformations from confinement into freedom. What emerges is not a repaired version of what went in but something different in kind, able to do what the earlier form could not — and she describes her life after the surgery as a new one rather than her old one restored.
Why could the speaker switch to para-athletics comfortably?
Because she already loved sports and had been a swimmer. The discipline was hers already; only its form changed.
Why does she call the 2016 Rio Games a 'breakthrough moment'?
Because it was her first Paralympic medal, and the first won by an Indian woman in any sport — so it broke through for her own career and for the country's record at the same time.
What does the phrase 'in hindsight' indicate about the speaker, and why are the other options wrong?
That she is reflective. The phrase means understanding something after it has happened, which is reflection and nothing else. She is plainly determined and courageous too, but not on the evidence of that phrase, and nothing in it suggests curiosity.
Give one perception the speaker might have changed by winning that medal.
Any reasonable answer naming a belief the medal contradicts — for instance, that a woman using a wheelchair could not represent her country in an international throwing event. The marking rests on the reasoning rather than on a single right answer.
What is the tone of the second extract, and which three offered words are wrong?
Appreciative and optimistic. Moralistic is wrong because she describes what sport does rather than instructing anybody to be better; sentimental is wrong because there is no appeal to pity; and defensive is wrong because she is not answering an accusation.
Complete and explain the analogy: ability is to potential as preconceived notions are to what?
Stereotypes. In each pair the second word is the wider term for the first — potential is the general idea behind a particular ability, and stereotypes are the general form that particular preconceived notions take.
True or false: the Paralympics both showcase remarkable abilities and question stereotypes. How do you know?
True. The extract says both things in a single sentence: that sport has the extraordinary ability to challenge stereotypes and change attitudes, and that when people witness the strength and skill of para-athletes it breaks down preconceived notions.
What does 'helped me push boundaries' tell us about the speaker?
That she did not settle for what was expected of her and kept enlarging what she attempted. A boundary is a limit somebody else has drawn, and pushing it is a continuing activity rather than a single achievement.
Which phrase in the second extract suggests she was able to transform her life?
A new lease of life. It is the one phrase in the extract that names a change of state rather than a change of circumstance.
How do her achievements challenge societal perceptions?
By producing counter-examples that an assumption cannot absorb. Every first on her list was regarded as impossible until it happened, and afterwards the impossibility has to be rewritten rather than restated. That is why she calls her awards a testimony.
What is the likely long-term impact of advocacy aimed at schools and colleges?
Changing a policy changes what is allowed; changing what a young person assumes changes what is expected, in every situation no policy covers. The second is slower and far more durable, and it compounds, since today's students become tomorrow's employers, teachers and coaches.
Why is 'every setback is an opportunity to prove your strength' a lesson for everyone, not only sportspeople?
Because a setback is information about a situation rather than a verdict on a person, so the sentence applies wherever setbacks occur. The useful word is prove: strength that has never been tested is only assumed, and a setback is the first occasion on which it becomes visible.

Play this topic

  • Match the Term to Its Definition
  • True or False: Reading Skills
  • Complete the Statement
  • Unscramble the Reading Terms

The Language and Skills Work of This Lesson

Five phrases taken from the interview, a word cline of movement verbs, the functions of four modal auxiliaries, reported speech in its simplest form, a listening announcement, two registers of interview, a notice to draft and the history of the Paralympic Games.

What you will be able to do

  • Match the lesson's five phrases to their meanings and use them correctly.
  • Arrange the movement words on a cline from slowest to fastest.
  • Identify the function a modal auxiliary is performing in a given sentence.
  • Convert a declarative sentence and a conversation into reported speech.
  • Distinguish a formal interview register from an informal one, and draft a notice.

Key points

  • The five phrases are defy the odds, a new lease of life, in hindsight, breakthrough moment and turn obstacles into stepping stones — each used by Dr. Malik about her own life.

  • A cline arranges words of similar meaning along a scale; here the scale runs from creep at the slowest to dart at the fastest.

  • A modal auxiliary performs a different function depending on the situation, so the same verb can express ability, possibility, obligation or prediction.

  • In the four sentences given, could shows past ability, couldn't impossibility, should obligation and would prediction; promise and possibility are the two unused functions.

  • Reporting a declarative sentence takes three steps: use a reporting verb, remove the quotation marks, and add the linking word that.

  • The changes noted are tense shifts and pronoun shifts — have been to had been, you to she, I to she, decided to had decided.

  • The listening passage is an announcement for a special assembly on World Inclusion Day, held in the school auditorium.

  • A notice carries the organisation's name, the word NOTICE, the date, a heading, the details, and then a signature, name and designation.

Full explanation

Five Phrases

The lesson takes five phrases from the interview and asks for their meanings — and every one of them is used by Dr. Malik about her own life, so the exercise doubles as a summary of the chapter.

Phrase Meaning
defy the odds succeed at something most people expect to end in failure
a new lease of life an occasion when you become more energetic and active than before
in hindsight the ability to understand something after it has happened
breakthrough moment a time of significant development or discovery
turn obstacles into stepping stones overcome challenges and achieve goals

Where each occurs

  • The chapter's opening question asks what happens when athletes defy the odds.
  • The Paralympics gave her a new lease of life.
  • In hindsight, the Rio silver was a personal victory.
  • Rio was her breakthrough moment.
  • Family support and fortitude let her turn obstacles into stepping stones.

The Word Cline

A cline arranges words of similar meaning along a scale, so the differences between them become visible. The exercise starts from sprinting, a word from athletics, and asks for the whole set ordered from slowest to fastest.

creep → crawl → plod → amble → saunter → stroll → walk → jog → run → sprint → dart

What the middle of the scale teaches

The ends are easy. The interesting work is between them, because several of these words would get the same one-line dictionary gloss.

  • plod — slow and heavy; effortful.
  • amble — slow and easy; no effort implied.
  • saunter and stroll — leisure rather than effort. Saunter carries a touch of confidence.
  • jog — steady, and usually deliberate exercise.
  • dart — fast and sudden, over a short distance.

So pace is not the only axis. Effort, purpose and duration are all hiding inside a list that looks like a single scale.

Modal Auxiliaries

A modal auxiliary is a helping verb whose function changes with the situation. The lesson makes that its whole point.

The four sentences

Sentence Modal Function
I could hear the audience clapping could past ability
It couldn't be helped couldn't impossibility
I should give it my best shot should obligation
I knew if I tried, I would win would prediction

Six functions are offered for four sentences, so two are left over: promise and possibility.

The same verbs, other functions

Modal Other functions
could possibility, unreal ability, request, suggestion
couldn't inability
should probability, advice
would request, past habit

The lesson to take. You cannot learn what a modal means. You can only learn to read what it is doing in the sentence in front of you.

Reported Speech

The interview sentences are in direct speech, and they are declarative sentences — statements, not questions, exclamations or commands.

The three steps

  1. Use a reporting verb — said, told or says.
  2. Remove the quotation marks.
  3. Add the linking word that after the reporting verb.

The changes noted

From the worked examples:

  • have been → had been
  • you → she
  • I → she
  • decided → had decided

So tense moves back a step and pronouns change person.

One exception worth noticing

In the last worked example the reporting verb is says rather than said — and the tense inside does not shift: she believes youth is the voice of tomorrow.

That is the rule behind the rule. Tense moves back because the reporting happens later. With a present-tense reporting verb, there is no gap to record.

The conversation

The dialogue between Siya and Tarun is to be reported in the same way. Siya watched a documentary; Tarun had not known the Paralympics had equestrian events; Siya found it interesting; Tarun remarked that para equestrians must be training for months; Siya added that they also have to develop their own style of communication with the horse; and Tarun said he would watch it the following weekend.

Note the reporting verbs the exercise itself supplies: said, replied, added, remarked, enquired. Variety is expected.

Listen and Respond

An announcement for a special assembly.

Question Answer
The venue the school auditorium
The presentation on inclusion by the Interact Club
The dance themes diversity and acceptance
Conducted by experts supporting inclusion a panel discussion
The closing item a song

The occasion is World Inclusion Day, and the assembly opens with a welcome speech by the Principal.

The skill. Answers are limited to one or two exact words heard, so this trains precise catching rather than summary.

Two Registers

The speaking task interviews two people — the Sports Captain informally, and the Sports Coach formally — using the same five questions in two versions.

Informal Formal
Hello! It is so good of you to see me. Good morning, it is my privilege to have this interaction.
Tell me who you are and why sport matters to you. Would you say something about how your life in sport started?
Did anything get in your way? What did you do about it? Would you tell us something of the difficulties you met and how you got past them?
What impressive achievements have you won? What do they mean to you? A good many honours have come your way. What do they represent for you?
Is there anything you would want to say to younger athletes coming up? What advice do you have for aspiring athletes?

What actually differs

Not politeness — distance.

  • The formal version uses modals: could you tell me, rather than tell me.
  • It uses longer noun phrases: accolades and accomplishments rather than achievements.
  • It asks about meaning rather than feeling: what do these mean to you, not how do you feel about them.
  • It names a role — aspiring athletes — where the informal names people: your peers or juniors.

The formal register treats the interviewee as a position; the informal treats them as a person. Both are appropriate, in their place.

The Notice

What it is: writing that conveys information to students or to a specific group.

What it covers: an event, a celebration, a competition, important information, a lost or found article.

The format:

  1. Name of Organisation
  2. The word NOTICE
  3. Date
  4. Heading
  5. Details
  6. Signature, Name, Designation

The task: as Sports Captain, draft a notice in not more than 50 words inviting students to register for selection in different events of an Inter-school Athletic Meet — inside a box.

Where the Paralympics Came From

The origin traces to 1948, the year Sir Ludwig Guttmann got up a sporting contest in England for ex-servicemen with spinal cord injuries.

The Stoke Mandeville Games were the Olympic-style games for differently-abled athletes, and were first organised in Rome in 1960.

Since then:

  • the Paralympics are split into Winter and Summer Games, alternating every two years;
  • since the late twentieth century they have been held in the same city that hosts the corresponding Olympic Games;
  • and they follow shortly after the Olympics.

Why the origin matters. The movement did not begin as a celebration. It began as rehabilitation for injured soldiers — which is exactly the shift the chapter is about, from something done for people to something done by them.

Concepts and terms

Cline

An arrangement of words of similar meaning along a scale, so that the differences between them become visible. Here the scale is pace, and it runs from creep to dart.

Modal auxiliary

A helping verb whose function changes with the situation it is used in. The same word can carry ability, possibility, obligation, advice or prediction, so the sentence rather than the dictionary decides.

Reported speech

Somebody else repeating what a speaker said. For a declarative sentence the changes are small: a reporting verb, no quotation marks, the linking word that, and the usual shifts of tense and pronoun.

Register

The level of formality a situation calls for. The lesson sets the same five questions in an informal version and a formal one, so that the difference can be seen line by line.

Notice

A short piece of writing conveying information to students or to a particular group — an event, a competition, a lost article. It is boxed, dated, headed, and signed with a name and designation.

What Students Get Wrong

Did you know

Every one of the lesson's five phrases is spoken by Dr. Malik about her own life, so the vocabulary exercise doubles as a summary of the interview.

The word cline starts from sprinting, a word the chapter uses, and works outwards from athletics into ordinary walking.

The modal exercise offers six functions for four sentences, so two are deliberately left over.

Memory tricks

Reporting a statement — Verb, quotes, that. — Add a reporting verb, remove the quotation marks, add the linking word.

The cline's two ends — Creep to dart. — Slowest and most careful at one end; fastest and most sudden at the other.

The four modals in the exercise — Could, couldn't, should, would. — Past ability, impossibility, obligation, prediction — in that order.

Practice MCQs with answers (28)

Q1 A student is asked which of the lesson's phrases describes succeeding where most people expect failure. Which should they choose? intermediate
  • A A new lease of life
  • B In hindsight
  • C Breakthrough moment
  • D Defy the odds
Show answer
Answer: Defy the odds
Why:

The chapter's opening question uses it of Paralympic athletes.

Q2 Which phrase would fit a sentence about somebody understanding, long afterwards, why an event mattered? advanced
  • A Defy the odds
  • B Turn obstacles into stepping stones
  • C In hindsight
  • D A new lease of life
Show answer
Answer: In hindsight
Why:

It names an understanding available only after the fact.

Q3 What do all five phrases in the matching exercise have in common? advanced
  • A Each is used by Dr. Malik about her own life
  • B Each comes from the field of athletics
  • C Each contains exactly three words
  • D Each appears in the interviewer's questions rather than her answers
Show answer
Answer: Each is used by Dr. Malik about her own life
Why:

Which makes the vocabulary exercise a summary of the interview.

Q4 A teacher explains that a cline is more useful than a list of synonyms. Why? advanced
  • A It groups words by the number of letters they contain
  • B It sorts words by how often they are used
  • C It arranges words along a scale, so the differences between them become visible
  • D It shows which words share an origin
Show answer
Answer: It arranges words along a scale, so the differences between them become visible
Why:

A dictionary would gloss several of these words alike.

Q5 Which order correctly gives the slowest three words of the movement cline? intermediate
  • A Plod, creep, crawl
  • B Creep, crawl, plod
  • C Crawl, amble, creep
  • D Creep, saunter, crawl
Show answer
Answer: Creep, crawl, plod
Why:

Dart stands at the opposite end of the scale.

Q6 A student places two slow words at the same point on the cline. Which distinction separates plod from amble? advanced
  • A Plod is used only of animals; amble only of people
  • B Plod implies effort and heaviness; amble implies ease
  • C Plod is faster than amble
  • D Plod describes movement indoors only
Show answer
Answer: Plod implies effort and heaviness; amble implies ease
Why:

Effort is a second axis hiding inside a scale of pace.

Q7 Which word on the cline suggests speed over a short distance and a sudden start? intermediate
  • A Jog
  • B Dart
  • C Stroll
  • D Plod
Show answer
Answer: Dart
Why:

It sits at the fast end, beyond sprint.

Q8 Assertion (A): A cline of movement words measures more than pace. Reason (R): Effort, purpose and duration are carried by words such as plod, jog and saunter as well as speed. advanced
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Why:

Which is why several of the words resist a single ordering.

Q9 Somebody says they could hear the audience clapping during a match years ago. What function is the modal performing? advanced
  • A Possibility
  • B Request
  • C Suggestion
  • D Past ability
Show answer
Answer: Past ability
Why:

Could carries four other functions in different situations.

Q10 In the sentence 'It couldn't be helped', what is the modal doing? advanced
  • A Expressing impossibility
  • B Expressing inability
  • C Expressing a prediction
  • D Expressing advice
Show answer
Answer: Expressing impossibility
Why:

Inability is couldn't's other function, in a different kind of sentence.

Q11 Which pairing of sentence to function is correct in the lesson's exercise? advanced
  • A I knew if I tried, I would win — obligation
  • B I knew if I tried, I would win — prediction
  • C I should give it my best shot — prediction
  • D It couldn't be helped — past ability
Show answer
Answer: I knew if I tried, I would win — prediction
Why:

Should carries the obligation in that set.

Q12 Six functions are offered against four sentences in the modal exercise. Which two go unused? advanced
  • A Obligation and advice
  • B Prediction and request
  • C Past ability and inability
  • D Promise and possibility
Show answer
Answer: Promise and possibility
Why:

The extras prevent the last answer being reached by elimination.

Q13 A student learns a single fixed meaning for each modal verb. Why will that fail? advanced
  • A Modal verbs have no meaning outside written English
  • B The function depends on the situation, so could alone covers five different jobs
  • C Modal verbs change their spelling between functions
  • D Modal verbs are used only in reported speech
Show answer
Answer: The function depends on the situation, so could alone covers five different jobs
Why:

Possibility, unreal ability, request, suggestion and past ability.

Q14 What kind of sentences are the interview lines used for the reported speech exercise? intermediate
  • A Interrogative
  • B Declarative
  • C Imperative
  • D Exclamatory
Show answer
Answer: Declarative
Why:

Statements rather than questions or commands.

Q15 Which set correctly gives the three steps for reporting a statement? intermediate
  • A Add a reporting verb, remove the quotation marks, add the linking word that
  • B Add a question mark, keep the quotation marks, change the subject
  • C Remove the reporting verb, add if or whether, reverse the word order
  • D Change the tense forward, keep the pronouns, add a comma
Show answer
Answer: Add a reporting verb, remove the quotation marks, add the linking word that
Why:

The usual shifts of tense and pronoun follow from there.

Q16 Consider these changes noted in the worked examples. 1. Have been becomes had been. 2. You becomes she. 3. Decided stays unchanged. Which of the statements are correct? advanced
  • A 1 and 2 only
  • B 1 and 3 only
  • C 2 and 3 only
  • D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: 1 and 2 only
Why:

Decided becomes had decided, a step further back.

Q17 In one worked example the inner tense does not move at all. What accounts for that? advanced
  • A The sentence is a question rather than a statement
  • B The reporting verb is says rather than said, so there is no gap in time to record
  • C The original sentence was already in the past tense
  • D The speaker is quoted rather than reported
Show answer
Answer: The reporting verb is says rather than said, so there is no gap in time to record
Why:

The shift is a record of time passing, not a ritual.

Q18 Which set of reporting verbs does the Siya and Tarun exercise itself supply? advanced
  • A Said, said, said, said, said
  • B Told, asked, ordered, warned, promised
  • C Announced, declared, insisted, denied, agreed
  • D Said, replied, added, remarked, enquired
Show answer
Answer: Said, replied, added, remarked, enquired
Why:

So variety is expected rather than repetition.

Q19 In the listening announcement, who makes the presentation on inclusion? advanced
  • A The Principal
  • B The school dance team
  • C A panel of guest speakers
  • D The Interact Club
Show answer
Answer: The Interact Club
Why:

The Principal gives the welcome speech, and the dance team performs separately.

Q20 Which two themes does the dance performance in that announcement focus on? advanced
  • A Inclusion and achievement
  • B Friendship and courage
  • C Diversity and acceptance
  • D Teamwork and discipline
Show answer
Answer: Diversity and acceptance
Why:

The assembly closes with a song instead.

Q21 A student rewrites 'Tell me about yourself' as 'Could you tell me how your journey began'. What has changed, and what has not? advanced
  • A The question has become a command; the subject has changed
  • B The tense has shifted back; the meaning has narrowed
  • C The register has become formal through a modal; the information asked for is the same
  • D The question has become informal; the length has increased
Show answer
Answer: The register has become formal through a modal; the information asked for is the same
Why:

Register is about distance rather than about content.

Q22 Which feature is characteristic of the formal interview register in this lesson? advanced
  • A Addressing the interviewee by their first name
  • B Beginning with an expression of personal gladness
  • C Asking what accomplishments mean rather than how they feel
  • D Asking about peers and juniors rather than aspiring athletes
Show answer
Answer: Asking what accomplishments mean rather than how they feel
Why:

The formal register treats the interviewee as a position, not a person.

Q23 Which sequence gives the correct format of a notice? advanced
  • A Date, organisation, details, heading, NOTICE, signature
  • B Heading, details, organisation, date, signature, NOTICE
  • C Organisation, NOTICE, date, heading, details, signature with name and designation
  • D NOTICE, signature, heading, organisation, date, details
Show answer
Answer: Organisation, NOTICE, date, heading, details, signature with name and designation
Why:

And the whole thing is drawn inside a box.

Q24 A student writes a 90-word notice as a flowing paragraph. What two rules have been broken? advanced
  • A The requirement for a signature, and the use of the first person
  • B The heading, and the mention of a date
  • C The use of modals, and the reporting verb
  • D The fifty-word limit, and the fixed format inside a box
Show answer
Answer: The fifty-word limit, and the fixed format inside a box
Why:

A notice is a shape as much as a message.

Q25 Who organised the competition from which the Paralympic movement traces its origin, and for whom? advanced
  • A The International Paralympic Committee, for injured athletes
  • B The Stoke Mandeville hospital, for local schoolchildren
  • C Sir Ludwig Guttmann, for war veterans with spinal cord injuries
  • D The Olympic Committee, for retired competitors
Show answer
Answer: Sir Ludwig Guttmann, for war veterans with spinal cord injuries
Why:

In England, in 1948.

Q26 Where and when were the Stoke Mandeville Games first organised? advanced
  • A England, in 1948
  • B Tokyo, in 1964
  • C Rome, in 1948
  • D Rome, in 1960
Show answer
Answer: Rome, in 1960
Why:

1948 and England belong to the original competition.

Q27 How have the Paralympics been arranged since the late twentieth century? advanced
  • A Held in the same host city as the Olympics, shortly after them
  • B Held in a different continent from the Olympics each time
  • C Held in the same year but before the Olympics
  • D Held only in the country that won most medals previously
Show answer
Answer: Held in the same host city as the Olympics, shortly after them
Why:

And split into Winter and Summer Games alternating every two years.

Q28 Why is the origin of these Games worth knowing for this particular chapter? advanced
  • A The movement began as rehabilitation — something done for people before it was done by them
  • B The movement began in India, which the chapter is about
  • C The movement began as a commercial venture
  • D The movement has always been organised by athletes themselves
Show answer
Answer: The movement began as rehabilitation — something done for people before it was done by them
Why:

Which is the same shift the interview describes.

Important short questions (6)

Give the five phrases from the interview with their meanings, and say what they have in common.

To defy the odds is to succeed when most people expect failure. A new lease of life is an occasion when you become more energetic and active than before. In hindsight is the ability to understand something after it has happened. A breakthrough moment is a time of significant development or discovery. To turn obstacles into stepping stones is to overcome challenges and achieve goals. What they have in common is that every one is used by Dr. Malik about her own life, so the exercise doubles as a summary of the chapter.

What is a cline, and what does this one reveal that a list of synonyms would not?

A cline arranges words of similar meaning along a scale so the differences between them become visible. Here the order runs creep, crawl, plod, amble, saunter, stroll, walk, jog, run, sprint, dart. What it reveals is that pace is not the only thing these words carry. Plod is heavy where amble is easy, saunter and stroll add leisure rather than effort, jog implies deliberate exercise, and dart implies suddenness over a short distance. Effort, purpose and duration are all hiding inside what looks like a single scale.

Explain what a modal auxiliary is, and identify the function in each of the lesson's four sentences.

A modal auxiliary is a helping verb whose function changes according to the situation it appears in, so the same word can carry quite different work. In the lesson's four sentences: could hear the audience clapping expresses past ability; it couldn't be helped expresses impossibility; I should give it my best shot expresses obligation; and I knew if I tried, I would win expresses prediction. Six functions are offered for four sentences, so promise and possibility are left over.

Set out the steps for reporting a declarative sentence, and explain the one worked example where the tense does not move.

Use a reporting verb — said, told or says; remove the quotation marks; and add the linking word that after the reporting verb. Tenses then shift back a step and pronouns change person, so have been becomes had been and I becomes she. In one worked example, however, the tense stays put, because the reporting verb there is says rather than said. The shift exists to record the gap between speaking and reporting, and with a present-tense reporting verb there is no gap to record.

What separates the formal interview register from the informal one in this lesson?

Distance rather than politeness — both versions are perfectly courteous. The formal version uses modals, asking whether the interviewee could tell the questioner something rather than simply telling them. It prefers longer noun phrases, using accolades and accomplishments where the informal says achievements. It asks what those accomplishments mean rather than how they feel. And it names a role, addressing advice to aspiring athletes, where the informal names people — peers and juniors. In short, the formal register treats the interviewee as a position and the informal treats them as a person.

Give the origin and present arrangement of the Paralympic Games, and say why the origin matters for this chapter.

The origin traces to 1948, when Sir Ludwig Guttmann organised a sports competition in England for war veterans with spinal cord-related injuries. The Stoke Mandeville Games, the Olympic-style games for differently-abled athletes, were first organised in Rome in 1960. Today the Paralympics are split into Winter and Summer Games alternating every two years, and since the late twentieth century they have been held in the same host city as the corresponding Olympics, following shortly after them. The origin matters because the movement began as rehabilitation for injured soldiers — something done for people before it became something done by them, which is exactly the shift Dr. Malik's interview describes.

Long answer questions (3)

Set out the vocabulary work of this lesson in full — the five phrases and the word cline — and show what each teaches.

The first exercise matches five phrases to their meanings. To defy the odds is to succeed in doing something when most people think it would end in failure. A new lease of life is an occasion when you become more energetic and active than earlier. In hindsight is the ability to understand something after it has happened. A breakthrough moment is a time of significant development or discovery. And to turn obstacles into stepping stones is to overcome challenges and achieve goals.

What makes the exercise more than a vocabulary drill is that every one of the five is spoken by Dr. Malik about her own life. The chapter opens by asking what happens when athletes defy the odds; the Paralympics gave her a new lease of life; in hindsight the Rio silver was a personal victory; Rio was her breakthrough moment; and family support with her own fortitude let her turn obstacles into stepping stones. Learning the phrases is therefore also revising the interview.

The second exercise is a cline — an arrangement of words of similar meaning along a scale, so that the differences between them become visible. It starts from sprinting, a word the chapter itself uses, and asks for the whole set from slowest to fastest: creep, crawl, plod, amble, saunter, stroll, walk, jog, run, sprint, dart.

The ends of that scale are straightforward. The value of the exercise lies in the middle, where several words would receive the same one-line gloss in a dictionary. Plod is slow and heavy and implies effort; amble is slow and easy and implies none. Saunter and stroll are leisurely rather than effortful, with saunter carrying a touch of confidence. Jog is steady and usually deliberate exercise. Dart is fast and sudden and covers a short distance.

So the cline teaches something a synonym list cannot: that effort, purpose and duration are riding inside what appears to be a single scale of speed, and that choosing between near-synonyms is choosing between all of those at once.

Explain the grammar work of this lesson — modal auxiliaries and reported speech — with examples.

A modal auxiliary is a helping verb whose function changes with the situation in which it is used, and the lesson makes that its whole point. Four sentences are given. In the first, somebody could hear the audience clapping, which expresses past ability. In the second, it couldn't be helped, which expresses impossibility. In the third, the speaker should give it their best shot, which expresses obligation. In the fourth, the speaker knew that if they tried they would win, which is a prediction. Six functions are offered against these four sentences, so two — promise and possibility — are deliberately left over, which prevents the last answer being reached by elimination.

The same four verbs are then shown doing other work. Could also carries possibility, unreal ability, request and suggestion. Couldn't carries inability. Should carries probability and advice. Would carries request and past habit. The lesson a student should draw is that a modal cannot be learned as a meaning; it can only be read as a function in the sentence in front of them.

The second piece of grammar is reported speech. The interview lines used are in direct speech and are declarative sentences — statements rather than questions or commands — and reporting them takes three steps. Use a reporting verb, said or told or says. Remove the quotation marks. Add the linking word that after the reporting verb.

The changes then noted are the ordinary ones. Tense moves back a step, so have been becomes had been and decided becomes had decided. Pronouns change person, so you becomes she and I becomes she.

One worked example is worth attention because its tense does not move at all: where the reporting verb is says rather than said, the inner verb stays in the present. This is the rule behind the rule. Tense shifts backwards to record the gap between the speaking and the reporting, and where the reporting is happening now there is no gap to record.

Describe the listening, speaking and writing work of this lesson, and explain what each is designed to train.

The listening passage is an announcement for a special assembly on World Inclusion Day. It is to be held in the school auditorium and opens with a welcome speech by the Principal. The Interact Club will make a presentation on inclusion; the school dance team will perform on the themes of diversity and acceptance; a panel discussion will follow, conducted by experts who advocate inclusion in various fields; and the celebration ends with a song. Answers are limited to one or two exact words heard, so what is being trained is precise catching rather than summary — a student who grasps the sense and puts it in their own words will lose the mark.

The speaking task interviews two people, the Sports Captain informally and the Sports Coach formally, using the same five questions in two versions set side by side. What actually differs is not politeness, since both are courteous, but distance. The formal version uses modals, asking whether the coach could tell the interviewer something rather than simply telling them. It prefers longer noun phrases, saying accolades and accomplishments where the informal says achievements. It asks what those accomplishments mean instead of how they feel. And it addresses a role — aspiring athletes — where the informal addresses people, peers and juniors. The formal register treats the interviewee as a position; the informal treats them as a person, and both are right in their place.

The writing task is a notice. A notice conveys information to students or to a specific group, and may concern an event, a celebration, a competition, important information or a lost article. Its format is fixed: the name of the organisation, the word NOTICE, the date, a heading, the details, and then a signature with name and designation. The particular task is to draft one as Sports Captain, in not more than fifty words, inviting students to register for selection in the events of an Inter-school Athletic Meet, and to draw it inside a box. The discipline here is compression into a fixed shape — a notice is a form as much as a message.

Flashcards (24)

Give the meanings of 'defy the odds' and 'a new lease of life'.
To defy the odds is to bring something off when nearly everybody expects it to fail. A new lease of life is a point at which somebody becomes livelier and more active than they had been before.
Give the meanings of 'in hindsight', 'breakthrough moment' and 'turn obstacles into stepping stones'.
In hindsight — the ability to understand something after it has happened. Breakthrough moment — a time of significant development or discovery. Turn obstacles into stepping stones — overcome challenges and achieve goals.
What do all five phrases in that exercise have in common?
Every one of them is used by Dr. Malik about her own life, so the vocabulary exercise doubles as a summary of the interview.
What is a cline, and what does this lesson's cline measure?
An arrangement of words of similar meaning along a scale, so that the differences between them become visible. This one measures pace, from the slowest movement to the fastest.
Give the movement words in order from slowest to fastest.
Creep, crawl, plod, amble, saunter, stroll, walk, jog, run, sprint, dart.
Distinguish plod from amble, and saunter from jog.
Plod is slow and heavy, and implies effort; amble is slow and easy, and implies none. Saunter is leisurely and carries a touch of confidence; jog is steady and usually deliberate exercise. So the cline hides effort and purpose inside what looks like a single scale of pace.
What is a modal auxiliary, and what is the lesson's point about it?
A helping verb whose function changes with the situation it is used in. The point is that you cannot learn what a modal means — only what it is doing in the sentence in front of you.
Give the function of the modal in each of the four sentences in the exercise.
Could hear the audience clapping — past ability. It couldn't be helped — impossibility. I should give it my best shot — obligation. I knew if I tried, I would win — prediction.
Which two functions are offered in that exercise but not needed?
Promise and possibility. Six functions are given against four sentences, so two are deliberately left over.
List the other functions of could, couldn't, should and would.
Could — possibility, unreal ability, request, suggestion. Couldn't — inability. Should — probability, advice. Would — request, past habit.
What kind of sentences are the interview lines used for the reported speech exercise?
They are in direct speech, and they are declarative sentences — statements rather than questions, exclamations or commands.
Give the three steps for reporting a declarative sentence.
Use a reporting verb — said, told or says. Remove the quotation marks. Add the linking word that after the reporting verb.
What changes are noted in the worked examples of reported speech?
Tense shifts — have been becomes had been, and decided becomes had decided. Pronouns change person — you becomes she, and I becomes she.
In one worked example the tense does not shift at all. Why not?
Because the reporting verb there is says rather than said. Tense moves back to record the gap between speaking and reporting, and with a present-tense reporting verb there is no gap to record.
What reporting verbs does the Siya and Tarun exercise itself supply?
Said, replied, added, remarked and enquired — so variety is expected rather than five repetitions of said.
Give the five answers to the listening announcement.
The venue is the school auditorium; the presentation on inclusion is by the Interact Club; the dance performance focuses on diversity and acceptance; a panel discussion is conducted by experts who support inclusion; and the celebration ends with a song.
What is the occasion of that assembly, and how does it open?
World Inclusion Day. It opens with a welcome speech by the Principal, and the answers must be given in one or two exact words heard.
What really separates the formal interview from the informal one?
Distance rather than politeness. The formal version uses modals such as could you tell me, prefers longer noun phrases like accolades and accomplishments, asks what achievements mean rather than how they feel, and names a role — aspiring athletes — where the informal names people.
Give the format of a notice.
Name of the organisation; the word NOTICE; the date; a heading; the details; and then the signature, name and designation. The task's notice must be under fifty words and drawn inside a box.
What may a notice be written about?
An event, a celebration, a competition, important information, or a lost or found article. It conveys information to students or to a specific group of people.
Where and when did the Paralympic movement begin?
In England, in 1948. Sir Ludwig Guttmann put on a sporting contest for soldiers who had come back from the war with injuries to the spinal cord.
What were the Stoke Mandeville Games, and where were they first held?
Olympic-style games for athletes with disabilities. Rome hosted the first of them in 1960, and they have run alongside the Olympic Games ever since.
How are the Paralympics organised today?
They are split into Winter and Summer Games, which alternate every two years. Since the late twentieth century they have been held in the same city that hosts the corresponding Olympic Games, and follow shortly after them.
Why is the origin of the Paralympics worth knowing for this chapter?
Because the movement did not begin as a celebration but as rehabilitation for injured soldiers. That is exactly the shift the chapter is about — from something done for people to something done by them.

Play this topic

  • Match the Phrase to Its Meaning
  • True or False: Grammar and Skills
  • Complete the Statement
  • Unscramble the Terms

Class 9 English Chapter 5 — frequently asked questions

What are the Paralympic Games, and what does the chapter say they do beyond competition?

They are a celebration of resilience and of the extraordinary talent of athletes with locomotor, sensory or intellectual disabilities. Beyond the competition itself, the chapter says they exist to quell stereotypes and to redefine possibilities. The choice of verb is pointed: quell is normally used of riots, so a stereotype is presented as something to be put down rather than debated.

Describe the turning point in Dr. Malik's life and the choice she made.

At twenty-nine she was diagnosed with a spine tumour. She underwent surgery, and the doctors then declared that she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life, paralysed waist down. She says she had two choices: to squander her life in remorse, or to transform it into a world of limitless possibilities. She chose the second, and that phrase became the title of the chapter.

How did her Paralympic career begin, and what was her breakthrough?

She had always loved sports and had been a swimmer, so switching to para-athletics came comfortably — the discipline was already hers and only its form changed. Her breakthrough came at the 2016 Rio Paralympic Games, where she secured the silver medal in the shot-put. Looking back, she calls it both a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things.

Define fact and opinion, and show how the worked pair illustrates the difference.

A fact is evidence or factual information that can be proved to be true; an opinion is the writer's belief or perception. The worked pair puts them side by side. Securing the silver medal in the shot-put at Rio in 2016 is a fact, since a record can confirm it. Feeling that it was a private triumph, and a step towards shifting the way people see things is an opinion. The verb settles it: secured describes an event, while I feel announces a perception.

A student argues that because the speaker sincerely feels something, the sentence reporting it must be a fact. Correct the reasoning.

The sentence is indeed true, but truth is not the test. An accurate report of what somebody believes is a fact about the speaker, not about the event described. The question asks whether the thing described can be proved, and a feeling about a medal's significance cannot be checked in the way the medal itself can. Sincerity makes a sentence honest; it does not make the content verifiable.

Explain cause and effect using the lesson's worked pair, and give the test that identifies each.

A cause is the action or event and an effect is the outcome. In the worked pair the cause is being diagnosed with a tumour in the spine, and the effect is the surgery together with the news that she would be bound to a wheelchair for the rest of her life. The test is to ask which sentence could stand alone. A diagnosis makes sense by itself; surgery and a verdict about a wheelchair need the diagnosis behind them before they mean anything at all.

Give the five phrases from the interview with their meanings, and say what they have in common.

To defy the odds is to succeed when most people expect failure. A new lease of life is an occasion when you become more energetic and active than before. In hindsight is the ability to understand something after it has happened. A breakthrough moment is a time of significant development or discovery. To turn obstacles into stepping stones is to overcome challenges and achieve goals. What they have in common is that every one is used by Dr. Malik about her own life, so the exercise doubles as a summary of the chapter.

What is a cline, and what does this one reveal that a list of synonyms would not?

A cline arranges words of similar meaning along a scale so the differences between them become visible. Here the order runs creep, crawl, plod, amble, saunter, stroll, walk, jog, run, sprint, dart. What it reveals is that pace is not the only thing these words carry. Plod is heavy where amble is easy, saunter and stroll add leisure rather than effort, jog implies deliberate exercise, and dart implies suddenness over a short distance. Effort, purpose and duration are all hiding inside what looks like a single scale.

Explain what a modal auxiliary is, and identify the function in each of the lesson's four sentences.

A modal auxiliary is a helping verb whose function changes according to the situation it appears in, so the same word can carry quite different work. In the lesson's four sentences: could hear the audience clapping expresses past ability; it couldn't be helped expresses impossibility; I should give it my best shot expresses obligation; and I knew if I tried, I would win expresses prediction. Six functions are offered for four sentences, so promise and possibility are left over.

All Class 9 English chapters

All English chapters · Every Class 9 subject · The whole NCERT library

Study this chapter properly, free

Everything above is on this page to read. In the Veda app the same chapter becomes spaced-repetition flashcards, timed tests that mark themselves, Veda Bites you can swipe, and games — with your progress tracked topic by topic.

Get Veda free