Class 9 English Chapter 4: Vitamin-M
- 3 topics
- 96 MCQs
- 18 short answers
- 9 long answers
- 65 flashcards
- 12 games
- ~86 min read
- English
The Story, Scene by Scene
A boy promises his mother he will keep his grandfather indoors, and then follows him across a city instead. This topic works through all three parts: the month that produced the rule, the pursuit and its four humiliations, and the parcel waiting at home.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why the rule against going out alone was made, and by whom.
- Describe Grandpa's old house and the accident that ended his life there.
- Put the stages of Grandpa's day out in the right order.
- Explain how Ravi was fooled on the bus.
- Describe what happens when Ravi gets home, and what the parcel turns out to be.
Key points
The story is by Asha Nehemiah, and the joke that gives it its title is made by Ravi's mother over her father's head.
Grandpa is seventy-five, a former lawyer, and had been keeping house alone for ten years since his wife died.
In one month he was taken to hospital after absent-mindedly doubling his medicine, and got lost on a walk and could not find his way home.
He fell while pottering in the garden of his brick house and lay outside all night because nobody was there to help him up.
He remembers chess games move by move but forgets the names of people he meets often, which is the puzzle Ravi cannot solve.
Grandpa goes out for a Tamil newspaper, and Ravi follows him secretly to the park, the tea stall, the barber shop and the bus.
On the bus the yellow cap turns out to be on a stranger, to whom Grandpa had given it in the barber shop because the day was hot.
Grandpa is asleep at home, and his gift to Ravi is a book of detective stories with advice on how not to be fooled while trailing a suspect.
Full explanation
Part One: How the Rule Came About
The story opens on a joke. Ravi's mother, putting tablets on a saucer, wishes somebody would invent a memory vitamin — Vitamin-M, she says — that could be given to old people.
Ravi warns her that Grandpa will hear. She doubts it: he does not hear especially well these days, nor see especially well, nor even remember especially well.
And there in the room, in a rocking chair, is the man being discussed — frail, holding the newspaper inches from his nose.
The month that made the rule
Grandpa came to live with them only a month earlier, because he was getting too old to live on his own. The month had been difficult, and the story is careful to say why.
- He was admitted to hospital after absent-mindedly taking a double dose of his medicines.
- He went out for a walk and forgot the way back home.
So when his daughter forbids him to go out alone again, she has reasons. The story never pretends otherwise.
What Grandpa says back
He is very upset, and his reply carries a hint of the steel that had come with the work when he was a lawyer.
He has been looking after himself for the better part of his seventy-five years. After his wife died ten years ago he took over her duties as well, and has been cooking, shopping and keeping house.
And now, he says, she has forced him to come and live in this poky little flat, in this horrible, crowded city — and thinks she has the right to forbid him to go out on his own.
The brick house
When they are alone he speaks longingly of his small brick house in town.
A wonderful place, with a big mango tree in the garden, quiet enough that at dusk you can catch a leaf coming down.
But one evening, pottering around in that garden, he slipped and fell — and lay outside all night, because there was nobody in the house to get him back on his feet.
A month had gone by since, and it had made Ravi's mother lock the house and bring him to the city.
The instruction, and the tone
Her orders to Ravi are flat: whatever happens, Grandpa is not to go out on his own, it is too dangerous. She adds the medicines to be given after lunch.
Then she turns to her father and announces that she is off to work.
And here comes the detail the whole story turns on. Ravi winces at the over-loud tone she uses — as though she were speaking to a child who could not hear or understand too well.
Grandpa continues to rock gently and gives no sign that he has heard her at all.
Part Two: The Pursuit
Chess, and the puzzle
After she leaves, Ravi offers chess or the cricket match. Grandpa plays a great game — cool and cunning — and Ravi's own game has improved since he arrived.
That is the opening move Karpov made when he played against the computer. You are walking into the very error Bobby Fischer made in that famous match against Spassky.
Which produces the question Ravi cannot answer: how does he hold thousands of chess games in his head and still lose the names of people he sees all the time?
The trap
Grandpa puts his paper down. He will just walk across to the corner shop, to see whether the Tamil newspaper has arrived.
Ravi offers to go instead — and walks straight into it.
I hope you are not going to be as tiresome as your mother. Treating me like a baby! Has she told you I am not to go out alone? Has she told you to keep me here like a prisoner?
Ravi feels guilty, then recovers to say loyally that of course she has not — that his mother would never treat him like a baby or a prisoner.
Good, says Grandpa craftily, then you will have no objection to my going out.
He picks up his shiny black mahogany walking stick with a brass handle carved as an eagle's head, puts on his bright-yellow cap, and goes off twirling the stick jauntily.
And Ravi is left in a dilemma. Insisting on going along would hurt his grandfather; letting him go alone would infuriate his mother. So he decides to follow secretly, at a safe distance.
Four humiliations
The park. Grandpa buys a paper cone of peanuts and settles on a bench to watch the children. Ravi has to get down behind a bush clipped into the shape of an elephant — and is promptly discovered by a small child, who offers to show him a better place to hide. The child's mother arrives and threatens him with an umbrella. Ravi has to crawl out of the park on all fours.
The tea stall. He takes position behind a big banyan tree, and is immediately surrounded by vendors who assume he is a rival: this area is booked by us; there is no room for any new vendors. Every one of them, the story notes drily, could address a gathering without a loudspeaker.
The forbidden feast. Driven behind a shiny silver car, Ravi watches his grandfather work through a sugary cup of tea (forbidden at home), two bananas (another banned item) and an ice cream from a cart.
The barber shop. Grandpa zigzags through the traffic — brakes screech — and goes in. Since Grandpa is as bald as a table tennis ball, this deserves a closer look, so Ravi crosses the road and ducks into the shop next door, only to be evicted a moment later amid feminine shrieks: it is a Ladies' Hairdressing Salon.
The cap
Grandpa then walks briskly to the bus stop and boards the first bus. Ravi sprints, jumps on, and can see the yellow cap near the front.
It is warm inside, so the wearer takes the cap off — revealing a full head of grey hair.
A total stranger. In white pyjama and shirt, which is Grandpa's standard attire, and a yellow cap exactly like his.
But the cap has a coffee stain on the rim, just like Grandpa's.
The stranger grins and explains: a kind old gentleman in the barber shop insisted that he take the cap, the day being so hot.
Which was Grandpa all over — open-handed as ever. But where had he got to?
Part Three: Home
Ravi went back to the barber shop. Not there. Not in the park either. He was frantic — his mother had left him in charge. He tried telephoning first his mother and then his father, and both numbers were busy.
Sick with worry, he walked home turning over whether Grandpa would manage the way back.
And the first thing he heard on opening the door came the soft burr of Grandpa's snoring from the bedroom.
He knelt by the bed and laid his cheek on the old man's. There were more creases in that skin than there are lines on a map, and he carried the smell of eucalyptus ointment and shaving cream, and a rush of love went through Ravi, and hugged him; Grandpa did no more than grunt in his sleep.
He made up his mind to ask nothing, because that would mean admitting he had been following him.
The report, and the parcel
At his mother's question about their day, Grandpa answered coolly: he had had a quiet morning, but he did not know about Ravi, who had just disappeared instead of staying at home to look after him.
Ravi looked confused and embarrassed.
Then came a gift-wrapped parcel. His mother protested that Ravi's birthday had been three months ago — had Papa forgotten?
No, said Grandpa. But she knew he always gave a gift to every child in the house on his own birthday. Had she forgotten?
She flushed, and darted a stricken look at the calendar, where she had circled the date in red at the beginning of the year and written Papa's birthday.
There were gifts for her too, and for Ravi's father, since Grandpa still considered them his babies.
And then, to Ravi's father: My daughter needs some Vitamin-M, I think — for her memory.
The last gift
Ravi's parcel held a fat hardback, The Best Detective Stories.
Fine stories, Ravi — there are some very useful hints in there about detective work. How not to be taken in while you are following a suspect, for one thing,* said Grandpa solemnly.
His father, baffled, asked whether Ravi wanted to be a detective at all.
I have not decided yet, Ravi answered — because he was too busy trying to work out whether the glint in Grandpa's eye meant nothing at all or something mischievous.
The story ends there, without telling us.
Concepts and terms
Weak and easily damaged, said of a body rather than a mind. The word is used of Grandpa at the very start, and the rest of the story is about how little it explains.
Small and cramped in an unpleasant way. Grandpa applies it to his daughter's flat, and the word carries his whole objection to the city in four letters.
Moving about unhurriedly doing small jobs. It is what Grandpa was doing in his own garden when he slipped and fell, which is the accident that brought him to the city.
Showed a brief expression of discomfort or embarrassment. Ravi winces at the over-loud voice his mother uses to his grandfather, and that flinch is the first sign of whose side the story is on.
A situation in which a choice must be made between two options, neither of them satisfactory. Ravi's is that escorting Grandpa would hurt him and letting him go would break a promise.
What Students Get Wrong
Did you know
Grandpa is described as bald as a table tennis ball, which is exactly why Ravi thought a visit to a barber was worth investigating.
Every item of the forbidden feast — sugary tea, two bananas and an ice cream — is something banned for him at home.
The mother had circled her father's birthday in red on the calendar at the beginning of the year, and still forgot it.
Memory tricks
Grandpa's route — Park, tea stall, barber, bus. — Four stops, and Ravi is humiliated at each of the first three before being fooled at the fourth.
Why the rule exists — A double dose, a lost walk, a night in the garden. — Three real incidents inside a month, which is why the mother's anxiety is not invented.
Practice MCQs with answers (36)
- A Grandpa, about his daughter's forgetfulness
- B Ravi's mother, about old people in general and her father by implication
- C Ravi, about his own difficulty remembering lessons
- D Ravi's father, about the family's habit of losing things
Show answer
Why:
And by the last page the old man has handed the joke back to her.
- A A hospital admission after a double dose, a walk he could not return from, and a night spent lying in a garden
- B A quarrel with a neighbour, a missed appointment, and a lost wallet
- C A fall on a staircase, a fire in a kitchen, and an argument with a doctor
- D A series of forgotten names, a misplaced newspaper, and a broken spectacle frame
Show answer
Why:
All three inside a single month, which is why the story never mocks her fear.
- A His right as a father to be obeyed without argument
- B A doctor's opinion that walking is good for him
- C Most of seventy-five years spent looking after himself, and ten of keeping house alone
- D The promise his daughter made to his late wife
Show answer
Why:
Competence demonstrated over decades, set against a rule made in a month.
- A He was a teacher, and he explains everything twice
- B He was a lawyer, and a trace of that firmness survives
- C He was a doctor, and he cites medical evidence
- D He was a soldier, and he gives orders rather than reasons
Show answer
Why:
It shows again later, when he traps Ravi with a single question.
- A Grand new flat — comfortable but impersonal
- B Poky little flat — cramped, and unpleasantly so
- C Cold dark flat — badly built and badly lit
- D Busy little flat — full of people at all hours
Show answer
Why:
Four letters carrying his whole objection to the move.
- A A wide veranda, and neighbours who called every evening
- B A big mango tree in the garden, and a quiet in which a falling leaf can be heard
- C A well in the courtyard, and a view of the hills
- D A brick wall he built himself, and a gate his wife painted
Show answer
Why:
Both are the exact opposite of the crowded city he now lives in.
- A On a city street, and he was not found until a passer-by called for help
- B In his own garden, and he lay outside all night because nobody was there to help him up
- C In the flat, and nobody heard him because the television was on
- D At the hospital, where he slipped on a wet corridor floor
Show answer
Why:
The very solitude he valued is what turned a fall into a night outdoors.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Both are true, but the mango tree is not what turns the things he praises into the reason he had to leave.
- A The over-loud tone she uses, as though to a child who cannot hear or understand
- B The list of medicines she leaves behind for him to administer
- C Her insistence that he cancel his plans for the holidays
- D Her refusal to say goodbye to her father at all
Show answer
Why:
The offence is the manner rather than the instruction.
- A He answers her sharply and turns away
- B He asks her to repeat what she has said
- C He rocks gently and gives no sign of having heard her
- D He agrees at once and promises to stay indoors
Show answer
Why:
Whether he has heard is left open, which matters later.
- A Anand against Carlsen, and Tal against Botvinnik
- B Kasparov against Karpov, and Fischer against Tal
- C Karpov against the computer, and Fischer against Spassky
- D Spassky against the computer, and Anand against Kramnik
Show answer
Why:
Recalled move by move, which is precisely the oddity.
- A Whether he has been reading about chess in secret
- B Why he refuses to play against anybody but Ravi
- C How he learned the game without ever taking lessons
- D How a man who holds whole matches in his head loses the names of people he sees every week
Show answer
Why:
The uneven memory that the whole story rests on.
- A By promising to return within ten minutes
- B By offering to take Ravi with him as far as the corner
- C By telephoning his daughter and obtaining her permission
- D By asking whether Ravi has been told to keep him a prisoner, so that denying it concedes the point
Show answer
Why:
The story supplies the adverb for it: craftily.
- A It leaves Grandpa alone in the flat with his medicines
- B It means Ravi will be out when his mother telephones
- C It obliges Ravi to buy a paper he cannot read
- D It shows Grandpa that Ravi has been told to keep him indoors
Show answer
Why:
Grandpa immediately asks whether his daughter has given that instruction.
- A Following him would take the whole day, and staying home would be dull
- B Telling his mother would betray Grandpa, and telling Grandpa would betray his mother
- C Buying the newspaper himself would be quicker, but Grandpa wanted the walk
- D Escorting him openly would hurt him, and letting him go alone would break a promise
Show answer
Why:
His solution — following secretly — is what sets the rest of the story going.
- A Park, tea stall, barber shop, bus
- B Tea stall, park, bus, barber shop
- C Barber shop, park, tea stall, bus
- D Park, barber shop, tea stall, bus
Show answer
Why:
Ravi is humiliated at the first three and fooled at the fourth.
- A A small child finds him behind the bush and offers to show him a better hiding place
- B Grandpa spots him and calls him over to the bench
- C A park attendant asks him to leave the flowerbeds
- D The peanut seller points him out to the crowd
Show answer
Why:
The child's mother then arrives with an umbrella, and he crawls out on all fours.
- A They take him for a new vendor, and say the area is booked by them
- B They believe he is following one of their customers
- C They think he has damaged one of their stalls
- D They object to his hiding behind their banyan tree at night
Show answer
Why:
A misunderstanding, and none of them needs a loudspeaker to say so.
- A Sugary tea, two bananas and an ice cream — every one of them banned for him at home
- B Only a cup of plain tea, which shows his restraint
- C A full meal, which explains why he later fell asleep
- D Medicines he had forgotten to take at home
Show answer
Why:
The day out is partly an escape from the household's rules.
- A The barber shop is on the far side of a dangerous road
- B Grandpa had a haircut only the previous week
- C Grandpa is as bald as a table tennis ball
- D The shop had been closed on every earlier occasion
Show answer
Why:
There is nothing there for him to have cut.
- A He is stopped by a policeman for crossing against the traffic
- B He loses sight of Grandpa in the crowd outside the shop
- C He is recognised by the barber, who tells Grandpa
- D He ducks into the shop next door and is thrown out of a Ladies' Hairdressing Salon
Show answer
Why:
Amid a volley of feminine shrieks, as the story puts it.
- A Grandpa asleep against the window
- B A full head of grey hair, on a total stranger
- C A woman who had taken the cap by mistake
- D The barber from the shop across the road
Show answer
Why:
Grandpa is bald, so the hair settles it immediately.
- A A name written inside the band
- B Its unusual shade of yellow
- C The coffee stain on its rim
- D A tear in the fabric he had noticed earlier
Show answer
Why:
The stranger is also wearing white pyjama and shirt, Grandpa's standard attire.
- A He found it lying on a seat in the bus
- B He bought it that morning at the same shop
- C A kind old gentleman in the barber shop insisted he take it, because the day was hot
- D The barber gave it to him after a customer left it behind
Show answer
Why:
Typical generosity — whatever else it also happened to accomplish.
- A He reports the matter at the police station near the bus stop
- B He waits at the bus stop until the same bus returns
- C He searches the barber shop and the park, telephones both parents and finds the lines busy
- D He goes straight home and tells his mother what has happened
Show answer
Why:
He goes home frantic, wondering whether Grandpa can find his own way back.
- A His mother's voice on the telephone
- B Grandpa complaining about the heat
- C The television reporting the cricket match
- D The gentle whirr of Grandpa snoring in his bedroom
Show answer
Why:
Grandpa had come home well before him.
- A He wakes Grandpa to ask where he had been
- B He searches the room for the yellow cap
- C He kneels, lays his cheek against the old face and hugs him — relief turning into open affection
- D He leaves a note apologising for the afternoon
Show answer
Why:
Grandpa only grunts in his sleep, and Ravi asks nothing.
- A Because his mother had told him not to discuss the day
- B Because Grandpa was too tired to be disturbed
- C Because he had already guessed the whole answer
- D Because asking would mean admitting that he had been following him
Show answer
Why:
A silence that protects him — and leaves Grandpa free to speak first.
- A Warmly — that Ravi had been attentive all day
- B Vaguely — that he could not remember much of it
- C Angrily — that Ravi had followed him about the city
- D Coolly — that he had a quiet morning but Ravi disappeared instead of looking after him
Show answer
Why:
Every word of it true, and Ravi cannot object to any of it.
- A Ravi's, which the family had forgotten three months earlier
- B His late wife's, which he marks with presents each year
- C His own, and he gives a gift to every child in the house on that day
- D Ravi's mother's, which he had remembered and she had not
Show answer
Why:
There are gifts for Ravi's parents too, since he still considers them his babies.
- A Circled it in red on the calendar and written Papa's birthday beside it
- B Entered it in her office diary for a day's leave
- C Told Ravi to remind her when it came round
- D Arranged for a gift to be delivered on the day
Show answer
Why:
Which is precisely why her forgetting it is worth the story's attention.
- A That Ravi should be sent out more often on his own
- B That his daughter needs some Vitamin-M, for her memory
- C That the flat is too small for four people
- D That he intends to return to his brick house
Show answer
Why:
The joke of the opening scene, handed back without a raised voice.
- A A chess set, with advice on studying famous openings
- B A yellow cap, with advice on wearing it in the sun
- C A map of the city, with advice on finding one's way home
- D A book of detective stories, with tips on how not to be fooled while trailing a suspect
Show answer
Why:
Delivered solemnly, which is what makes it impossible to answer.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
It ends on a twinkle Ravi cannot read, and says no more.
- A Explaining to his father why he wants to be a detective
- B Trying to decide whether the twinkle in Grandpa's eye is innocent or mischievous
- C Apologising to his mother for leaving the flat
- D Reading the first of the detective stories aloud
Show answer
Why:
He answers his father's question with I have not decided yet, for a different reason.
- A The description of Grandpa's walking stick
- B The advice about not being fooled while trailing a suspect
- C The mention of the cricket match on television
- D The name of the newspaper Grandpa went out to buy
Show answer
Why:
Without it the gift is only a book, and the twinkle means nothing.
Important short questions (6)
Because everything he valued had been taken away at once. He hated the noise and bustle of city life, and the flat was poky and little compared with his own brick house, which had a big mango tree and a quiet so complete that a falling leaf could be heard at dusk. Worse, he was forbidden to go out alone, having looked after himself for most of seventy-five years.
Because of three incidents, all real and all recent. He had been admitted to hospital after absent-mindedly taking a double dose of his medicines. He had gone for a walk and forgotten the way back home. And before that he had fallen while pottering in his own garden and lain outside all night, since nobody was there to help him up. Her fear was earned rather than imagined.
No. The clearest sign is that he winces at the over-loud tone she uses when speaking to him, as though to a child who cannot hear or understand. He also tells Grandpa, loyally, that his mother would never treat him like a baby or a prisoner — and he feels guilty for a moment first, which shows he knows the charge is not groundless.
At the park he crouched behind a bush trimmed like an elephant. A small child found him and offered to show him a better hiding place. The child's mother threatened him with an umbrella, and he had to crawl out on all fours. At the tea stall he hid behind a banyan tree and was surrounded by vendors who took him for a rival and told him the area was booked by them.
He had been following a bright-yellow cap. On the bus its wearer took it off in the heat and turned out to have a full head of grey hair, while Grandpa is bald. The man was a stranger, though he wore white pyjama and shirt, Grandpa's usual attire, and the cap carried the same coffee stain on its rim. A kind old gentleman at the barber shop had pressed it on him because the day was hot.
He heard Grandpa snoring in his bedroom, knelt beside him and hugged him, and decided not to ask any questions, since asking would confess that he had followed him. The parcel was a birthday gift — Grandpa's own birthday, on which he gives a present to every child in the house. Ravi's was a book of detective stories, offered with advice on how not to be fooled while trailing a suspect.
Long answer questions (3)
He leaves having talked Ravi into permission, carrying a shiny black mahogany stick with a brass eagle's head and wearing a bright-yellow cap, twirling the stick jauntily. Ravi, caught between hurting him and breaking a promise, decides to follow secretly.
The first stop is the children's park. Grandpa buys a paper cone of peanuts and settles on a bench to watch the children. Ravi crouches behind a bush trimmed like an elephant, is discovered by a small child offering a better hiding place, is threatened with an umbrella by the child's mother, and crawls out of the park on all fours.
The second is the tea stall. Ravi takes position behind a big banyan and is at once surrounded by vendors who take him for a rival and inform him that the area is booked. Driven behind a silver car, he watches Grandpa work through a sugary tea, two bananas and an ice cream — every one of them forbidden at home.
Grandpa then zigzags across the traffic into a barber shop. Since he is bald as a table tennis ball this deserves investigating, so Ravi crosses, ducks into the shop next door and is thrown out of a Ladies' Hairdressing Salon.
Finally Grandpa walks briskly to the bus stop and boards. Ravi sprints and jumps on, follows the yellow cap to the front — and finds a stranger with a full head of grey hair underneath it.
The opening invites the reader to accept it. His daughter says he does not hear, see or remember too well; he sits frail in a rocking chair with the paper inches from his nose; and within a month he has taken a double dose of medicine and lost his way home from a walk.
But the evidence against the description begins almost at once.
At chess he is cool and cunning, and recalls whole games move by move — the opening Karpov made against the computer, the mistake Fischer made against Spassky. Ravi cannot reconcile that with a man who forgets the names of people he meets often.
He then handles Ravi with complete precision. One question about being kept a prisoner forces a loyal denial, and the denial becomes permission. The story supplies the adverb: craftily.
He knows the household's rules well enough to break every one of them in an afternoon, and remembers his way home through a city he dislikes, arriving well before the boy who was following him.
And he remembers his own birthday, together with a custom of long standing, when the daughter who circled the date in red at the beginning of the year has forgotten it entirely.
So the failing is real but narrow — names, doses, a route taken once. Judgement, wit and long memory are untouched, and the story's joke is that the one person who forgets something that matters is not the old man.
Ravi comes home frantic, having searched the barber shop and the park and failed to reach either parent by telephone, and hears the gentle whirr of Grandpa snoring in his bedroom. He kneels, puts his cheek against a face with more creases than a map has lines, and hugs him; Grandpa only grunts. Ravi decides to ask nothing, because asking would confess.
When his mother returns and asks about the day, Grandpa answers coolly that he had a quiet morning but cannot speak for Ravi, who disappeared instead of staying at home as instructed. Every word is true, and Ravi can object to none of it.
Then a gift-wrapped parcel appears. His mother protests that Ravi's birthday was three months ago — has Papa forgotten? No, says Grandpa: she knows he gives a present to every child in the house on his own birthday. Has she forgotten? She flushes and darts a stricken look at the calendar, where she had circled the date in red at the start of the year. There are gifts for both parents too, since he still considers them his babies.
And then, to Ravi's father: his daughter needs some Vitamin-M, for her memory.
Ravi's parcel holds a book of detective stories, offered with the solemn observation that it contains good tips on how to avoid being fooled while trailing a suspect.
The story ends with Ravi trying to decide whether the twinkle in his grandfather's eye is innocent or mischievous — and it refuses to tell him, because the pleasure of the ending lies in not being certain.
Flashcards (20)
Play this topic
- Match the Word to Its Meaning
- True or False: The Story
- Complete the Statement
- Unscramble the Words of the Story
The People, and What the Story Is Saying
Three people, one disagreement, and a joke that comes back round. This topic examines Grandpa, Ravi and Vidya as the story draws them, works out what the story actually argues about age and capability, and reads the title and the twist.
What you will be able to do
- Describe Grandpa's character using evidence from three different parts of the story.
- Trace how Ravi's position shifts between the opening scene and the last page.
- Explain why Vidya is treated sympathetically even though the story disagrees with her.
- State what the story argues about old age, and how it avoids preaching.
- Explain the title and the twist, and say what the story deliberately leaves unsettled.
Key points
Grandpa is proud, independent, witty and generous, and the story proves each of those with an incident rather than an adjective.
His memory fails for doses, routes and names, and holds firm for chess games, birthdays and household rules — which is why the label pinned on him in the first scene does not fit.
Ravi begins as the enforcer of a rule he does not believe in, and ends as somebody who has been quietly taught a lesson.
Vidya's fear is grounded in three genuine incidents, so the story criticises her manner rather than her motive.
The over-loud voice is the story's real target: being managed is presented as more wounding than being restricted.
The title turns twice — first as Vidya's joke about old people, then as Grandpa's remark about his daughter's memory.
The twist is that the supposedly helpless old man outmanoeuvres the boy who was minding him, and the cap is the instrument.
The story ends without confirming whether Grandpa knew, because an unproved suspicion is funnier and kinder than a confession.
Full explanation
Grandpa
The story never hands out adjectives. It supplies incidents and expects the reader to do the naming.
Proud
When he is forbidden the street, he does not sulk. He states a record: most of seventy-five years looking after himself, and ten since his wife died in which he has cooked, shopped and kept house. The firmness in it is a trace of his old profession as a lawyer.
What offends him is not the danger. It is being told.
Independent
He misses a house he ran alone, and he says so in terms that are all about self-sufficiency: his own garden, his own quiet, his own routine. The city flat is poky, and the word does double duty — small, and beneath him.
Witty
He does not argue his way out of the rule. He engineers his way out with one question:
Has she told you I am not to go out alone? Has she told you to keep me here like a prisoner?
Ravi, who genuinely does not think of his grandfather as a prisoner, denies it loyally — and the denial is the permission. The story supplies the adverb in the narration: craftily.
Generous
He gives his cap to a stranger in a barber shop because the day is hot. He gives presents to every child in the house on his own birthday, and counts his grown daughter and her husband among the children.
The cap is the story's best single detail, because it is generous and strategic at once, and the reader is never told which it mainly was.
The memory question
He has genuinely taken a double dose, and genuinely lost his way on a walk. He forgets the names of people he meets often.
But he holds whole chess games — Karpov against the computer, Fischer against Spassky — move by move. He knows every household rule well enough to break each one in an afternoon. He finds his own way home through a city he dislikes, arriving before the boy following him. And he remembers his birthday when his daughter, who ringed it in red in January, does not.
So the label fixed to him in the first scene is not false — it is too broad. That gap is the story.
Ravi
Ravi is the only person in the story who changes.
Where he starts
He begins as the enforcer of a rule he does not believe in. He warns his mother that Grandpa will hear her; he winces at her tone; he tells Grandpa loyally that she would never treat him like a baby.
But he has promised. So he is stuck.
The dilemma
Going along openly would wound an old man who has just objected to being managed. Letting him go alone would break the promise. Neither is safe and neither is honourable, and the compromise he invents — follow, unseen — is the whole plot.
It is also, quietly, the wrong choice. It keeps the promise in letter while treating his grandfather exactly as his mother did: as somebody to be managed without being consulted.
What the afternoon does to him
The comedy is not decoration. Every humiliation is a small demonstration that he is not equal to the job he has taken on: chased out of a park by an umbrella, mistaken for a vendor, thrown out of a hairdresser's, and finally following a cap rather than a person.
Where he ends
He comes home frantic, finds the man asleep, and does something the opening scene would not have predicted: he kneels, puts his cheek against the old face and hugs him.
Then he decides to ask nothing — because asking would confess.
And at the table he is answered without being accused, thanked without being forgiven, and handed a book about not being fooled while following somebody. He cannot object to any of it.
Vidya
It would be easy to make her the villain. The story declines.
Her case
Three incidents inside a month: hospital after a doubled dose, a walk he could not return from, a night spent lying in a garden because nobody was there to help him up. She locked the house and brought him away because the alternative was to leave him there.
The story never once suggests she is wrong to be frightened.
Her fault
It is entirely in the delivery.
- The rule is announced, not discussed.
- The tone is over-loud, as though to a child who cannot follow.
- The medicines are handed to her son rather than to her father.
Each of these says the same thing: decisions about him are made around him.
Her moment
When the parcel appears she is genuinely stricken. She flushes, and looks at a calendar where she had circled the date in red at the start of the year.
That is why the ending lands as comedy rather than cruelty. She is not exposed as unloving. She is exposed as forgetful — and she had been the one laughing about forgetfulness.
What the Story Argues
Age is not one thing
A person can need supervision over medicines and need none at all over decisions. The story's whole method is to split those two apart and show a family treating them as one.
Dignity is separate from safety
The restriction may be justified. The manner is not. The story's sharpest moment is not the rule but the voice, and the detail it chooses to make that point is Ravi's wince.
It argues by showing
There is no speech about respecting the elderly anywhere in this story. The case is made entirely by events: a chess game, a trap, an afternoon, a cap and a parcel. That is why it does not read as a lecture.
The Title and the Twist
Two turns
The title begins as Vidya's joke: somebody should invent a memory vitamin for old people. It is made across her father's head, on the assumption that he cannot hear.
It ends as Grandpa's answer, delivered mildly to her husband: his daughter needs some Vitamin-M, for her memory.
Same phrase, opposite target, and no voice raised in between.
The twist
The boy set to mind the old man is the one who gets lost. The cap does it — given away, honestly and plausibly, to a stranger dressed exactly as its owner dresses, at the one stop where Ravi could not follow him inside.
What is left open
Did Grandpa know?
The evidence: the cap to a look-alike; the cool report that Ravi disappeared; a book about not being fooled while trailing a suspect; and the word solemnly attached to the advice.
But the story never says. It stops with Ravi studying a twinkle and unable to tell whether it is innocent or mischievous.
Settling it would spoil it. Unproved, the joke is kind: Ravi is answered without ever being charged, and can never quite establish that he was.
Concepts and terms
Showing what a person is like by what they do rather than by describing them. The story never calls Grandpa clever; it lets him trap Ravi with a single question and leaves the reader to draw the conclusion.
A gap between what is said or expected and what turns out to be true. Here the woman who jokes about failing memory is the one who forgets the birthday she had circled in red.
A situation in which the person supposed to be in charge turns out to be the one being managed. Ravi is set to mind Grandpa and spends the afternoon being led round a city.
Treating somebody as less capable than they are, usually while believing oneself kind. The over-loud voice is the story's chosen example of it.
Leaving a question genuinely open. The twinkle in the last sentence has two possible meanings and the story refuses to pick one.
What Students Get Wrong
Did you know
Grandpa never once raises his voice at his daughter in the entire story, though he wins every exchange he takes part in.
The word the story chooses for how he obtains permission is craftily — placed in the narration, not in dialogue, so the reader is told before Ravi works it out.
He gives gifts to Ravi's parents too, because he still considers them his babies — which quietly reverses who is minding whom.
Memory tricks
Grandpa's four qualities — Proud, independent, witty, generous. — Each has its own scene: the argument, the ten years of housekeeping, the trap, and the cap given away.
The title's two turns — Her joke, his answer. — The same phrase opens the story about him and closes it about her.
Practice MCQs with answers (26)
- A It never says so; it shows him obtaining permission with one question and supplies only the adverb
- B It says so twice, in the opening and closing paragraphs
- C It has Ravi's father describe him as clever at the dinner table
- D It relies on Vidya's description of her father's legal career
Show answer
Why:
Characterisation through incident: the reader does the naming.
- A Generosity — the record of seventy-five years he cites when forbidden the street
- B Independence — the question about being kept a prisoner
- C Wit — the ten years of cooking and shopping after his wife died
- D Generosity — the cap handed to a stranger because the day was hot
Show answer
Why:
The others match the right qualities to the wrong scenes.
- A The correct dose of his medicines
- B Whole chess games, recalled move by move
- C The route home from an unfamiliar walk
- D The names of people he meets often
Show answer
Why:
The gap between the two lists is what the story is built on.
- A Because none of the incidents behind it ever took place
- B Because it was made by somebody who had not met him
- C Because it describes his eyesight correctly but his hearing wrongly
- D Because the failures it names are real, but it treats a narrow lapse as a general decline
Show answer
Why:
Judgement, wit and long memory are untouched throughout.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
He never once argues that the streets are safe.
- A Crowded — that the family has too many members for the space
- B Horrible — that the building itself is badly maintained
- C Little — that the rooms are too small for his furniture
- D Poky — that the flat is beneath the house and the life he was taken from
Show answer
Why:
Size, and status, in four letters.
- A Agreeing wholeheartedly with his mother's assessment of his grandfather
- B Planning from the first page to help his grandfather escape the flat
- C Enforcing a rule he does not believe in, having already given his word
- D Indifferent to the argument and interested only in the cricket match
Show answer
Why:
He warns his mother, winces at her tone, and defends Grandpa to his face.
- A It puts his grandfather in greater physical danger than staying home would have
- B It breaks the promise to his mother as completely as walking out would have
- C It requires him to lie to his grandfather's face before he leaves
- D It keeps the promise in letter while managing his grandfather without consulting him
Show answer
Why:
He repeats the very fault he had winced at an hour earlier.
- A They delay the plot so that the day can plausibly last until evening
- B They establish the geography of the city for the final chase
- C They show that Ravi is not equal to the task he has taken on, so the reversal lands
- D They show that strangers in the city are hostile to children
Show answer
Why:
Comedy doing structural work rather than decoration.
- A Ravi checking whether his grandfather had taken his medicines
- B Ravi kneeling, laying his cheek against the old face and embracing him
- C Ravi searching the room for evidence of the afternoon
- D Ravi telephoning his mother to report that all was well
Show answer
Why:
Relief turning into open affection, and no questions asked afterwards.
- A 1 and 3 only
- B 1 and 2 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The story criticises her manner and never questions her affection.
- A The rule being announced rather than discussed
- B His habit of holding the newspaper close to his face
- C The over-loud tone used when addressing him
- D The medicines being handed to her son rather than to him
Show answer
Why:
That one is only a description of his eyesight.
- A Because nobody present understands what her father has said
- B Because she laughs at the remark along with everybody else
- C Because she is exposed as forgetful rather than unloving, having herself joked about forgetfulness
- D Because her father apologises immediately afterwards
Show answer
Why:
She flushes and looks at a calendar she had marked in January.
- A That old people should never be restricted under any circumstances
- B That families are usually right to take charge of an elderly relative
- C That a person may need supervision over some things and none at all over others
- D That memory loss in old age is generally imaginary
Show answer
Why:
The harm comes from treating the two as one question.
- A Through a speech by Ravi's father at the end of the story
- B Through a narrator who comments on each scene as it closes
- C Through events alone — a chess game, a trap, an afternoon out, a cap and a parcel
- D Through a letter Grandpa writes to his daughter
Show answer
Why:
There is no speech about respecting the elderly anywhere in it.
- A It begins as her joke about old people and ends as his remark about her memory
- B It begins as a medical term and ends as the name of a shop
- C It begins as Ravi's nickname for his grandfather and ends as a family saying
- D It begins as a slogan on the medicine bottle and ends as a title for the book
Show answer
Why:
Same phrase, opposite target, and no voice raised in between.
- A It is left behind on a seat where Ravi is certain to find it
- B It is passed on plausibly, to a man dressed exactly as its owner dresses, at the one stop Ravi could not enter
- C It is the only bright-coloured object anywhere in the story
- D It is described in the opening paragraph and never mentioned again
Show answer
Why:
Generosity and strategy at once, and the reader is never told which dominated.
- A The cap passed to a man in his own style of dress
- B His cool report that Ravi disappeared instead of looking after him
- C His complaint that the flat is poky and the city crowded
- D The book about not being fooled while trailing a suspect
Show answer
Why:
That complaint belongs to the opening argument, well before the afternoon.
- A Unproved, the joke stays kind; proved, it would become a scolding
- B It would make the detective book seem an unsuitable gift
- C It would contradict the description of his memory in the opening scene
- D It would require the story to continue for several more pages
Show answer
Why:
Ravi is answered without ever being charged, and cannot establish that he was.
- A Role reversal
- B Alliteration
- C Personification
- D Foreshadowing
Show answer
Why:
Ravi even receives a gift as a child, alongside his own parents.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Her fear is grounded in three real incidents and she is dismayed at the close. The assertion holds, the reason is false.
- A Solemnly — placed in dialogue, so Ravi hears it before the reader does
- B Craftily — placed in the narration, so the reader is told before Ravi works it out
- C Jauntily — placed at the moment of departure, to suggest carelessness
- D Frantically — placed at the end, to describe his state of mind
Show answer
Why:
The reader is ahead of Ravi from that sentence onward.
- A Memory and eyesight
- B City and village
- C Comedy and plot
- D Safety and dignity
Show answer
Why:
The restriction may be justified while the manner remains indefensible.
- A The list of medicines left on a saucer
- B The rocking chair in the sitting room
- C Ravi's wince at his mother's tone
- D The reference to Grandpa's brick house
Show answer
Why:
A flinch, placed before anybody has left the flat.
- A He gives gifts he had bought for himself that morning
- B He gives to Ravi's parents too, since he still considers them his babies
- C He refuses to accept any gift in return
- D He gives the same gift to every member of the family
Show answer
Why:
The people minding him are, in his household custom, still the children.
- A It states its moral in the opening paragraph and then illustrates it
- B It leaves its moral to a closing speech by Grandpa
- C It relies on a narrator who explains each character's motives
- D It argues its case entirely through events and never states a moral
Show answer
Why:
Which is exactly why it does not read as a lecture.
Important short questions (6)
By supplying incidents and letting the reader name the quality. His pride appears in the record he cites when he is forbidden the street. His independence in ten years of cooking and keeping house alone. His wit in the single question that turns Ravi's loyal denial into permission. And his generosity in the cap he hands to a stranger and the gifts he gives on his own birthday. The only label the narration offers is the adverb craftily.
It is well meant, since he is trying to protect an old man without wounding him, but it keeps his promise only in letter. By shadowing his grandfather instead of speaking to him, he does exactly what his mother had done: he makes a decision about the old man without consulting him. He repeats the very fault he had winced at an hour earlier, and the afternoon's humiliations follow from it.
No. Her fear rests on three real incidents within a month — a hospital admission after a doubled dose, a walk from which her father could not find his way back, and a night he spent lying in his garden. She locked the house and brought him away because the alternative was leaving him there. What the story criticises is her manner: a rule announced rather than discussed, an over-loud tone, and medicines handed to her son rather than her father.
That age is not a single condition. A person may need supervision over medicines and none whatever over decisions, and a family that treats the two as one question does real harm. It also insists that dignity is separate from safety: the restriction may be justified while the manner is not. It avoids preaching by containing no speech on the subject at all, making its case entirely through a chess game, a trap, an afternoon out, a cap and a parcel.
It begins as Vidya's joke, made across her father's head on the assumption that he cannot hear: somebody should invent a memory vitamin for old people. It ends as Grandpa's reply, delivered mildly to her husband, that his daughter needs some of that vitamin for her own memory. The same phrase, aimed the opposite way, with no voice raised in between — and with the calendar she had marked in January standing as proof.
Because the ambiguity is what keeps the ending generous. The evidence points one way — the cap given to a look-alike, the cool report of Ravi's disappearance, a book about not being fooled while trailing a suspect, and the word solemnly attached to the advice. But left unproved, Ravi is answered without ever being accused, and can never quite establish that he was. Proved, the same act would be a scolding.
Long answer questions (3)
He is seventy-five, a retired lawyer, and a widower of ten years who kept his own house until a fall ended the arrangement. The story describes him once as frail and then spends the rest of its length correcting the impression.
He is proud. Forbidden the street, he does not plead but states a record: most of seventy-five years spent looking after himself, ten of them cooking, shopping and keeping house alone. The firmness is a trace of his profession.
He is fiercely independent. Everything he misses about his brick house is an image of self-sufficiency — his own garden, his own routine, a quiet so complete that a falling leaf could be heard. The flat is poky, and the word carries both a size and a verdict.
He is witty, and the story shows it rather than saying it. He does not argue the rule away; he asks whether his daughter has told Ravi to keep him a prisoner, and the loyal denial that follows becomes the permission he wanted. The narration supplies one word for the manoeuvre: craftily.
He is generous without calculation, or at least without any the reader can prove. He presses his cap on a stranger in a barber shop because the day is hot, and he gives presents to every child in the house on his own birthday — counting his grown daughter and her husband among the children.
And his memory is not what anyone has called it. He loses doses, routes and the names of people he meets often. He holds whole chess games, every household rule, his way home through a city he dislikes, and a birthday his daughter had circled in red and forgotten.
What emerges is a man whose failings are narrow and real, and whose judgement is entirely intact — which is exactly the distinction the family around him has stopped making.
It begins by giving her a case that cannot be dismissed. Three things happened to her father inside one month. He doubled his medicines absent-mindedly and was taken to hospital; he set out for a walk and could not find his way back; and, earliest of the three, he fell in his garden and lay there till morning with nobody in the house to help. She locked that house and brought him to the city because the alternative was to leave him in it. At no point does the story suggest her fear is invented.
Having granted her the argument, it then attacks the delivery.
The rule is announced rather than discussed; her father is informed of a decision about his own life. The tone is over-loud, as though addressed to a child who cannot hear or follow. The medicines are handed to her son rather than to the man who will take them. Each detail says the same thing: decisions about him are made around him.
And the story places its verdict early, in a single gesture. Ravi winces. That flinch tells the reader whose side the narrative is on before any of the action has started.
Yet the ending refuses cruelty. When the parcel arrives and she realises whose birthday it is, she flushes and darts a stricken look at the calendar where she had circled the date in red at the beginning of the year. She is not exposed as unloving. She is exposed as forgetful — she, who had opened the story laughing about forgetfulness in old people.
So the correction lands exactly where the fault was, and nowhere else. She is answered, not condemned, and there are gifts for her too.
The twist reverses the whole arrangement. A boy is left in charge of an old man said to be failing. By evening it is the boy who has lost his charge, searched half a city, failed to reach either parent and come home frightened — while the old man has found his own way back and gone to sleep.
The cap is the instrument, and it is well chosen. It is given away in the one place Ravi cannot follow him into, to a stranger wearing the white pyjama and shirt that are Grandpa's own habitual dress, with a plausible and entirely characteristic reason attached: it was such a hot day. Ravi has been tracking a colour rather than a face, and the colour walks onto a bus without him.
Then the evidence accumulates. Grandpa reports coolly that Ravi disappeared instead of looking after him — every word true, and impossible to contest without confessing. He gives a book of detective stories. He attaches advice about how to avoid being fooled while trailing a suspect. And he delivers it solemnly.
Any one of these could be innocent. Together they are hard to read as accident.
But the story never says, and the final sentence makes the refusal deliberate: Ravi is left trying to decide whether the twinkle in his grandfather's eye is an innocent gleam or a mischievous one, and answers his father's unrelated question absent-mindedly because of it.
The reason for leaving it there is a matter of tone. Proved, the afternoon becomes a punishment and the gift becomes a rebuke; the old man would have won by humiliating a boy who meant well. Unproved, Ravi is answered without ever being charged — he knows what he did, he cannot be certain anybody else does, and nothing needs to be said aloud. The doubt is what keeps the victory a kind one.
Flashcards (20)
Play this topic
- Match the Term to Its Meaning
- True or False: People and Meaning
- Complete the Statement
- Unscramble the Critical Terms
The Language and Skills Work of This Lesson
Movement words against sound words, six words pinned down with their parts of speech, prepositions, the two kinds of question and how to report them, five intonation patterns, a podcast on meditation, and a second story about a child who loses his parents at a fair.
What you will be able to do
- Sort the lesson's word bank into movement words and sound words, and use them in a passage.
- Give the meaning, part of speech and a synonym for the six words in the vocabulary table.
- Choose the right preposition for direction, location, time and manner.
- Distinguish wh-type from yes-or-no questions and convert both into reported speech.
- Apply the five intonation patterns and summarise the podcast on meditation.
- Relate The Lost Child to the ideas of the main lesson.
Key points
The word bank splits into two columns: movement words such as pottering, ducked and sprinting, and sound words such as boomed, shrieks and whirr.
The two synonyms the lesson asks for alongside dilemma are quandary and predicament.
Six words go into the table with meaning, part of speech, synonym and antonym: craftily, dilemma, furious, boomed, humiliation and attire.
Five emotion words are matched to five meanings out of six offered, with one meaning left over.
A preposition shows the relationship of a noun or pronoun to other words, indicating direction, location, time or manner.
Interrogative sentences come in two kinds — wh-type and yes-or-no type — and each is reported differently.
Reporting a question means turning it into a statement, adding if or whether for yes-or-no questions and repeating the wh-word for the other kind.
Intonation is the pitch of the voice, and the lesson gives five patterns, including a rise-fall for questions offering a choice.
Full explanation
Movement Words and Sound Words
The lesson hands over a box of twenty words and asks for two columns.
Column 1 — movement
pottering, ducked, evicted, jumping, crawl, briskly, darted, twirling, creeping, zigzagging, sprinting, trailing, crouch
Every one describes what a body is doing, or the manner in which it does it.
Column 2 — sound
boomed, bustle, shrieks, thudded, whirr, grunted, snoring
Every one describes what reaches an ear.
The practice passage
The gap-fill is about a detective following a suspect through dimly lit lanes — which is a joke the story has already set up. Heavy footsteps thudded; the man had to crouch behind market stalls and go zigzagging through the lanes; he boomed when he hit a pole; and what was left behind was the distant whirr of a sleeping city.
Why it matters. A scene is built out of both columns at once. Take away the sound words from the barber-shop episode and the shrieks that get Ravi evicted vanish with them.
Words to Pin Down
Two names for one fix
Alongside dilemma the lesson asks for two words spelled out with letters missing:
- QUANDARY
- PREDICAMENT
All three name a situation in which no available choice is comfortable — which is exactly Ravi's position at the door.
The table of six
| Word | Part of speech | Meaning | Synonym |
|---|---|---|---|
| craftily | adverb | in a cunning, indirect way | slyly |
| dilemma | noun | a choice between two poor options | quandary |
| furious | adjective | extremely angry | enraged |
| boomed | verb | sounded loudly and deeply | thundered |
| humiliation | noun | loss of dignity before others | embarrassment |
| attire | noun | clothing, dress | garments |
Note that attire is a noun here, not a verb, and that it is the word attached to Grandpa's white pyjama and shirt.
Emotions and expressions
Five words are matched to meanings, and one meaning is left over.
- embarrassed — felt uncomfortable
- countered — replied to an argument
- flushed — became red in the face
- stricken — affected severely by an unpleasant feeling
- gleam — an expression of emotion
The extra meaning is to be confused, which matches none of the five.
Three of these five words are the ones the last page of the story runs on: Vidya flushed, darted a stricken look at the calendar, and Grandpa countered with a question of his own.
Prepositions
A preposition shows how a noun or pronoun stands in relation to the other words around it — usually direction, location, time or manner.
The lesson pulls four out of the story itself:
- walk across to the corner shop
- a shadow fall over him
- the vendors sitting under the tree
- took position behind a big banyan
The passage
The practice paragraph is a walk: through a village, over a brook, near a cottage, sitting in the garden, strolling along a riverbank, heading towards the unknown.
Notice how each one does a different job. Through is a path taken inside something; over crosses above it; near is only proximity; along follows a line.
Questions, and How to Report Them
Two kinds
All the quoted sentences are interrogative. They divide into:
- Yes-or-no type — Shall we play chess or watch the cricket match? / Have you forgotten? / Are you playing hide and seek?
- Wh-type — Who are you? / What did you both do today?
So there are two kinds of interrogative sentence, not three.
Direct into indirect
Words inside quotation marks are the speaker's own — direct speech. When somebody else repeats them at another time and place, that is indirect or reported speech.
Three sets of things shift:
Tense — present goes to past; present progressive to past progressive; past to past perfect; past progressive to past perfect progressive.
Pronouns — I becomes he or she; we becomes they; our becomes their.
Time and place — here becomes there; today becomes that day; tomorrow becomes the following day; now becomes then.
The three steps
- Turn the interrogative into a declarative sentence — subject before verb, no question mark.
- For a yes-or-no question, join with if or whether.
- For a wh- question, repeat the same wh-word as the joining word.
Worked example
Direct: "Do you help in taking care of your grandparents at home?" asked Arvind.
Reported: Arvind asked Priya whether she helped in taking care of her grandparents at home.
The question became a statement, do you help became she helped, your became her, and whether built the bridge.
Intonation
Intonation is the pitch of the voice while speaking. In questions it signals the sentiment, or the answer expected.
The lesson gives five patterns:
| Kind of question | Pitch at the end | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Wh- and how questions | Falling | Information is being requested, not confirmation |
| Yes-or-no questions | Rising | The answer is genuinely open |
| Affirmative clause + negative tag | Rising | The speaker is fairly sure of the answer |
| Negative clause + affirmative tag | Falling | The speaker is unsure |
| A question offering a choice | Rise-fall | Up on the first option, down on the second |
The task is then to go back into the story, pick out different questions and say them aloud in pairs using these patterns — and the story is full of them, from Who are you? to Has she told you I am not to go out alone?
The Podcast on Meditation
A listening passage introduces meditation as an important yogic practice, commonly used for relaxation and stress management.
What it claims:
- It gives rest and peace to the mind, clearing away the thoughts that cause stress.
- It improves well-being physically and emotionally.
- Afterwards a person feels fresh and gains a new perspective on stressful situations.
- It reduces negative emotions and increases self-awareness.
- Practised daily it becomes a routine, influencing memory power.
- Regular practice helps in handling exam-related pressure with ease.
The listening exercise asks for answers of not more than three exact words taken from what is heard — so the skill being tested is precise catching, not paraphrase.
Speaking and Writing
The presentation
A short personal account of caring for an older person, structured in three parts: the background of the experience; what you learned about yourself, including any strength you did not know you had; and what you learned about the older person — their needs, preferences and the difficulties of ageing.
The article
'Our Inspiring Elderly', for a school magazine, in four paragraphs:
- Introduce the topic — the main idea only, no detail.
- Support it — how the elderly inspire, with examples, facts and quotations.
- Elaborate — how they overcame challenges, and the effect that had on you.
- Conclude — a final comment leaving the reader with the central idea.
The title goes at the top, with your name and grade below it.
Learning Beyond the Text: The Lost Child
Mulk Raj Anand's story is printed here in full. It is a spring festival, and a small boy is walking with his parents to a fair.
The pattern of the first half
Five times the boy is drawn to something, and five times he moves on without asking properly:
- a toy in a roadside shop — he pleads, and his father's look refuses him
- burfi at the sweet stall — he murmurs the request, knowing he will be called greedy
- a garland of gulmohur — he half-murmurs it, knowing they will call the flowers cheap
- balloons on a pole — he says nothing, knowing he will be called too old for toys
- a snake-charmer's flute — he goes closer, then walks on, because such music is forbidden
Each time the refusal is anticipated rather than spoken. And through all of it the parents' one repeated phrase is a call to come along.
The turn
At the roundabout he finally makes a bold request — and there is no reply. His parents are not ahead of him, not to either side, not behind.
The second half
Now a stranger picks him up out of a crush at a temple entrance and offers him, one after another, the roundabout, the snake-charmer's music, a balloon, a garland and sweets — the same five temptations in reverse order.
He refuses all five. His only answer is that he wants his mother and his father, and the story ends there.
Why it is printed with this lesson
Two stories about care, arranged as mirrors.
In Vitamin-M an old man is treated as less capable than he is, and demonstrates otherwise. In The Lost Child a boy is given everything except the one thing he actually needs.
Both turn on the same failure: attending to a person's wants instead of listening to the person. In one story the answer is a cap and a parcel; in the other it is five refusals and a single repeated cry.
Concepts and terms
One set tells you how a body travels — pottering, crawling, darting, zigzagging. The other tells you what the air carries — boomed, shrieks, thudded, whirr. Sorting them is a way of noticing that a scene is built from both at once.
A word showing how a noun or pronoun stands in relation to the rest of the sentence — its direction, location, time or manner. Across, over, under and behind all appear in phrases taken straight from the story.
A sentence that asks. The lesson separates two kinds: those opening with a wh-word, answered with information, and those answered with yes or no.
Somebody repeating another person's words at a different time and place. Tenses shift back, pronouns change, and words of time and place move with them — here becomes there, today becomes that day.
The pitch of the voice as it rises or falls. It carries meaning on its own: the same words can express certainty or doubt depending on where the voice goes at the end.
What Students Get Wrong
Did you know
The practice passage for the word bank is itself about a detective following a suspect, which is exactly the skill the story's last page jokes about.
The matching exercise on emotions offers six meanings for five words, so one meaning is deliberately left unused.
The podcast says that meditation increases self-awareness and can lessen exam-related pressure.
Memory tricks
The two columns — Feet in one, ears in the other. — Movement words are things a body does; sound words are things a listener receives.
Reporting a question — Flatten it, then bridge it. — Turn the question into a statement, then join it with if or whether, or with the same wh-word.
Intonation — Wh- falls, yes-or-no rises. — And a question offering a choice does both — up, then down.
Practice MCQs with answers (34)
- A It is an adjective and belongs in neither column
- B It describes the manner of moving rather than anything heard
- C It describes a body at rest rather than in motion
- D It appears only in the practice passage and not in the box
Show answer
Why:
The sound column holds boomed, bustle, shrieks, thudded, whirr, grunted and snoring.
- A Crouch, thudded, creeping
- B Darted, whirr, sprinting
- C Crouch, darted, creeping
- D Twirling, grunted, crawl
Show answer
Why:
Thudded, whirr and grunted all belong to the other column.
- A Boomed
- B Darted
- C Crouched
- D Zigzagged
Show answer
Why:
The others are all movement words from the first column.
- A The passage repeats the plot of the story exactly
- B It is the only exercise in the unit that uses complete sentences
- C The detective in it is described as an elderly man
- D The story's closing gift is a book about not being fooled while trailing a suspect
Show answer
Why:
The exercise and the last page of the story share their joke.
- A Confusion and hesitation
- B Argument and objection
- C Quandary and predicament
- D Difficulty and obstacle
Show answer
Why:
All three name a position in which no available choice is comfortable.
- A It is a noun there, meaning clothing — the white pyjama and shirt
- B It is an adjective there, describing somebody well dressed
- C It is an adverb there, describing the manner of dressing
- D It does not appear in the table at all
Show answer
Why:
Part of speech is half of what the table is testing.
- A Craftily — adjective
- B Craftily — adverb
- C Humiliation — verb
- D Furious — noun
Show answer
Why:
Humiliation is a noun and furious an adjective.
- A Became red in the face
- B To be confused
- C Replied to an argument
- D Expression of emotion
Show answer
Why:
None of the five words carries that sense.
- A Flushed
- B Stricken
- C Countered
- D Gleam
Show answer
Why:
It is what Grandpa does when his daughter protests about the parcel.
- A The chess game before the newspaper is mentioned
- B The barber shop and the salon next door
- C The birthday parcel, where she flushes, looks stricken, and he counters
- D The opening exchange about the memory vitamin
Show answer
Why:
The vocabulary work is drawn from the passage it accompanies.
- A The tense of the main verb in a sentence
- B Whether a sentence is a question or a statement
- C How a noun or pronoun stands towards the other words — its direction, location, time or manner
- D The emotion with which a sentence should be spoken
Show answer
Why:
Four kinds of relationship, carried by very small words.
- A Walk across to the corner shop
- B A shadow fall over him
- C Twirling his walking stick jauntily
- D Took position behind a big banyan
Show answer
Why:
That phrase is used for the vocabulary work on dilemma instead.
- A Under
- B Over
- C Beside
- D Among
Show answer
Why:
Under would put the walker beneath the water.
- A Through is for time and along is for place
- B Through is a path taken inside something; along follows a line
- C Through is used only with plural nouns
- D Along is used only after verbs of resting
Show answer
Why:
Each preposition carries a distinct geometry.
- A Two — wh-type and yes-or-no type
- B Three — wh-type, yes-or-no type and exclamatory
- C One, since all questions behave the same way
- D Four, one for each kind of intonation
Show answer
Why:
The split decides which bridge word is used when reporting.
- A Have you forgotten?
- B Are you playing hide and seek?
- C Shall we play chess or watch the cricket match?
- D What did you both do today?
Show answer
Why:
The other three are all answered with yes or no.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
The first of the three steps the lesson lists.
- A Whether may never be used in reported speech at all
- B Whether may only be used when the reporting verb is in the present tense
- C Nothing — either bridge works for either kind of question
- D A wh-question keeps its own wh-word as the bridge; whether belongs to yes-or-no questions
Show answer
Why:
The choice of bridge is exactly what the two types decide.
- A Here to now, today to tomorrow, tomorrow to today, now to here
- B Here to there, today to that day, tomorrow to the following day, now to then
- C There to here, that day to today, then to now
- D No change is made to words of time and place
Show answer
Why:
Somebody else is speaking, somewhere else, some time later.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
I becomes he or she, as we becomes they and our becomes their.
- A He asked her whether she helped in looking after her grandparents at home
- B He asked did she help in looking after her grandparents at home?
- C He asked if do you help in looking after your grandparents at home
- D He asked what she helped with at home
Show answer
Why:
Statement order, tense back, your to her, and whether as the bridge.
- A The speed at which a sentence is delivered
- B The pitch of the voice while speaking
- C The loudness of a spoken sentence
- D The pauses placed between clauses
Show answer
Why:
In questions it signals the sentiment, or the answer expected.
- A Rising, because every question ends on a rise
- B Rise-fall, because a choice is being offered
- C Falling, because information is being requested rather than confirmation
- D Level, because the sentence contains a how-word
Show answer
Why:
Wh- and how questions share the falling pattern.
- A That the speaker has no idea what the answer is
- B That the speaker is offering the listener a choice
- C That the speaker is correcting an earlier statement
- D That the speaker is fairly sure of the answer
Show answer
Why:
A negative clause with an affirmative tag falls instead, showing uncertainty.
- A One that offers a choice between two things
- B One beginning with a wh-word
- C One answered only with yes or no
- D One ending in a negative tag
Show answer
Why:
Up on the first option, down on the second.
- A It increases both
- B It reduces both
- C It leaves both unchanged but improves sleep
- D It reduces the first and increases the second
Show answer
Why:
Both claims are made in the same sentence of the transcript.
- A Not more than one word, testing vocabulary range
- B A full sentence, testing note-making
- C There is no limit, so long as the meaning is right
- D Not more than three exact words, testing precise catching rather than paraphrase
Show answer
Why:
The words must be the ones actually heard.
- A It should be practised only before examinations and not otherwise
- B Daily practice is discouraged as it becomes mechanical
- C It has no effect on examination stress but improves eyesight
- D Practised daily it becomes a routine, and regular practice eases exam-related pressure
Show answer
Why:
The transcript also links it to memory power.
- A Three paragraphs: introduction, body, conclusion
- B Two paragraphs: an anecdote and a moral
- C Five paragraphs, one for each elderly person described
- D Four paragraphs: introduction, supporting detail, challenges overcome, conclusion
Show answer
Why:
The title goes at the top, with the writer's name and grade below it.
- A He asks for each thing and is refused aloud each time
- B He is drawn to each thing but moves on, having already anticipated the refusal
- C He is bought each thing in turn and loses interest
- D He ignores all of them and hurries towards the fair
Show answer
Why:
The refusals are expected rather than spoken, which is the point.
- A A garland of gulmohur
- B Balloons on a pole
- C A kite
- D A snake-charmer's flute
Show answer
Why:
The other two are a toy in a roadside shop and burfi at the sweet stall.
- A Offers him the same five attractions in reverse order, and is refused every time
- B Takes him straight to the police post at the fairground gate
- C Asks the crowd to help find his parents, and the boy falls asleep
- D Buys him the toy he had been refused earlier, and the boy is comforted
Show answer
Why:
His only answer throughout is that he wants his mother and his father.
- A Both are set entirely within a single household
- B Both turn on attending to what a person is offered instead of listening to the person
- C Both end with a character reunited with a missing relative
- D Both are told from the point of view of an elderly narrator
Show answer
Why:
An old man treated as less capable than he is; a boy given everything but what he needs.
- A Rewriting the story's ending from Grandpa's point of view
- B Preparing a debate on whether the elderly should live alone
- C Writing a letter from Ravi to his mother
- D Choosing, from several pictures, the walking stick that matches the story's description
Show answer
Why:
There is also a photograph slide show, with when, who and why for each picture.
Important short questions (6)
One column holds movement words, which describe what a body does or the manner in which it does it — pottering, zigzagging and sprinting, for instance. The other holds sound words, which describe what reaches an ear — boomed, whirr and shrieks. The distinction matters because a scene is built from both at once: remove the sound words from the barber-shop episode and the shrieks that get Ravi thrown out disappear with them.
A preposition shows how a noun or pronoun stands in relation to the other words around it, indicating direction, location, time or manner. In the practice paragraph each does a distinct job. Through a village is a path taken inside something, over a brook crosses above it, and near a cottage is proximity only. In the garden is containment, along a riverbank follows a line, and towards the unknown gives direction without arrival.
First convert the interrogative into a declarative sentence, with the subject before the verb and no question mark. Then, if it is a yes-or-no question, join it to the reporting verb with if or whether. If it is a wh-question, repeat the same wh-word instead. So a direct question asking Priya whether she helps at home becomes: Arvind asked Priya whether she helped in taking care of her grandparents at home. The tense has moved back and your has become her.
Wh- and how questions fall at the end, because information is being requested. Yes-or-no questions rise, because the answer is genuinely open. An affirmative clause with a negative tag rises, showing the speaker is fairly sure of the answer. A negative clause with an affirmative tag falls, showing the speaker is unsure. And a question offering a choice takes a rise-fall — up on the first option, down on the second.
It presents meditation as an important yogic practice used for relaxation and stress management. It gives rest and peace to the mind by clearing away the thoughts that cause stress, which improves well-being both physically and emotionally. A person feels fresh afterwards and gains a new perspective on stressful situations. It also reduces negative emotions and increases self-awareness. Practised daily it becomes a routine, influences memory power, and helps in handling exam-related pressure with ease.
Because both turn on the same failure, seen from opposite ends of a lifetime. An old man is treated as less capable than he is, and quietly proves otherwise. A small boy is offered a roundabout, music, a balloon, a garland and sweets, and refuses every one of them, because the only thing he needs is his parents. In both, the people meaning well attend to what a person might be given instead of listening to the person.
Long answer questions (3)
The first task divides a box of twenty words in two. The movement column holds pottering, ducked, evicted, jumping, crawl, briskly, darted, twirling, creeping, zigzagging, sprinting, trailing and crouch. The sound column holds boomed, bustle, shrieks, thudded, whirr, grunted and snoring. A gap-fill then uses them in a passage about a detective following a suspect — feet that thudded, a man who had to crouch behind stalls and go zigzagging through lanes, and the distant whirr of a sleeping city.
The second task takes the word dilemma from the sentence describing Ravi at the door and asks for two synonyms given as letter puzzles: quandary and predicament. All three name a position in which no available choice is comfortable.
The third is a table of six words to be completed with meaning, part of speech, synonym and antonym. Craftily is an adverb meaning in a cunning, indirect way. Dilemma is a noun. Furious is an adjective meaning extremely angry. Boomed is a verb meaning sounded loudly and deeply. Humiliation is a noun meaning loss of dignity before others. And attire is a noun meaning clothing — the white pyjama and shirt of the man on the bus — not a verb.
The fourth matches five emotion words to meanings, with one meaning deliberately left over. Embarrassed means felt uncomfortable; countered means replied to an argument; flushed means became red in the face; stricken means affected severely by an unpleasant feeling; and gleam is an expression of emotion. The unused meaning is to be confused.
Three of those five words carry the story's final page, where the mother flushes, darts a stricken look at the calendar, and is countered by her father.
The lesson begins by sorting quoted sentences from the story. All of them are interrogative, and they fall into two kinds. Yes-or-no questions expect confirmation or denial: one asks whether they should play chess or watch the cricket match, another whether somebody has forgotten, a third whether a boy is playing hide and seek. Wh-questions ask for information: who somebody is, and what two people did that day. So there are two kinds of interrogative sentence, not three.
The words inside quotation marks are the speaker's own, and are called direct speech. Indirect or reported speech is somebody else repeating those words at another time and in another place — and because both the time and the place have moved, three sets of things shift with them.
Tenses move one step back: present to past, present progressive to past progressive, past to past perfect, past progressive to past perfect progressive.
Pronouns change person: I becomes he or she, we becomes they, our becomes their.
Words of time and place follow: here becomes there, today becomes that day, tomorrow becomes the following day, now becomes then.
For questions specifically there are three steps. Convert the interrogative into a declarative sentence, so that the subject comes before the verb and no question mark remains. Then bridge it to the reporting verb — with if or whether for a yes-or-no question, and with the same wh-word for the other kind.
So a direct question asking somebody whether they help in taking care of their grandparents at home is reported as: he asked her whether she helped in taking care of her grandparents at home. Every rule is visible in that one line — statement order, tense moved back, your turned to her, and whether providing the join.
It is the festival of spring, and crowds are moving towards a fair. A small boy walks with his parents, running ahead and falling behind, and is called along again and again.
Five times he is drawn to something. A toy in a roadside shop, which he pleads for and is refused with a look. Burfi at the sweet stall, which he murmurs for, knowing he will be called greedy. A garland of gulmohur, which he half-murmurs for, knowing the flowers will be called cheap. Balloons on a pole, which he does not ask for at all, knowing he will be told he is too old for toys. And a snake-charmer's flute, which he approaches and then leaves, because such music is forbidden him. Each time the refusal is anticipated rather than spoken, and each time he moves on.
At the roundabout he finally makes a bold request — and there is no reply. His parents are not ahead of him, not to either side, not behind. He runs in panic, his turban comes untied, and his crying subsides into sobs.
A man lifts him out of a crush near a temple entrance and tries, one by one, to comfort him: a ride on the roundabout, the snake-charmer's music, a rainbow-coloured balloon, a garland for his neck, sweets from the counter. The same five attractions, offered in reverse order, and refused every one. His only answer is that he wants his mother and his father, and there the story stops.
What it shares with Vitamin-M is a single failure, viewed from the two ends of a life. An old man is treated as less capable than he is, decided about rather than consulted, and answers by quietly proving otherwise. A small boy is offered everything the fair contains and none of it is what he needs. In both, people who mean no harm attend to what a person might be given instead of listening to the person in front of them — and in both, the story makes that point without ever stating it.
Flashcards (25)
Play this topic
- Match the Word to Its Part of Speech and Sense
- True or False: Grammar and Skills
- Complete the Statement
- Unscramble the Terms
Class 9 English Chapter 4 — frequently asked questions
Because everything he valued had been taken away at once. He hated the noise and bustle of city life, and the flat was poky and little compared with his own brick house, which had a big mango tree and a quiet so complete that a falling leaf could be heard at dusk. Worse, he was forbidden to go out alone, having looked after himself for most of seventy-five years.
Because of three incidents, all real and all recent. He had been admitted to hospital after absent-mindedly taking a double dose of his medicines. He had gone for a walk and forgotten the way back home. And before that he had fallen while pottering in his own garden and lain outside all night, since nobody was there to help him up. Her fear was earned rather than imagined.
No. The clearest sign is that he winces at the over-loud tone she uses when speaking to him, as though to a child who cannot hear or understand. He also tells Grandpa, loyally, that his mother would never treat him like a baby or a prisoner — and he feels guilty for a moment first, which shows he knows the charge is not groundless.
By supplying incidents and letting the reader name the quality. His pride appears in the record he cites when he is forbidden the street. His independence in ten years of cooking and keeping house alone. His wit in the single question that turns Ravi's loyal denial into permission. And his generosity in the cap he hands to a stranger and the gifts he gives on his own birthday. The only label the narration offers is the adverb craftily.
It is well meant, since he is trying to protect an old man without wounding him, but it keeps his promise only in letter. By shadowing his grandfather instead of speaking to him, he does exactly what his mother had done: he makes a decision about the old man without consulting him. He repeats the very fault he had winced at an hour earlier, and the afternoon's humiliations follow from it.
No. Her fear rests on three real incidents within a month — a hospital admission after a doubled dose, a walk from which her father could not find his way back, and a night he spent lying in his garden. She locked the house and brought him away because the alternative was leaving him there. What the story criticises is her manner: a rule announced rather than discussed, an over-loud tone, and medicines handed to her son rather than her father.
One column holds movement words, which describe what a body does or the manner in which it does it — pottering, zigzagging and sprinting, for instance. The other holds sound words, which describe what reaches an ear — boomed, whirr and shrieks. The distinction matters because a scene is built from both at once: remove the sound words from the barber-shop episode and the shrieks that get Ravi thrown out disappear with them.
A preposition shows how a noun or pronoun stands in relation to the other words around it, indicating direction, location, time or manner. In the practice paragraph each does a distinct job. Through a village is a path taken inside something, over a brook crosses above it, and near a cottage is proximity only. In the garden is containment, along a riverbank follows a line, and towards the unknown gives direction without arrival.
First convert the interrogative into a declarative sentence, with the subject before the verb and no question mark. Then, if it is a yes-or-no question, join it to the reporting verb with if or whether. If it is a wh-question, repeat the same wh-word instead. So a direct question asking Priya whether she helps at home becomes: Arvind asked Priya whether she helped in taking care of her grandparents at home. The tense has moved back and your has become her.
All Class 9 English chapters
All English chapters · Every Class 9 subject · The whole NCERT library
Study this chapter properly, free
Everything above is on this page to read. In the Veda app the same chapter becomes spaced-repetition flashcards, timed tests that mark themselves, Veda Bites you can swipe, and games — with your progress tracked topic by topic.
Get Veda free