Class 9 English Chapter 1: How I Taught My Grandmother to Read
- ★ Free chapter
- 3 topics
- 108 MCQs
- 18 short answers
- 9 long answers
- 60 flashcards
- 12 games
- ~84 min read
- English
The Story, Scene by Scene
A girl of twelve spends a season reading a magazine serial aloud to a grandmother who cannot read. She goes away for a week, comes back to find the old woman weeping, and by the end of the story the roles have swapped so completely that the grandmother bends down and touches her feet. This topic follows that sequence of events closely, because every question the lesson asks depends on knowing exactly what happened and in what order.
What you will be able to do
- Retell the events of the story in the order in which they happen.
- Explain what the serial Kashi Yatre is about and why the grandmother cared about it.
- Describe what the narrator found on returning from the wedding, and what caused it.
- State the decision the grandmother took, the deadline she set and the reason she gave.
- Describe what happened at Dassara and how the story closes.
Key points
The narrator, a girl of about twelve, is staying with her grandparents in a village in north Karnataka, where poor transport means the morning paper arrives in the afternoon and the weekly magazine a day late.
Triveni is the popular Kannada writer of the time, easy to read and convincing, who wrote about complex psychological problems in the lives of ordinary people and died young.
Her novel Kashi Yatre is running as a serial in the Kannada weekly Karmaveera, and every Wednesday the narrator reads the new episode aloud to her grandmother.
The grandmother, Krishtakka, whom the narrator calls Avva, never went to school and cannot read; she listens with total concentration and can afterwards repeat the whole episode by heart.
The narrator goes to a wedding in a neighbouring village for a couple of days and stays a week, and returns to find Avva in tears, though she had never seen her cry even in the most difficult situations.
That night Avva explains that the magazine arrived while she was away, that she could not read a word of it, and that being unable to read had left her feeling dependent and helpless despite the family being well-off.
Avva decides to learn the Kannada alphabet, setting Saraswati Puja day during Dassara as her deadline, and says that for a good cause determination can overcome any obstacle and that learning has no age bar.
At Dassara she reads the title and publisher of the novel her granddaughter gives her, and touches the girl's feet, saying she is honouring a teacher rather than a granddaughter.
Full explanation
A Village, a Bus, and a Weekly Magazine
The narrator is a girl of about twelve, staying with her grandparents in a village in north Karnataka. The transport of those days was not good, so the morning paper reached the village only in the afternoon and the weekly magazine came a day late. Everyone waited for the bus, because the bus brought the papers, the magazines and the post.
That small detail sets up the whole story. In a place like this, a weekly instalment of a serial is not a small thing. It is the event of the week.
Triveni, and the Serial
Triveni was the popular Kannada writer of the time. Her style was easy to read and convincing, and her stories dealt with complicated inner problems in the lives of ordinary people. She died very young, and yet forty years later her novels were still being appreciated.
One of her novels, Kashi Yatre, was running as a serial in the Kannada weekly Karmaveera.
Its story is worth holding on to, because it explains a great deal about the grandmother. An old lady longs to make the journey to Kashi, or Varanasi, and worship Lord Vishweshwara there — something most Hindus regard as the highest merit. Her struggle to make that journey is what the novel describes. There is also a young orphan girl in the story who falls in love but has no money for her wedding. At the end, the old lady gives away all her savings and never goes to Kashi at all, saying that the orphan girl's happiness matters more than the pilgrimage.
Avva
The narrator's grandmother is Krishtakka. The narrator calls her Avva, the word for mother in the Kannada of north Karnataka.
She never went to school, so she could not read.
Every Wednesday, when the magazine came, the narrator read her the next episode. During that time the old woman forgot all her work and listened with the greatest concentration — and afterwards she could repeat the entire text by heart. Notice what that tells us: her memory was excellent and her attention complete. The only thing missing was the alphabet.
She had never been to Kashi either, and she identified herself with the novel's main character. So she, more than anybody, wanted to know what happened next, and she insisted the serial be read out to her.
Afterwards she would go to the temple courtyard, where her friends gathered and the children played hide and seek, and she would argue about the latest episode. The narrator, at twelve, never understood why there was so much debate about a story.
The Week Away
Then the narrator went with her cousins to a wedding in a neighbouring village.
A wedding in those days was a great event. The children ate and played endlessly, enjoying the freedom of having all the elders too busy to watch them. She went meaning to stay a couple of days — and stayed a week.
Tears
When she came back, she found her grandmother in tears.
This surprised her, because she had never seen Avva cry even in the most difficult situations. She asked whether everything was all right. Avva nodded and did not answer, and the child forgot about it.
That night, after dinner, they were sleeping on the open terrace of the house. It was a summer night with a full moon. Avva came and sat beside her and put her hand on her forehead, and the narrator realised she wanted to talk.
The Life Story, Told at Night
What Avva told her was her own history. She had lost her mother when she was a young girl, with nobody to look after her or guide her. Her father was a busy man who married again. In those days education was not considered essential for girls, so she never went to school. She was married very young, had children, and became busy; later came grandchildren, and great happiness in cooking and feeding them all. But at times she regretted not going to school, and so she made sure her children and grandchildren studied well.
The narrator could not understand why her sixty-two-year-old grandmother was telling her, a girl of twelve, in the middle of the night, the whole story of her life.
What Had Actually Happened
Then Avva came to the point. While the narrator was away, Karmaveera had come as usual. Avva opened it. She saw the picture that goes with the Kashi Yatre story — and could not understand a word of what was written beside it.
She rubbed her hands over the pages, wishing they could understand what was printed there. She waited for her granddaughter to come back. She even thought of going to the village to fetch her. She could have asked somebody else nearby, but she was too embarrassed to do it.
And then the sentence that names the real injury: she felt dependent and helpless, and asked what use money was when she could not be independent. The family was well-off. That was never the problem.
The Decision
So she announced a decision. She would learn the Kannada alphabet, beginning the next day. She would work very hard. She fixed Saraswati Puja day during Dassara as her deadline, and said that by that day she should be able to read a novel on her own, because she wanted to be independent.
The narrator saw the determination on her face — and laughed at her. At sixty-two? With grey hair, wrinkled hands, spectacles, and all that work in the kitchen?
The narrator calls this what it was: childishly making fun of an old lady.
Avva only smiled, and answered that for a good cause a determined person can overcome any obstacle, that she would work harder than anybody, and that for learning there is no age bar.
The Tuition
From the next day the lessons began.
Avva turned out to be a splendid pupil, and the sheer quantity of homework she got through was astonishing — reading, repeating, writing, reciting. The narrator was her only teacher; she was the narrator's first student.
And here the narrator drops a line that changes the scale of the whole story: little did she know then that one day she would become a teacher of Computer Science and teach hundreds of students.
Dassara
The festival arrived. Secretly, the narrator bought Kashi Yatre, which by then had been published as a novel.
Her grandmother called her to the puja place and made her sit down on a stool. She gave her enough material for a frock. Then came something out of the ordinary: she stooped and touched her granddaughter's feet.
The narrator was taken aback, and says so plainly. Elders never touch the feet of youngsters. The feet of God, of elders and of teachers are touched as a mark of respect, and that is a great tradition — but here the reverse had happened, and it was not correct.
Avva's Answer
Avva had her reason ready. She was touching the feet of a teacher, not of her granddaughter — a teacher who had taught her so well, and with so much affection, that she could now read any novel confidently after so short a time. She was independent. It was her duty to respect a teacher, and she asked whether the scriptures do not say that a teacher should be respected irrespective of gender and age.
The narrator returned the namaskara by touching Avva's feet, and gave her gift to her first student.
Avva opened it and read, straight away, the title Kashi Yatre, the name Triveni, and the publisher's name.
The narrator knew then that her student had passed with flying colours.
Why the Order Matters
Read the sequence again and notice how tightly it is built. The serial creates the need. The week away exposes it. The night conversation explains it. The decision answers it. The festival tests it. Nothing in the story is decoration — even the detail about the slow bus is there so that a weekly magazine can matter enough to change a life.
Concepts and terms
Every Wednesday the magazine reaches the village and the narrator reads the latest episode of the serial aloud to her grandmother, who drops all her work to listen. Afterwards the old woman joins her friends in the temple courtyard and argues about the episode, which the child watches without understanding why it matters so much.
The novel being serialised. An old lady longs to make the pilgrimage to Kashi and worship there, which most Hindus hold to be the greatest merit; a young orphan girl in the same story is in love but has no money for her wedding. At the end the old lady gives away all her savings and never makes the journey.
The narrator goes with her cousins to a wedding in a neighbouring village, meaning to stay two days and staying seven. In that week the magazine arrives as usual, the grandmother opens it, and finds she cannot read a word of the episode she has been waiting for.
The festival day the grandmother had set as her deadline. She gives her granddaughter cloth for a frock and then bends and touches her feet, which inverts a tradition in which the young touch the feet of God, of elders and of teachers. She explains that she is honouring the teacher, not the child.
What Students Get Wrong
Did you know
The deadline the grandmother sets is not a date on a calendar but a festival — Saraswati Puja during Dassara, the day set aside for the goddess of learning.
The narrator mentions almost in passing that she would one day teach Computer Science to hundreds of students, which makes the illiterate grandmother her very first pupil.
The grandmother could repeat a whole episode by heart after one hearing, so the thing she lacked was never memory or intelligence — only the alphabet.
Memory tricks
The order of events — Serial, wedding, tears, decision, Dassara. — Five beats carry the whole plot: the weekly reading, the week away, the weeping she comes home to, the resolve taken that night, and the festival on which the student passes.
The two numbers that matter — Sixty-two and twelve. — The grandmother's age and the narrator's. Every exchange in the story gets its force from the gap between them, and the ending closes it.
Practice MCQs with answers (36)
- A It shows that the village was too poor to afford newspapers of its own
- B It explains why the narrator was sent away to a wedding for a week
- C It makes the weekly instalment an event important enough to change a life
- D It proves that the grandmother had no interest in current affairs
Show answer
Why:
Everything in the plot rests on the serial mattering enormously to Avva.
- A A Kannada poet whose work was admired only long after she had died
- B An English novelist whose books were translated into Kannada weeklies
- C A popular Kannada writer, easy to read, dealing with the inner problems of ordinary people
- D A journalist who wrote a weekly column about village transport
Show answer
Why:
Her subject was complex psychological problems in ordinary lives.
- A She spends them on the pilgrimage and reaches Kashi at last
- B She gives them all away and never makes the journey to Kashi
- C She divides them equally between the orphan girl and the temple
- D She keeps them, having decided the pilgrimage is not worth the cost
Show answer
Why:
The orphan girl's happiness is placed above the pilgrimage.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The family is described as well-off, so poverty is not the explanation.
- A Grandmother, in the Kannada spoken across the whole state
- B Mother, in the Kannada spoken in north Karnataka
- C Teacher, in the Kannada used in religious writing
- D Elder sister, in the dialect of a neighbouring village
Show answer
Why:
The narrator glosses the word at the moment she first uses it.
- A She discussed the episodes with her friends at the temple courtyard
- B She could repeat the entire text by heart after listening once
- C She waited eagerly every Wednesday for the magazine to arrive
- D She identified herself closely with the novel's main character
Show answer
Why:
Perfect recall of a heard text rules out any failure of memory.
- A Because she too had raised an orphan girl in her household
- B Because she too had given away the whole of her savings
- C Because she too had been married at a very young age
- D Because she too had never been to Kashi
Show answer
Why:
The unmade pilgrimage is what the two women share.
- A The grandmother read the episode aloud to her friends, who could not read either
- B The children were made to recite the episode while the elders listened
- C The grandmother debated the episode with friends, and the child did not see why it mattered
- D The priest explained the religious meaning of the pilgrimage in the story
Show answer
Why:
The narrator says she never understood why there was so much debate about a story.
- A She meant to stay a week and stayed a fortnight
- B She meant to stay one day and stayed three
- C She meant to stay a couple of days and stayed a week
- D She meant to stay a month and returned after a week
Show answer
Why:
The extra days are what leave the magazine unread.
- A The grandmother had promised never to cry in front of her grandchildren
- B Nobody in the village had ever seen any woman weep in public before
- C The grandmother had been perfectly cheerful when the narrator left
- D The narrator had not once known her to weep, however bad things had been
Show answer
Why:
Her composure elsewhere is what makes these tears alarming.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
She began with her whole life story, and came to the magazine only afterwards.
- A No schooling, mother lost, grandchildren, early marriage, father remarried
- B Early marriage, mother lost, children, no schooling, father remarried
- C Mother lost, father remarried, no schooling, early marriage, children, grandchildren
- D Father remarried, grandchildren, early marriage, mother lost, no schooling
Show answer
Why:
She tells it in order, which is why the regret arrives last.
- A The village she grew up in had no school of any kind
- B In those days education was not considered essential for girls
- C Her father could not afford the fees after remarrying
- D She was needed at home to look after her younger brothers
Show answer
Why:
The reason she gives is a social attitude, not a practical obstacle.
- A She hid it away unopened until her granddaughter should return
- B She carried it to the temple courtyard and had a friend read it aloud
- C She tore out the page with the picture and kept it under her pillow
- D She opened it, saw the picture beside the story, and understood nothing written there
Show answer
Why:
She even passed her hands across the sheets, as if touch might do what reading could not.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
She says the opposite: the family is well-off, and money is exactly what does not help her. The assertion stands, the reason is false.
- A Nobody else in the village was able to read Kannada
- B Her family had forbidden her to discuss the serial outside the house
- C The magazine had to be returned before anyone could be found
- D She was too embarrassed to ask anybody
Show answer
Why:
Shame, not the absence of readers, keeps her waiting.
- A The English alphabet, by the end of the following summer
- B To write her own name, by the next Wednesday's magazine
- C The Kannada alphabet, by Saraswati Puja day during Dassara
- D To read the newspaper, by the beginning of the wedding season
Show answer
Why:
The deadline is a festival day, chosen by the learner herself.
- A Write a letter to her granddaughter
- B Read a novel on her own
- C Recite an episode from memory
- D Teach the alphabet to her friends
Show answer
Why:
Reading unaided is the whole point of the exercise.
- A As quietly encouraging her grandmother to try
- B As refusing outright to give any lessons at all
- C As immediately fetching paper and beginning that night
- D As childishly making fun of an old lady
Show answer
Why:
The adult narrator judges her twelve-year-old self without excusing her.
- A Her poor memory, her weak eyesight and her lack of any free time
- B Her age, her grey hair, her wrinkled hands, her spectacles and her kitchen work
- C Her village accent, her old-fashioned clothes and her religious habits
- D Her fear of the neighbours, her pride and her refusal to ask for help
Show answer
Why:
She lists physical signs of age, which is what makes the mockery childish.
- A That the young should never laugh at the old, and that she would stop reading altogether
- B That determination overcomes any obstacle for a good cause, and that learning has no age bar
- C That she would learn faster than her granddaughter, and that the lessons must be secret
- D That the scriptures require her to study, and that her friends had challenged her
Show answer
Why:
Both claims are about learning, not about being wronged.
- A A slow but willing student who needed constant encouragement to continue
- B An impatient student who wanted to skip the alphabet and begin with novels
- C A wonderful student who did an amazing amount of homework, reading, repeating, writing and reciting
- D A secretive student who practised only when the household was asleep
Show answer
Why:
Four verbs describe her method, and the quantity of work astonishes her teacher.
- A It explains how she was able to teach the alphabet so effectively at twelve
- B It makes the illiterate grandmother the very first pupil of a lifelong teacher
- C It shows that she had already decided on her career before the story began
- D It proves that the grandmother's lessons were the cause of her later success
Show answer
Why:
The line quietly enlarges the scale of a small village episode.
- A A pair of spectacles, so that her grandmother could see the print
- B A new weekly magazine, so that the serial could continue at home
- C A notebook and pencil, so that the lessons could carry on afterwards
- D The novel Kashi Yatre, so that the gift was also the examination
Show answer
Why:
By then the serial had been published as a book, which makes it readable in one sitting.
- A A copy of the novel she had been reading
- B A sum of money saved for the festival
- C A garland brought from the temple
- D A gift of frock material
Show answer
Why:
The gift comes first; the surprising act follows it.
- A Because the grandmother had not yet finished learning to read
- B Because it was done at the puja place rather than at home
- C Because a gift had already been given and nothing more was owed
- D Because elders never touch the feet of youngsters in that tradition
Show answer
Why:
The feet of God, of elders and of teachers are touched, and the order had been reversed.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
She reclassifies the person, which brings the act back inside the rule.
- A The opening paragraph of the first chapter, without hesitating
- B The dedication written inside the cover by her granddaughter
- C The price printed on the back and the date of publication
- D The title of the novel, the author's name and the publisher's name
Show answer
Why:
Three pieces of printed information, read on the spot, settle the test.
- A That her student had passed with flying colours
- B That her student had learnt more than she could teach
- C That her student had repaid every lesson given
- D That her student had become her teacher in turn
Show answer
Why:
The story closes on an examiner's idiom, which the lesson later teaches.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
She read it immediately, which is exactly what proves the point.
- A The tears, the weekly readings, the festival, the decision, the week away
- B The weekly readings, the week away, the tears, the decision, the festival
- C The decision, the week away, the weekly readings, the tears, the festival
- D The week away, the festival, the tears, the weekly readings, the decision
Show answer
Why:
Need, exposure, explanation, answer, test — in that order.
- A The absence is what exposes the grandmother's helplessness and starts everything
- B The wedding is where the narrator first learns that her grandmother cannot read
- C The cousins at the wedding are the ones who suggest teaching the alphabet
- D The novel Kashi Yatre is bought at a shop in the neighbouring village
Show answer
Why:
Without the week away the magazine is never faced alone.
- A Angry and betrayed
- B Bored and restless
- C Dependent and helpless
- D Frightened and ashamed of her family
Show answer
Why:
Those two words are what turn a small frustration into a decision.
- A She carried the magazine with her to the temple courtyard every week
- B She learnt to write her name before she learnt to read the alphabet
- C She passed her hands across the sheets, as though touch might do what reading could not
- D She kept the picture from the serial pinned beside her bed
Show answer
Why:
The gesture is the most affecting image in the whole account.
- A The narrator alone, who was her only teacher while she was the narrator's first student
- B The narrator and her cousins together, taking a day of the week each
- C A teacher from the village school, with the narrator helping in the evenings
- D Her friends at the temple courtyard, who had all learnt to read as girls
Show answer
Why:
The pairing of only teacher and first student is the story's neatest symmetry.
- A Its old lady never reaches her goal, which is the situation the grandmother recognises
- B Its plot is repeated exactly by the events of the narrator's own household
- C Its author Triveni appears later in the story as a character in her own right
- D Its ending explains why the magazine arrived a day late every week
Show answer
Why:
The inner story supplies the mirror in which Avva sees herself.
Important short questions (6)
Transport was poor, so the morning paper came only in the afternoon and the weekly magazine a day late, and everyone waited for the bus that carried them. In a place where news arrived like that, the next instalment of a serial became the event of the week, which is why the grandmother cared about it so deeply.
An old lady longs to reach Kashi and worship Lord Vishweshwara there, while a young orphan girl in the same story has no money for her wedding, and the old lady ends by handing over everything she has put by and never goes. The grandmother had never been to Kashi either, so she identified herself with the character.
She found her grandmother in tears. It surprised her because she had never seen the old woman cry even in the most difficult situations, so weeping was entirely out of character. When asked whether anything was wrong, her grandmother only nodded and gave no answer, and the child forgot about it until that night.
The magazine arrived as usual. The grandmother opened it and saw the picture that went with the serial, but could understand nothing of what was written beside it. She rubbed her hands over the pages, waited for her granddaughter, and was too embarrassed to ask anyone else in the village to read it to her.
She decided to learn the Kannada alphabet from the next day, setting Saraswati Puja day during Dassara as her deadline, by which she meant to read a novel on her own. Her reason was independence: the family was well-off, but she asked what use money was when she could not read for herself.
The grandmother called her granddaughter, seated her on a stool and gave her a gift of frock material. She then bent down and touched her feet, explaining that she honoured a teacher rather than a granddaughter. The narrator returned the gesture, and the old woman opened her own gift and read its title and publisher at once.
Long answer questions (3)
The story begins with a ritual. In a village in north Karnataka where transport was poor and the weekly magazine came a day late, the narrator read the latest episode of a serial aloud to her grandmother every Wednesday. The old woman could not read, but listened with complete concentration and could repeat the whole episode afterwards by heart.
The ritual is broken by an absence. The narrator went with her cousins to a wedding in a neighbouring village, meaning to stay two days and staying a week.
That absence exposes the problem. The magazine arrived while she was away, and the grandmother, opening it, could understand nothing beside the picture. She was too embarrassed to ask a neighbour, and waited.
The narrator returned to find her in tears — something she had never seen before. That night, on the open terrace under a full moon, the grandmother told her own life story and then named what was wrong: she felt dependent and helpless, and money could not make her independent.
So she decided to learn the alphabet, fixing Saraswati Puja day during Dassara as her deadline. The lessons began the next day, and she proved a remarkable student.
At the festival the narrator gave her the serial, now published as a novel, and the grandmother read its title and publisher at once, touching her granddaughter's feet as a teacher's.
Everything before the scene is preparation and everything after it is consequence, so the night conversation carries the whole story.
The setting is deliberately gentle. It is a summer night with a full moon, the household is sleeping in the open, and the grandmother comes and sits beside the child and puts a hand on her forehead. The narrator says she realised from this that her grandmother wanted to speak. Tenderness is established before a word is said.
What the grandmother then gives is not an explanation but a life. She lost her mother young, her father was busy and remarried, girls were not thought to need education, she married early and was soon occupied with children and grandchildren. The regret about school comes last, after everything that made it impossible.
Only then does she reach the week just past — the magazine she could not read, the pages she rubbed with her hands, the neighbour she was too embarrassed to ask.
The weight falls on one distinction. The family is well-off, and she says so. What she lacks is not money but independence, and no amount of wealth supplies it.
Placing this at night, in private, between two people of very different ages, lets an old woman confess a shame she would not admit to the village — and lets a child be trusted with it.
The ending is a reversal. At the puja place on Dassara day, the grandmother seats her granddaughter on a stool, gives her cloth for a frock, and then bends down and touches her feet.
The narrator's own reaction is part of the effect. She is surprised and taken aback, and states the rule plainly: elders never touch the feet of youngsters, since the feet of God, of elders and of teachers are touched as a mark of respect. She calls the act not correct before it is explained.
The explanation reclassifies the person rather than breaking the rule. The grandmother says she is honouring a teacher, not a granddaughter — one who taught her so well and so affectionately that she can now read any novel confidently — and asks whether the scriptures do not require a teacher to be respected irrespective of gender and age.
The preparation runs through the whole story. The deadline was announced in advance, so the reader is waiting for this day. The narrator was called the only teacher and the grandmother the first student, so the roles are already named. The gift is the serial itself, published as a novel, so the present doubles as the examination.
The proof is immediate: the old woman opens it and reads the title, the author and the publisher on the spot. The narrator closes with an examiner's phrase, saying her student had passed with flying colours.
Flashcards (20)
Play this topic
- Match the Name to Its Place in the Story
- True or False: What Actually Happened
- Complete the Statement
- Unscramble the Words of the Story
Avva, the Narrator, and What the Story Is Saying
Two people carry this story: an old woman who was never given the chance to read, and a child who has that chance and does not value it. This topic examines both of them, works out what the story is arguing about education and respect, and looks at the choices the writer made — the first-person voice, the novel placed inside the novel, and an ending built on a deliberately broken custom.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the grandmother's character, using evidence from her words and actions.
- Describe the narrator's character, including the faults she admits to.
- State what the story argues about literacy, age and respect.
- Explain the purpose of the story-within-a-story.
- Comment on the writer's choice of a first-person voice looking back.
Key points
The grandmother was deprived of schooling rather than incapable of it, since her memory and concentration are shown to be excellent before she learns a single letter.
She is honest about her own shame, admitting she was too embarrassed to ask a neighbour, and honest about her wealth, which she rules out as the cause of her trouble.
Her determination is practical: she names a deadline, does an astonishing quantity of homework, and reads, repeats, writes and recites.
The narrator is careless and unthinking at twelve, staying away far longer than intended and openly mocking her grandmother's age, grey hair, wrinkled hands and spectacles.
She is also teachable, becoming a patient instructor and, as she mentions in passing, a teacher of Computer Science to hundreds of students in later life.
The story argues that literacy is independence: the family is well-off, and what the grandmother lacks is not money but the power to reach a page unaided.
It argues that learning has no age bar, and that respect follows the role rather than the years, which is why an elder may bow to a child who has taught her.
The craft is deliberate — an adult narrator judging her younger self, a novel about an unmade pilgrimage mirroring the grandmother's life, and a climax built on a custom reversed and then justified.
Full explanation
Two People, and a Gap of Fifty Years
The story has exactly two people in it who matter: a woman of sixty-two who cannot read, and a girl of about twelve who can. Everything it has to say comes out of the distance between them — and out of how that distance closes.
Avva: Deprived, Not Incapable
The most important thing to get right about the grandmother is that she is not slow.
Before she learns a single letter, the story shows us her mind at work. She sets aside all her work to listen. She listens with complete concentration. Afterwards she can give back the entire instalment from memory. She then goes to the temple courtyard and argues about it with her friends — so confidently that the child, watching, cannot understand why a story should cause so much debate.
Memory, attention, judgement: all present. What is missing is the alphabet, and the reason it is missing is stated plainly. In her girlhood, education was not considered essential for girls. She lost her mother early, her father was busy and married again, and she was married young herself.
She was deprived, not incapable. Every later triumph follows from that distinction.
Her Honesty
Two admissions make her formidable rather than pitiable.
The first is about shame. She could have asked somebody in the village to read the episode to her. She says so herself. But she was too embarrassed to do it — and she reports that embarrassment instead of hiding it.
The second is about money. She could easily have been mistaken for someone complaining of hardship, so she rules it out in advance: the family is well-off. What use is money, she asks, when she cannot be independent?
That second admission is the sharper of the two, because it names precisely what she has lost. Not comfort. Not security. Independence.
Her Determination
What follows is not a wish but a plan.
She fixes what she will learn — the Kannada alphabet. She fixes when she will begin — the next day. She fixes a deadline — Saraswati Puja day during Dassara. And she fixes the standard by which she will judge herself: by that day she should be able to read a novel on her own.
Then she does the work. The narrator calls her a wonderful student and says the amount of homework was amazing. She would read, repeat, write and recite.
When she is laughed at, she does not argue about her dignity. She makes a claim about learning instead: for a good cause a determined person can overcome any obstacle, and for learning there is no age bar.
The Narrator: Careless and Teachable
The narrator is a harder portrait, because she is drawn by herself.
At twelve she is careless. She goes to a wedding for a couple of days and stays a week, in a house where a woman is waiting for her to come back and read.
She is also unthinking. When her grandmother announces her decision, the girl laughs. She lists the grey hair, the wrinkled hands, the spectacles, the endless kitchen work. The adult who writes this down does not excuse it — she calls it childishly making fun of an old lady.
But she is teachable, in both senses. She becomes a patient teacher, giving daily lessons to her first student. And she learns the lesson the ending forces on her: when her grandmother bows, she returns the namaskara.
And in one short line the writer widens everything: little did she know she would one day teach Computer Science to hundreds of students. Her first pupil was an illiterate woman of sixty-two in a village.
What the Story Argues
Three claims, and the grandmother makes all three herself.
Literacy is independence. This is the heart of it. The family has money. She is loved and fed and secure. What she cannot do is reach a page by herself, and she refuses to accept that.
Learning has no age bar. Sixty-two against twelve — and it is the sixty-two-year-old who does the homework.
Respect follows the role, not the years. This is what the ending is for.
The Ending, and Why It Is Not a Broken Rule
At the puja place the grandmother bends and touches her granddaughter's feet.
The narrator states the objection immediately, and it is the reader's objection too. Elders never touch the feet of youngsters. The feet of God, of elders and of teachers are touched as a mark of respect. It is a great tradition, and here the reverse had happened. She calls it not correct.
Then the grandmother answers — and notice that she does not plead an exception. She reclassifies the person. She is touching the feet of a teacher, not of a granddaughter: a teacher who taught her so well and so affectionately that she can now read any novel confidently in a short time. She is independent, and it is her duty to respect a teacher. And she asks whether it is not written in the scriptures that a teacher should be respected irrespective of gender and age.
So the rule is not broken. The girl has simply become one of the three kinds of person the rule already covers.
The Craft
Three choices are worth naming.
First person, in retrospect. An adult is remembering herself at twelve. That is what allows the mockery to be recorded honestly — a child could not judge herself so clearly, and a third-person narrator could not be so forgiving.
A story inside the story. The novel is about an old lady who longs for a pilgrimage and never makes it. The grandmother never reached that city either. Without this mirror, her hunger for the next instalment would look like idle curiosity; with it, we understand that she has been listening to a version of her own life.
An objection raised, then answered. The narrator condemns the feet-touching before it is explained. That is why the explanation lands: the story has already said what we were going to say.
The Line to Remember
One sentence holds the whole argument: she is honouring a teacher, not a granddaughter — and scripture requires that a teacher be respected irrespective of gender and age. Both claims the story wants to make, put into the mouth of the character who had the least education and turns out to have the clearest sense of what education is worth.
Concepts and terms
The distinction on which the whole portrait of the grandmother rests. Before she learns anything she is shown absorbing an instalment completely and giving it back from memory, and arguing about it with her friends. Nothing she lacks is a capacity; what she lacks is the schooling her generation withheld from girls.
The grandmother's own account of what reading is for. She is not poor and does not need money. What she cannot do is reach a printed page without permission from somebody else, and it is that dependence, rather than any material want, that she refuses to accept.
The principle by which the ending is defended. The custom is that the young touch the feet of God, of elders and of teachers. By naming her granddaughter a teacher, the grandmother places her inside the rule rather than breaking it, and appeals to scripture that requires a teacher to be honoured irrespective of gender and age.
The serialised novel is about an old lady who longs to make a pilgrimage and never makes it. The grandmother, who never reached that city either, recognises herself in the character — so the inner story supplies the mirror that explains her attachment to a magazine.
What Students Get Wrong
Did you know
Every one of the story's three big claims is spoken by the grandmother, not by the narrator — the child does the teaching and the old woman does the arguing.
The narrator condemns the feet-touching as not correct before her grandmother explains it, so the reader's objection is raised inside the story and then answered.
The writer, Sudha Murty, gives the narrator a future as a teacher of hundreds, which quietly turns one village pupil into the first of a very long line.
Memory tricks
The grandmother in four words — Deprived, honest, determined, humble. — Denied schooling; frank about her shame and her wealth; fixed on a deadline and working to it; and willing at the end to bow to a child.
The three claims of the story — Reading frees, age is no bar, respect follows the role. — Each is stated by the grandmother herself rather than by the narrator, which is why the story never sounds like a lecture.
Practice MCQs with answers (36)
- A She waited eagerly each week for the bus that carried the magazine
- B She identified herself closely with the main character of the novel
- C She had made sure that her children and grandchildren studied well
- D She could give back a whole instalment from memory after a single hearing
Show answer
Why:
Total recall of a heard text is evidence of an excellent mind, not a slow one.
- A Willing but forgetful
- B Wealthy but uninterested
- C Educated but out of practice
- D Deprived but capable
Show answer
Why:
The schooling was withheld from her; the ability was always there.
- A To reassure her granddaughter that lessons could easily be paid for
- B To rule out poverty as the cause and name independence as what she lacks
- C To explain why she had been able to buy the weekly magazine
- D To contrast her own childhood with the comfort of her old age
Show answer
Why:
She forestalls a misreading before it can happen.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The initiative is entirely hers; the child supplies only the teaching.
- A Listen, copy, memorise and test
- B Practise, revise, question and answer
- C Read, repeat, write and recite
- D Spell, pronounce, translate and explain
Show answer
Why:
The list conveys quantity of effort rather than any special method.
- A The grandmother identifies the problem, chooses the remedy and does the work herself
- B The grandmother had already begun learning before her granddaughter returned
- C The child refuses to help and the grandmother must find another teacher
- D The family arranges a tutor from the village school to take the lessons
Show answer
Why:
The child supplies lessons; every decision in the story is the grandmother's.
- A As gently warning her against disappointment
- B As childishly making fun of an old lady
- C As immediately admiring her grandmother's courage
- D As silently doubting whether the plan would work
Show answer
Why:
She judges her younger self without softening the judgement.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Remove the mockery and the contrast the ending depends on disappears.
- A It explains where she had learnt the teaching methods she used
- B It makes an illiterate woman of sixty-two the first pupil of a lifelong teacher
- C It shows that her grandmother's lessons determined her choice of profession
- D It proves that she had always intended to become a teacher of some kind
Show answer
Why:
One line quietly enlarges the scale of a small village episode.
- A Literacy is chiefly valuable because it allows people to enjoy novels
- B Literacy is the only reliable route out of poverty in a village
- C Literacy matters less than the memory and attention of the learner
- D Literacy is a form of independence that money cannot substitute for
Show answer
Why:
The family's wealth is stated precisely so that this point cannot be missed.
- A The narrator states the principle in her closing paragraph
- B A woman of sixty-two does the homework and meets her deadline
- C The grandmother's friends at the temple agree with her decision
- D The village schoolmaster confirms that adults may enrol
Show answer
Why:
The proof is in what happens, not in what anybody declares.
- A Parents, priests and teachers
- B God, elders and teachers
- C God, kings and parents
- D Elders, guests and priests
Show answer
Why:
The list matters because the ending turns on the third item.
- A It shows that the narrator had studied the scriptures more carefully than her grandmother
- B It lets the reader's own objection be raised inside the story, so the reply has something to answer
- C It delays the ending long enough for the rest of the family to gather round
- D It proves that the custom was unfamiliar to the villagers of that district
Show answer
Why:
An objection voiced first is what keeps the justification from sounding like a moral tacked on.
- A She argues that the custom is out of date and should be abandoned
- B She insists that her age entitles her to set aside the ordinary rule
- C She reclassifies the person, naming the girl a teacher rather than a granddaughter
- D She says that the act was a private one and so the rule does not apply
Show answer
Why:
The rule already covers teachers, so nothing has been broken.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
She rests it on what the scriptures require of anyone taught by another, not on her own case. The assertion holds, the reason is false.
- A Only where the teacher is older than the student
- B Only within the household where the teaching took place
- C Irrespective of gender and age
- D According to the length of time the teaching lasted
Show answer
Why:
The phrase is what makes a twelve-year-old girl eligible.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
She accepts it, and returns the namaskara by touching her grandmother's feet.
- A She protests and refuses to accept the gesture at all
- B She leaves the puja place without saying anything further
- C She calls the rest of the family to witness what has happened
- D She returns the namaskara by touching her grandmother's feet
Show answer
Why:
The gesture returned is her acceptance of what has happened.
- A Its plot is repeated exactly by the events in the narrator's household
- B Its author appears later in the story as a character in her own right
- C Its ending explains why the magazine reached the village a day late
- D Its old lady longs for a journey she never makes, which is the grandmother's own situation
Show answer
Why:
The inner story supplies the mirror that explains her attachment.
- A As idle curiosity rather than as recognition of her own life
- B As evidence that she had already learnt to read in secret
- C As proof that she disliked the company of her own family
- D As a sign that she had no other entertainment in the village
Show answer
Why:
The mirror is what raises a weekly habit into something that can change a life.
- A A detailed account of what the grandmother thought at every moment
- B An honest record of the narrator's own childish behaviour
- C A neutral description of village life free from personal feeling
- D A conclusion in which the narrator is shown to have been right
Show answer
Why:
A child could not judge herself so clearly, nor a distant narrator so forgivingly.
- A It avoids mentioning education anywhere in its closing paragraphs
- B Its narrator refuses to draw any conclusion from the events at all
- C It presents both sides of the question of whether adults should study
- D Its three main claims are spoken by the grandmother rather than by the narrator
Show answer
Why:
The character with the least schooling makes every argument.
- A The child does both the teaching and the arguing throughout
- B The child does the teaching while the old woman does the arguing
- C The old woman does both the teaching and the arguing throughout
- D Neither character argues; the narrator states the lesson directly
Show answer
Why:
That division is exactly what keeps the story from moralising.
- A They show that she had been badly treated by the rest of her family
- B They reveal that she had been ill during the week of the absence
- C They indicate that she had already decided to give up the serial
- D They measure how much the loss cost a woman not given to weeping
Show answer
Why:
Her usual composure is what makes the tears significant rather than ordinary.
- A A practical determination that turns a wish into a plan
- B A superstitious belief that only festival days bring success
- C An unwillingness to begin the work immediately
- D A desire to impress her friends at the temple courtyard
Show answer
Why:
A date, a standard and daily work are what separate a plan from an intention.
- A It proves that she had been secretly educated in religious texts
- B It shows that the narrator had taught her the scriptures during the lessons
- C The character with the least schooling makes the clearest case about learning
- D It suggests that she valued religion more highly than literacy
Show answer
Why:
The irony is deliberate and is part of the story's argument.
- A The narrator — patient and admirable from the very first page
- B The grandmother — resentful of the family's treatment of her
- C The narrator — reluctant to teach and needing to be persuaded
- D The grandmother — honest about her own embarrassment
Show answer
Why:
She reports her shame instead of hiding it, which is a mark of strength.
- A It separates them, showing that a well-off woman may still be dependent
- B It joins them, showing that wealth is what finally bought her the lessons
- C It ignores wealth entirely and concentrates on the village's poverty
- D It argues that only the wealthy have the leisure to learn as adults
Show answer
Why:
The separation is the whole point of her question about the use of money.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The narrator is the granddaughter herself, writing in the first person.
- A The description of the bus that brought the post to the village
- B The mention of the grandmother's friends at the temple courtyard
- C The narrator's admission that she laughed at her grandmother
- D The detail that the gift was a piece of frock material
Show answer
Why:
The ending measures the grandmother's dignity against that mockery.
- A She blames her father and stepmother for denying her an education
- B She regards it as too painful to speak about even to her granddaughter
- C She explains it without blaming anyone, and treats it as a reason to act now
- D She insists that her generation was right not to educate its girls
Show answer
Why:
She reports the circumstances plainly and moves straight to her decision.
- A It promises a guide to teaching adults which the story then supplies
- B It is ironic, since the grandmother in fact teaches herself without help
- C It refers to the novel Kashi Yatre rather than to the alphabet
- D It names the narrator's role but the story's real subject is her grandmother's resolve
Show answer
Why:
The narrator gives the lessons, but every decision belongs to the old woman.
- A Only those who have been formally trained for the work
- B Only those older than the person being taught
- C Anyone who teaches, whatever their age or gender
- D Only members of the learner's own household
Show answer
Why:
The phrase about gender and age is what admits a twelve-year-old girl.
- A That children should be more patient with the elderly members of a family
- B That village life was harder before transport and newspapers improved
- C That reading is freedom, that age is no barrier to it, and that teaching earns respect
- D That magazine serials were once the chief entertainment of rural India
Show answer
Why:
Three claims, all of them spoken by the grandmother herself.
- A The serial is never described in enough detail to be the subject
- B The serial is the occasion; the subject is what illiteracy costs an intelligent adult
- C The serial ends before the events of the story have finished
- D The serial belongs to the grandmother's friends rather than to her
Show answer
Why:
Remove the serial and the need remains; remove the illiteracy and there is no story.
- A That she had waited eagerly for her granddaughter to return from the wedding
- B That the family was well-off but she could not read the magazine
- C That she honours a teacher rather than a granddaughter, whom scripture requires be respected whatever their gender and age
- D That she would work harder than anybody to learn the alphabet
Show answer
Why:
It contains both the reclassification and the authority that supports it.
Important short questions (6)
She set aside all her work to listen, followed each instalment with complete attention, and could afterwards repeat the whole of it from memory. She then debated it confidently with her friends. Memory, attention and judgement were therefore all intact, and the only thing she lacked was the alphabet, which her generation had not thought girls needed.
She raises it in order to rule it out. Without that sentence her complaint might be mistaken for one about hardship, and she wants the real loss named exactly. What she has lost is the power to reach a printed page unaided, and she asks what use money can be when it cannot make her independent.
She stayed a week at a wedding when she meant to stay two days, and she made fun of her grandmother's grey hair, wrinkled hands and spectacles, calling this childish. The admissions strengthen the story because the grandmother's dignity is measured against them, and because an adult judging her younger self is easier to trust.
The custom is that the young touch the feet of God, of elders and of teachers. The grandmother does not claim an exception; she reclassifies the person, saying she honours a teacher rather than a granddaughter and appealing to scripture that requires a teacher to be respected irrespective of gender and age. The girl has become someone the rule already covers.
The serialised novel concerns an old lady who longs to make a pilgrimage and never makes it. The grandmother had never reached that city either, so she recognises her own life in the character. Without that mirror her hunger for each instalment would look like idle curiosity rather than something capable of changing how she lived.
Because the character with the least schooling then makes the clearest case for what schooling is worth, which is a pointed irony. It also keeps the story from moralising: the child does the teaching while the old woman does the arguing, so the lesson arrives as a person's conviction rather than as the author's comment.
Long answer questions (3)
She is, first, deprived rather than incapable. Before she learns a letter she listens with total concentration, repeats a whole instalment from memory and argues about it with her friends. Her mind was never the obstacle; her generation simply did not think girls needed schooling.
She is honest, and in two directions. She admits she was too embarrassed to ask a neighbour to read to her, which is not a flattering thing to confess. She also states that her family is well-off, ruling out in advance any misreading of her complaint as poverty.
She is clear-sighted about what she has lost. Not comfort and not security, but independence — the power to reach a page without depending on anyone.
She is determined in a practical way. She decides what to learn, when to begin, by when to finish and how success will be judged, and then reads, repeats, writes and recites until the amount of homework astonishes her teacher.
She is dignified under mockery. Laughed at for her age, she does not defend her pride but makes a claim about learning instead.
And she is humble enough to bow to a child, yet precise about why — she honours a teacher, on an authority higher than her own feelings.
It makes three claims. The first is that literacy is independence: the household wants for nothing, and what the grandmother cannot do is reach a printed page by herself, which she refuses to accept. The second is that learning has no age bar, a claim the plot demonstrates rather than asserts, since a woman of sixty-two does the homework while the literate child of twelve has to be corrected. The third is that respect follows the role rather than the years.
What keeps it from lecturing is the distribution of voices. Every one of these claims is spoken by the grandmother — the character with the least schooling — and none by the narrator. The child does the teaching; the old woman does the arguing.
The method is demonstration rather than statement. We are shown her recall and her debating before we are told anything about her ability, so the conclusion is one the reader has already drawn.
The ending is handled the same way. The narrator voices the reader's objection, calling the reversal not correct, and only then does the grandmother answer it by naming the girl a teacher and appealing to scripture.
Because the argument is answered inside the story, nothing has to be added at the end, and the last line is not a moral but a verdict: the student had passed.
The ending is built in three deliberate movements.
First the reversal. At the puja place the grandmother seats her granddaughter, gives her cloth for a frock, and then bends down and touches her feet.
Then the objection, and it is the narrator who raises it. She is taken aback and states the custom plainly: the young touch the feet of God, of elders and of teachers, and elders do not touch the feet of youngsters. She calls the act not correct. This is the reader's own objection, and placing it inside the story means the explanation will be answering something real rather than defending a point nobody disputed.
Then the justification. The grandmother does not ask for an exception, which would leave the custom damaged. She reclassifies the person instead: she is honouring a teacher and not a granddaughter — one who taught her so well and so affectionately that she can now read confidently. She adds the authority: scripture requires a teacher to be respected irrespective of gender and age.
The result is that nothing has been broken. The girl has become one of the three kinds of person the rule already names.
The narrator's response confirms it. She returns the gesture and hands over her gift, and the old woman reads its title and publisher at once — so the argument ends with a demonstration rather than with the last word.
Flashcards (20)
Play this topic
- Match the Quality to Its Evidence
- True or False: Characters and Themes
- Complete the Statement
- Unscramble the Critical Words
The Language and Skills Work of This Lesson
A lesson in Kaveri does not stop at the story. This unit also asks you to notice a particular kind of fixed phrase, to build opposites with prefixes, to collect idioms about studying, to use one tense correctly against another, to listen to a talk on digital literacy, to argue both sides of a question in turn, and to write a formal letter to a newspaper. This topic covers all of it.
What you will be able to do
- Define a binomial and use the ones this unit lists.
- Form opposites using the prefixes the unit introduces.
- Explain the idioms of learning collected in this lesson.
- Use the past perfect correctly alongside the simple past.
- Describe the Turncoat speaking format and the structure of a letter to the editor.
Key points
A binomial is an expression of two words, usually joined by a conjunction such as and or or, which are habitually used together in a fixed order; the story supplies hide and seek.
The binomials this unit collects include sink or swim, on and off, mix and match, all or nothing, part and parcel, pick and choose, sooner or later, and leaps and bounds.
Prefixes such as un-, ir-, in-, im-, dis- and mis- reverse or negate a meaning, and the story itself supplies unhappy, unusual, unfortunately, irrespective and independent.
The idioms of learning gathered here are to hit the books, to draw a blank, to learn the ropes, to rack one's brain, to learn by heart and to burn the midnight oil.
The story ends on a further idiom, to pass with flying colours, which means to perform outstandingly.
The past perfect marks the earlier of two completed past actions while the more recent one takes the simple past, as in the pairing of bought with had passed.
The listening passage argues that literacy now includes using digital tools responsibly, and names the Digital Saksharta Abhiyan, or National Digital Literacy Mission, which imparts IT training across the country.
Turncoat is a solo debate in which one speaker argues for a motion and then, at a signal, argues against it; the writing task is a letter to the editor in at least three paragraphs.
Full explanation
Why a Lesson Has a Second Half
The story ends when the grandmother reads the title of her gift. The unit does not. It goes on to ask you to look closely at particular words, to fix one point of grammar, to listen to a talk, to argue a case both ways and to write a formal letter.
That second half is not an appendix. Almost all of it grows out of the story, and in one case the lesson explains its own last sentence.
Binomials
In the story the children gather in the temple courtyard to play hide and seek. That phrase is a binomial.
A binomial is an expression of two words, usually linked by a conjunction such as and or or, which are commonly used together in a fixed order.
The fixed order is the point. Hide and seek is correct; seek and hide would be understood but sounds broken. Nothing about the meaning requires the order — usage does.
The unit collects eight more, each with its meaning:
| Binomial | Meaning |
|---|---|
| sink or swim | succeed or fail without help |
| on and off | sometimes, occasionally |
| mix and match | put different things together to get a range of possibilities |
| all or nothing | something to be done completely or not at all |
| part and parcel | a necessary part of something, or belonging to it |
| pick and choose | select only the best |
| sooner or later | at some time in the future |
| leaps and bounds | increasing or developing very quickly |
Prefixes That Reverse a Meaning
The second exercise starts from five words that occur in the story: unhappy, unusual, unfortunately, irrespective, independent.
Each is built by putting a prefix in front of a word to give it an opposite or negative sense. The prefixes in play are un-, im-, dis-, in-, mis- and extra-.
The work is to attach the right one, which is a matter of the word, not of choice:
- popular → unpopular
- belief → disbelief
- important → unimportant
- respect → disrespect
- correct → incorrect
- continue → discontinue
- understand → misunderstand
- ordinary → extraordinary
- interesting → uninteresting
- possible → impossible
Notice extraordinary. The prefix there does not negate at all — it intensifies. That is a reminder that a prefix changes meaning in whatever direction the prefix itself carries.
Idioms of Learning
The story's final sentence contains an idiom: the student had passed with flying colours, which means an outstanding performance.
The unit gathers six more, all about study:
| Idiom | Meaning |
|---|---|
| to hit the books | to study seriously |
| to draw a blank | to be unable to remember |
| to learn the ropes | to understand how to do an activity |
| to rack one's brain | to think very hard |
| to learn by heart | to memorise something |
| to burn the midnight oil | to study or work late into the night |
One of these describes the grandmother exactly. She could learn by heart long before she could read a word.
The Grammar Point: Past Perfect
The unit takes two sentences from the story and asks you to look at the verbs.
In the first, the narrator bought the novel — a simple past.
In the second, her student had passed with flying colours — a past perfect.
The rule: we use the past perfect for two completed actions, where one happened earlier and the other more recently. The more recent action is in the simple past; the earlier action takes the past perfect.
Two examples from the lesson show the shape:
- By the time I reached the party, everyone had finished eating.
- When she returned home, her brother had finished the project.
In both, the had form is the thing that happened first, even though it is mentioned second. That is precisely what the tense is for — it keeps the order of events straight when the sentence does not report them in order.
Listen and Respond: Digital Literacy
The listening passage is a short talk. Its argument runs like this.
Literacy once meant simply reading and writing. It now also takes in being able to handle digital tools well and responsibly: getting at information, making it and passing it on through technology — and it is not only about handling gadgets, but about understanding platforms, identifying reliable sources, and protecting personal data.
The speaker then gives three reasons it matters.
It empowers individuals. Students research critically, professionals handle digital transactions, and senior citizens stay connected.
It promotes safe internet use, by helping people recognise misinformation, scams and cyber threats.
It prepares us for a digital future, in which skills in online services, job applications and governance are essential.
The conclusion is blunt: being digitally literate is no longer optional but a necessity. And the talk ends by naming the scheme — the Digital Saksharta Abhiyan (DISHA), also called the National Digital Literacy Mission (NDLM), formulated to impart IT training to people across the country.
It is worth seeing why this passage sits beside this story. Both are about the meaning of literacy widening, and about what it costs a person to be left outside it — the grandmother with a magazine she cannot read, and a senior citizen today who cannot use the services everyone else uses.
Speaking: Turncoat
Turncoat is a solo debate. One speaker argues both sides of a topic, switching after a set time.
The procedure is fixed: begin by speaking for the topic for one minute; the teacher signals; then speak against it for one minute.
The two topics offered are whether it is important to learn a language besides your mother tongue, and whether learning can happen only when you are young. The second is the story's own question, put to the class.
The unit supplies openings for each side — phrases like to begin with, my first argument in favour of, and most importantly I want to mention that for the case in favour; and on the contrary, there are two sides to this topic, and if I could make a point here for the case against.
The skill being tested is not victory. It is the ability to state a case you may not hold, which is why the speaker has to change sides mid-way.
Writing: A Letter to the Editor
The writing task asks for a letter to the editor of a local newspaper about students helping with adult literacy camps.
A letter to the editor is written formally, and in it the writer offers suggestions or raises awareness on a matter of public interest, or responds to something already published.
The format:
- name, designation and address
- date
- subject: four or five words, in title case
- salutation: Sir or Madam
- body: at least three paragraphs
- complimentary close: Yours truly
The three paragraphs each do a different job.
Paragraph 1 — state the problem. Raise the issue by citing a recent news item, a survey report or personal experience.
Paragraph 2 — analyse it. Set out causes and consequences.
Paragraph 3 — offer solutions. Suggest what could be done, ask the relevant authorities to act, and ask the editor to publish.
The language should be formal, clear and specific, in short sentences that come to the point, stating the purpose plainly and giving only relevant detail.
Learning Beyond the Text
The unit closes by widening out. India has 22 major languages listed in the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution, and the exercise asks you to collect the words for grandmother, grandfather, mother, father, sister and brother in five of them — beginning with the story's own Avva.
It also names the institutions behind different kinds of literacy: the National Literacy Mission Authority and the Directorate of Adult Education for adult education; the National Centre for Financial Education for financial literacy; the Early Literacy Project for out-of-school and under-achieving children; and the Centre for Cultural Resources and Training for cultural literacy.
Each of these is the grandmother's problem, handled at the scale of a country.
Concepts and terms
An expression made of two words, usually linked by a conjunction such as and or or, which are commonly used together and in a settled order. The order cannot be swapped: one says hide and seek, never seek and hide. The story supplies that example when the children play in the temple courtyard.
A syllable placed before a word to reverse or negate its meaning. This unit works with un-, ir-, in-, im-, dis- and mis-, and draws its examples straight from the story, where unhappy, unusual, unfortunately, irrespective and independent all appear.
The tense used for the earlier of two completed actions in the past. The action that happened first takes the past perfect and the one that happened later takes the simple past, so that the order of events is clear even when the sentence does not report them in order.
A speaking format in which a single speaker argues a motion in both directions. The speaker begins in favour for a fixed time, switches sides when the teacher signals, and then argues against for the same length of time, so that the exercise tests the ability to see a case from both sides.
What Students Get Wrong
Did you know
The idiom the story closes on — passing with flying colours — is taught later in the same unit, so the lesson quietly explains its own last line.
The talk on digital literacy argues that the meaning of the word literacy has itself changed, which is the same claim the story makes about what it costs not to be able to read.
Turncoat forces a speaker to argue against a case they have just been making, so the exercise is less about winning than about understanding.
Memory tricks
What makes a binomial — Two words, one conjunction, no swapping. — If the pair can be reversed without sounding wrong, it is not a binomial. The fixed order is the test.
Which action takes the past perfect — Earlier gets had. — Of two completed past actions, the one further back takes had plus the past participle, and the nearer one takes the plain simple past.
Practice MCQs with answers (36)
- A A binomial must always be joined by the conjunction or rather than and
- B A binomial has a fixed order, so the two words cannot be reversed
- C A binomial must contain two nouns, and seek is a verb
- D A binomial cannot be drawn from the vocabulary of a children's game
Show answer
Why:
Usage, not meaning, fixes the order of the pair.
- A Two words of opposite meaning placed together for contrast in a sentence
- B Two words that rhyme and are used together for emphasis in speech
- C Two words of which the second repeats the first with a small change
- D Two words, usually joined by a conjunction, commonly used together in a fixed order
Show answer
Why:
The conjunction and the settled order are both part of the definition.
- A Mix and match
- B Part and parcel
- C On and off
- D Sink or swim
Show answer
Why:
The phrase means succeeding or failing without help.
- A Pick and choose — to select only the best
- B All or nothing — to do something occasionally
- C Sooner or later — to combine different possibilities
- D Leaps and bounds — a necessary part of something
Show answer
Why:
The other three have each been given the wrong meaning.
- A All or nothing
- B By leaps and bounds
- C Part and parcel
- D Sink or swim
Show answer
Why:
The phrase is reserved for rapid increase or development.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Unhappy, unusual and unfortunately take un-; irrespective takes ir- and independent takes in-.
- A un-
- B im-
- C dis-
- D mis-
Show answer
Why:
The prefix has to suit the word, and possible takes im-.
- A The right prefix is decided by the word, and these take dis- and im- instead
- B Neither word may take a prefix of any kind in standard English
- C Both words need the prefix mis- rather than any other
- D The prefix should follow the word rather than precede it
Show answer
Why:
Prefixing is not a free choice; each word selects its own.
- A Its prefix is attached to a verb rather than to an adjective
- B Its prefix intensifies the word instead of negating it
- C It is the only word in the list that occurs in the story
- D It takes a hyphen where the other words in the list do not
Show answer
Why:
A prefix shifts meaning in whatever direction the prefix itself carries.
- A To hit the books
- B To learn the ropes
- C To draw a blank
- D To burn the midnight oil
Show answer
Why:
The blank is the empty space where the memory should be.
- A Learning the ropes
- B Drawing a blank
- C Racking her brain
- D Learning by heart
Show answer
Why:
The idiom is about coming to understand an activity.
- A To hit the books
- B To rack one's brain
- C To burn the midnight oil
- D To learn by heart
Show answer
Why:
She could give back a whole instalment from memory without reading a word.
- A Drawing a blank
- B Burning the midnight oil
- C Picking and choosing
- D Learning the ropes
Show answer
Why:
The phrase survives from a time when late study meant an oil lamp.
- A It means a narrow escape, and the unit never explains it at all
- B It means an outstanding performance, and the unit goes on to teach the idiom it has just used
- C It means a long delay, and the unit lists it among the binomials
- D It means an honest failure, and the unit corrects it in the grammar section
Show answer
Why:
The lesson quietly explains its own closing line.
- A Of two completed past actions, the earlier takes the past perfect and the later the simple past
- B Of two completed past actions, the later takes the past perfect and the earlier the simple past
- C Any action in the past may take the past perfect if it is important to the speaker
- D The past perfect is used only when no other past tense appears in the sentence
Show answer
Why:
Earlier gets had; the nearer event stays in the plain simple past.
- A The arrival at the party, because it is mentioned first in the sentence
- B Both happened at exactly the same moment
- C The order cannot be worked out from the sentence as written
- D The finishing of the eating, because it is in the past perfect
Show answer
Why:
Mentioned second, but marked by had as the earlier of the two.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
That is precisely the job the tense exists to do.
- A The sense that the two events happened on the same day
- B The sense that the brother was working on a project at all
- C The sense that the brother finished before she arrived, which needs the past perfect
- D Nothing at all, since both verbs are correctly in the past
Show answer
Why:
Putting both in the simple past collapses the order of events.
- A It once included digital skills and has since narrowed to reading and writing
- B It has always meant the same thing and is simply taught differently now
- C It once meant reading and writing and now includes using digital tools responsibly
- D It now refers only to the ability to identify reliable sources online
Show answer
Why:
The widening of the word is the talk's opening move.
- A Buying devices, repairing them and disposing of them safely
- B Learning to type, to print and to scan printed documents
- C Registering for schemes, paying taxes and applying for licences
- D Understanding platforms, identifying reliable sources and protecting personal data
Show answer
Why:
The speaker is careful to say it is not only about using gadgets.
- A School students
- B Factory workers
- C Government officials
- D Senior citizens
Show answer
Why:
Students research critically and professionals handle transactions; seniors stay connected.
- A Viruses, power failures and hardware faults
- B Advertising, spam and unwanted subscriptions
- C Piracy, plagiarism and copyright breaches
- D Misinformation, scams and cyber threats
Show answer
Why:
These come under the heading of promoting safe internet use.
- A National Literacy Mission Authority and Directorate of Adult Education, providing schooling
- B Early Literacy Project and Centre for Cultural Resources, providing teacher training
- C National Centre for Financial Education and NDLM, providing banking services
- D Digital Saksharta Abhiyan and National Digital Literacy Mission, providing IT training
Show answer
Why:
DISHA and NDLM are two names for one scheme imparting IT training across the country.
- A Both are set in villages in north Karnataka during the same period
- B Both are narrated by a granddaughter describing an elderly relative
- C Both are about the meaning of literacy widening and the cost of being left outside it
- D Both end by naming a government scheme for adult education
Show answer
Why:
A grandmother with an unreadable magazine and a senior citizen without digital skills are the same problem.
- A A team debate in which each side has exactly one minute to speak
- B A discussion in which the audience decides the topic before it begins
- C A solo debate in which one speaker argues for a topic and then against it
- D A written exercise in which two opposing letters are composed
Show answer
Why:
One speaker, both sides, with a signal to switch.
- A Whether learning can happen only when you are young
- B Whether it is important to learn a language besides your mother tongue
- C Whether magazines should be delivered daily to villages
- D Whether elders should be taught by younger family members
Show answer
Why:
The grandmother settles that question in practice; the class argues it in theory.
- A The ability to speak for longer than any other student
- B The ability to state a case you may not personally hold
- C The ability to memorise a prepared speech word for word
- D The ability to defeat an opponent in open argument
Show answer
Why:
Switching sides mid-way makes winning beside the point.
- A To begin with, I would like to speak for the topic
- B My first argument in favour of this is
- C On the contrary, there are two sides to this topic
- D Most importantly, I want to mention that
Show answer
Why:
The other three belong to the case in favour.
- A An informal letter to a friend describing a recent news story
- B A formal letter offering suggestions or raising awareness on a matter of public interest
- C A letter of complaint sent privately to a government department
- D A letter of application seeking employment with a newspaper
Show answer
Why:
It may also respond to something already published.
- A Offer solutions, state the problem, thank the editor for publishing
- B Describe yourself, state the problem, list the sources you consulted
- C State the problem, analyse causes and consequences, offer solutions
- D Analyse causes, describe the newspaper, request a reply by post
Show answer
Why:
Each paragraph has a distinct job, in that order.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The close is Yours truly; affectionate closes belong to personal letters.
- A Informal and conversational, so that ordinary readers are not put off
- B Elaborate and literary, to show command of the language
- C Formal, clear and specific, in short sentences that come to the point
- D Technical and detailed, with as much background as possible
Show answer
Why:
Purpose stated concisely, with only relevant detail.
- A The close should be Yours sincerely, and the date should be omitted entirely
- B The close is correct, but the letter needs five paragraphs rather than three
- C The close is correct, and only the salutation Sir or Madam is missing
- D The complimentary close should be Yours truly, and a subject line in title case is required
Show answer
Why:
Both belong to the formal format the unit sets out.
- A 18
- B 22
- C 15
- D 28
Show answer
Why:
The exercise asks for family words from five of them.
- A The National Literacy Mission Authority
- B The National Centre for Financial Education
- C The Early Literacy Project
- D The Centre for Cultural Resources and Training
Show answer
Why:
The Directorate of Adult Education facilitates the programmes it designs.
- A National Centre for Financial Education — digital literacy
- B Early Literacy Project — adult literacy in villages
- C Centre for Cultural Resources and Training — cultural literacy
- D National Literacy Mission Authority — financial literacy
Show answer
Why:
The Early Literacy Project targets out-of-school and under-achieving children.
Important short questions (6)
A binomial is an expression of two words, usually joined by a conjunction such as and or or, which are habitually used together in a fixed order that cannot be reversed. The story supplies hide and seek. Two others are sink or swim, meaning to succeed or fail without help, and by leaps and bounds, meaning to develop very quickly.
A prefix such as un-, im-, dis-, in- or mis- is placed before a word to give it an opposite or negative sense, as in unhappy and independent from the story. The choice is fixed by the word itself: respect takes dis-, possible takes im- and understand takes mis-, so unrespect and unpossible are both wrong.
Where two past actions are both completed, the earlier one takes the past perfect and the more recent takes the simple past. In the sentence about reaching the party, everyone had finished eating before the speaker arrived, so had finished is past perfect while reached is simple past, even though the arrival is mentioned first.
Literacy once meant reading and writing and now also covers using digital tools responsibly — accessing, creating and sharing information, judging sources and protecting personal data. It matters because it empowers individuals, promotes safe internet use against misinformation, scams and cyber threats, and prepares people for a digital future.
A single speaker argues one topic in both directions, beginning in favour for a minute, switching when the teacher signals, then speaking against for a minute. What it tests is not the ability to win but the ability to state a case the speaker may not personally hold, since the sides are changed mid-way.
It opens with the writer's name, designation and address, then the date, then a subject line of four or five words in title case, then the salutation Sir or Madam. The body runs to at least three paragraphs stating the problem, analysing it, and offering solutions with a request to publish. It closes with Yours truly.
Long answer questions (3)
The unit works on three kinds of expression, and each begins from a word actually used in the story.
The first is the binomial: two words, usually joined by a conjunction, habitually used together in an order that cannot be reversed. The story supplies hide and seek, from the children's game in the temple courtyard. Eight more are collected with their meanings, among them sink or swim for succeeding or failing unaided, part and parcel for something inseparable from a whole, and by leaps and bounds for very rapid development.
The second is the negating prefix. Five words in the story already carry one: unhappy, unusual, unfortunately, irrespective and independent. The exercise then asks for the right prefix to be attached to ten further words, and the point is that the choice is not free. Respect takes dis-, possible takes im- and understand takes mis-, while extraordinary is the odd case in which the prefix intensifies rather than negates.
The third is the idiom, and here the connection is closest of all. The story's final sentence says the student had passed with flying colours, meaning an outstanding performance, and the unit then teaches six idioms about studying — hitting the books, drawing a blank, learning the ropes, racking one's brain, learning by heart and burning the midnight oil.
One of those describes the grandmother precisely. Long before she could read a word she could learn by heart.
The unit isolates the past perfect by setting two sentences from the story side by side. In the first the narrator bought the novel, which is a simple past. In the second her student had passed with flying colours, which is a past perfect.
The rule is this. Where two actions in the past are both complete, the earlier of them takes the past perfect and the more recent takes the simple past.
Two model sentences show the shape. By the time the speaker reached the party, everyone had finished eating. When she returned home, her brother had finished the project.
Notice what is happening in both. The event marked by had is mentioned second but happened first. That is the whole usefulness of the tense: it carries the order of events inside the verb, so the sentence is free to report them in whatever order reads best.
Collapse both verbs into the simple past and that information is lost. To write that the brother finished the project when she returned home suggests that he finished as she walked in, which is a different claim altogether.
For a reader this matters because stories rarely tell events in strict order. A narrator who is remembering, as this one is, constantly reaches backwards, and the past perfect is the signal that allows a reader to place each event correctly without being told explicitly.
The listening passage is a talk on digital literacy. It argues that literacy once meant reading and writing and now also includes using digital tools effectively and responsibly, which involves understanding platforms, judging reliable sources and protecting personal data. Three reasons are given for its importance: it empowers individuals, since students research critically, professionals handle transactions and senior citizens stay connected. It promotes safe use by helping people recognise misinformation, scams and cyber threats. And it prepares people for a future in which online services, job applications and governance all demand such skills. The talk ends by naming the Digital Saksharta Abhiyan, or National Digital Literacy Mission, which imparts IT training across the country. The speaking task is Turncoat, a solo debate in which one speaker argues a motion in favour for a minute, switches at the teacher's signal, and then argues against it. One of the topics offered asks whether learning can happen only when you are young. The writing task is a letter to the editor about students helping at adult literacy camps, written formally in at least three paragraphs: the problem, its causes and consequences, then solutions and a request to publish. All three return to the story's subject. The talk widens the meaning of literacy exactly as the story widens what reading is for; the debate topic is the question the grandmother settles in practice; and the letter concerns adult literacy, which is what she was.
Flashcards (20)
Play this topic
- Match the Expression to Its Meaning
- True or False: Words and Grammar
- Complete the Statement
- Unscramble the Language Words
Class 9 English Chapter 1 — frequently asked questions
Transport was poor, so the morning paper came only in the afternoon and the weekly magazine a day late, and everyone waited for the bus that carried them. In a place where news arrived like that, the next instalment of a serial became the event of the week, which is why the grandmother cared about it so deeply.
An old lady longs to reach Kashi and worship Lord Vishweshwara there, while a young orphan girl in the same story has no money for her wedding, and the old lady ends by handing over everything she has put by and never goes. The grandmother had never been to Kashi either, so she identified herself with the character.
She found her grandmother in tears. It surprised her because she had never seen the old woman cry even in the most difficult situations, so weeping was entirely out of character. When asked whether anything was wrong, her grandmother only nodded and gave no answer, and the child forgot about it until that night.
She set aside all her work to listen, followed each instalment with complete attention, and could afterwards repeat the whole of it from memory. She then debated it confidently with her friends. Memory, attention and judgement were therefore all intact, and the only thing she lacked was the alphabet, which her generation had not thought girls needed.
She raises it in order to rule it out. Without that sentence her complaint might be mistaken for one about hardship, and she wants the real loss named exactly. What she has lost is the power to reach a printed page unaided, and she asks what use money can be when it cannot make her independent.
She stayed a week at a wedding when she meant to stay two days, and she made fun of her grandmother's grey hair, wrinkled hands and spectacles, calling this childish. The admissions strengthen the story because the grandmother's dignity is measured against them, and because an adult judging her younger self is easier to trust.
A binomial is an expression of two words, usually joined by a conjunction such as and or or, which are habitually used together in a fixed order that cannot be reversed. The story supplies hide and seek. Two others are sink or swim, meaning to succeed or fail without help, and by leaps and bounds, meaning to develop very quickly.
A prefix such as un-, im-, dis-, in- or mis- is placed before a word to give it an opposite or negative sense, as in unhappy and independent from the story. The choice is fixed by the word itself: respect takes dis-, possible takes im- and understand takes mis-, so unrespect and unpossible are both wrong.
Where two past actions are both completed, the earlier one takes the past perfect and the more recent takes the simple past. In the sentence about reaching the party, everyone had finished eating before the speaker arrived, so had finished is past perfect while reached is simple past, even though the arrival is mentioned first.
All Class 9 English chapters
All English chapters · Every Class 9 subject · The whole NCERT library
Study this chapter properly, free
Everything above is on this page to read. In the Veda app the same chapter becomes spaced-repetition flashcards, timed tests that mark themselves, Veda Bites you can swipe, and games — with your progress tracked topic by topic.
Get Veda free